BearDevil;842293456 said:
Sounds like heresy, but Baker's the more valuable college swimmer than Ledecky. Katie's below NCAA record times in the 500 and 1650 and is a high A scorer in the 200 free, but she's only an 800 free relay swimmer for the top teams. Baker's versatile enough to be competitive in 7 to 9 individual events and can swim on four relays.
[FONT="Times New Roman"][SIZE="3"][COLOR="RoyalBlue"]Oh definitely! In the international arena and especially in the longer pool, there's no question that Katie & Missy currently towers above practically all their global competitors in their area of specialization - Ledecky in the [U]400[/U], [U]800[/U], [U]1500[/U] frees, the
WR holder in the latter 2 of these races...Missy in the [U]200 back[/U] (
WR in LCM + SCM), and to a lesser extent, the [U]100 back[/U] as she does have a bit of competition with Emily Seebohm from AUS there.
They both are also versatile enough to be a force to be reckoned with when venturing outside their typical events:
1)
Katie = 2nd fastest American and #9 world-ranked in the 200m free last year, not to mention swimming the fastest leadoff leg in the 4x200 free relay finals in Barcelona.
2)
Missy being put to work by Teri on the [U]500[/U] to become a top contender @ NCAAs in an event she's not known for. Also her "2nd best" stroke being good enough to claim the [U]200 free[/U] world champs title in 2013...going back to 2011 Worlds in Shanghai, where Missy swam a significantly faster split from her leadoff leg of the 4x200 relay than Federica Pellegrini's gold medal time in the 200 free individual!
Even when one considers SCY, Katie's [COLOR="Red"]4:28.71 AR[/COLOR] in the [U]500 free[/U] achieved last month is almost
6 seconds quicker than frosh Leah Smith's current top NCAA time of 4:34.35. That NCAA-leading time of Leah's from ACCs is itself 2 secs faster than her HS PB! Missy had swum a 4:34.63 back at Winter Nationals, which is at present good for #2 in NCAAs, shared with Brittany MacLean from UGA.
But as you had pointed out, BearDevil, relays account for a lion's share of the scoring points in the world of college swimming, and distance specialists are at a disadvantage when it comes to how many relays they can contribute to...
Not sure what criteria collegeswimming applies to their rankings, but it seems they do agree with you about Kathleen B being more valuable than Katie L, though I'm not sure I'd completely agree with them that Ella should be regarded as the nation's #1 college recruit for 2015, great as she is.[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT]
http://www.collegeswimming.com/recruiting/[U]Class[/U]:
20151 Ella F Eastin, CA
2
Kathleen Baker, NC
3
Kathleen G Ledecky, MD
4 Leah C Stevens, KY
5 Sonia Wang, CA
6 Nora E McCullagh, NC
7 Kathryn A McLaughlin, CA
8 Sydney E Pickrem, FL
9 Miranda Tucker, MI
10 Madeline M Hess, FL
...
18 Mary K Pelton, MD
24 Abbigail Rose Weitzeil, CA
44 Riley Scott, CA
[FONT="Times New Roman"][SIZE="3"][COLOR="RoyalBlue"]
{UPDATE} Kathleen Baker teamed up with Nora McCullagh on March 29 to smash the 15-18 National Age Group record in the
400 Medley relay, with an impressive time-trialed [U]
[COLOR="Red"]3:34.37[/COLOR][/U]. Kathleen's leadoff back split was [U]51.91[/U], Nora's anchor free leg was [U]48.90[/U]. Previous record of [U]
[COLOR="DimGray"]3:36.89[/COLOR][/U] was set last year by none other than an NCAP team that boasted Janet Hu & Katie Ledecky in their lineup!
Kathleen also was instrumental in helping her SWIMMAC Carolina teammates to break 2 more 17-18 NAG relay records the next day, with a [U]24.49[/U] split in her leadoff back leg of the
200 Medley relay's [U]
[COLOR="Red"]1:39.40[/COLOR][/U], followed by a [U]22.63[/U] split in her 1st leg of the
200 Free relay's
[U][COLOR="Red"]1:31.05[/COLOR][/U]!
------------------------
Finally, here's a tweet from Simone Manuel who will be repping LSJU next season, sounds like she's close buddies w/Katie - just keeping my fingers crossed that Katie will turn out to be just a bit closer friends with her Olympic/Worlds teammate (Missy) than she is with Simone tho...[/COLOR][/SIZE][/FONT]
Simone Manuel [COLOR="DimGray"]1h[/COLOR]
[COLOR="DarkRed"]HAPPY BIRTHDAY to @katieledecky!! I couldn't ask for a better roommate. I guess you're a great friend too. Love ya! [/COLOR]
Missy Franklin [COLOR="DimGray"]4 months ago[/COLOR]
[COLOR="DarkRed"]#TBT to London with @katieledecky! Just found this picture and realized how much I love it!❤️ Can't wait to see you this weekend!
[/COLOR]
http://instagram.com/p/g_XB-UwyY7/#[COLOR="White"].[/COLOR]