concordtom said:
SFCityBear said:
concordtom said:
Our 2009-10 roster
Player
Jerome Randle
Patrick Christopher
Jamal Boykin
Theo Robertson
Jorge Gutierrez
Omondi Amoke
Markhuri Sanders-Frison
Max Zhang
Nikola Knezevic
D.J. Seeley
Brandon Smith
Nigel Carter
Bak Bak
Was this the year that Omoke was excused at the end of season? (Yes)
So, Max (7'3" SOPH) played a bit (in 27 games and avg 10.7 mins).
We had two other "bigs": JR Markhuri Sanders-Frison at 6'7" and SR Jamal Boykin at 6'8".
Jordan Wilkes (5th year SR at 7'0") would have been a major upgrade over Max.
Jordan Wilkes was one of your favorite players. We get that. We also need to understand that memories of our favorite players can get more rosy over time.
My impression of Jordan Wilkes was that he was a nice kid, but a below average center. My memory of him was starting games, and being pulled after just a few minutes, as Braun was wont to to with a lot of players. Ben had a quick hook. I believe Jordan started those 32 games because he was 7'-0" tall and gave Cal the best chance to win the center jump at the start of each game. Both Boykin and Harper Kamp were much better basketball players than Jordan. Both were also more aggressive than Jordan. I don't see any upgrade for Jordan over Max. On a per minute basis their rebounding and scoring stats are just about equal, but Max was a shot blocker, which Jordan was not. I too was disappointed when Jordan did not return for his last season, because he had been improving a little. But as it turned out, with both Boykin and MSF ahead of him, he would have played little, probably splitting minutes with Max.
Omar Wilkes, on the other hand, was a very good player who would have helped almost any Cal team I've seen over the years.
As to Amoke, you are being very politically correct when you say he was "excused." When Sandy met with Mike Montgomery to discuss possible punishments for Amoke, Montgomery reportedly told her that "Amoke will never play for me again. Period." Or words to that effect. Amoke was kicked off the team, plain and simple.
False assertions, SFC
I never said he was my favorite, and I don't know why you feel the need to get edgy on me.
All I was doing was recalling the season, the team, etc. Sorry to bore you with that.
I did say he would have been a major upgrade, and that was likely too strong a compare. He would have been a very good upgrade, not "major". I was definitely NOT a fan of max. He couldn't catch the goddam ball if you dropped it into the post for him.
And you are correct in saying that Jordan was improving. By the end, he was hitting 10 foot jumpers and had begun to harness his game. By the senior season, I suspect he wouldn't have split with max but mostly owned Max. But, yes, he was not a major center. You are correct that he tipped and subbed out quickly, but recall my prior stats - he played 17.8 mins per game, and that's more than jumping for the tip.
I had hopes for further improvement for Jordan in 2010, which would have really helped (in my eyes). He failed to return and left us with 6'7", 6'8", and clumsy Max. Let's admit it, Max sucked!
We can agree to disagree, but then allow me to fantasy draft against you for money.
You didn't say Jordan was your favorite, and neither did I. I said he was ONE of your favorites, because you implied that when you pumped him up beyond what his performance ever showed, for me, at least. I'm not getting "edgy" on you, just trying to be reasonable and stick with what the stats show, and what my eyes told me when I saw him play.
I don't remember the ten foot jumpers. Jordan averaged less than two buckets a game in his last year, so I guess I missed seeing them. Did you know that In his first 2 seasons he made 5 out of 13 three point attempts, pretty darn good for a seven footer, but only had one attempt in his last season? Braun should have had him out on the perimeter more.
You neglected to mention that there was a coaching change from 2009 to 2010 from Braun to Montgomery. Wilkes was not going to supplant Boykin or MSF, no way. They were both studs, and if MSF had not been playing with injuries and needing rest, neither Max or Jordan would have seen even the 11 minutes Max got. As for who Montgomery would have preferred, I can't say. Max dropped the ball, as you said, but when he did hold on to it, he shot the ball better than Jordan, 63% to 51%. Jordan shot free throws much better, 80% to 50%. They rebounded and scored about the same on a per minute basis. Max blocked 37 shots in his last season, and Jordan blocked 14 in his last season, but on a per minute basis, Max blocked OVER FIVE TIMES as many shots as Jordan Wilkes.
So I guess that if I am the coach and MSF needs a rest, I'd live with the turnovers and the missed free throws, and go with the shot blocker and play Max Zhang before I'd play Jordan Wilkes. But I'm not the coach. Instead, it is Montgomery and Braun who made millions doing that, and you and I sit here with nothing better to do than argue about a couple of Cal's long gone third string centers. How ridiculous is that?
PS: I'd think that Wyking Jones would be happy to have either Max or Jordan this coming season, based on the current roster.