This was one game. One truly bad game. If we're doing comparisons, we can't say, "Things were worse than this" or "Things weren't as bad" in a particular season, or generally under Holmoe, or Gilby, or Dykes, or the end of Tedford. Those are seasons or eras, this was a game, and we can only compare to individual games.
Forget about anything else, given the caliber of opponent and how interesting the game was to watch, last Saturday was really close to the bottom in terms of individual home games. I'm not going to count any road games, those are sort of a different beast, and there have definitely been some road games that truly sucked. The season opener in 1995 at SD St.? Oh, man.
For me, having seen most home games starting with 1974, the 1998 Big Game is the closest comparison for games at Memorial. That game was like watching paint dry. The Bears lost 10-3 and had almost no hope of moving the ball. We were playing a LSJU team that finished 2-6 in conference, only ahead of 0-8 WSU in the Pac-10 standings. Hell, the Bears went 3-5 in conference, including a win against then-ranked 19 SC. LSJU had allowed at LEAST 28 points in EVERY GAME that season, until the Big Game when the Bears scored THREE. Sure, we MOSTLY stopped the LSJU offense, but even though it was a one score game, there never seemed to be any hope, and the offense was just horrific.
Yeah, there have been worse beat downs than last Saturday at Memorial, but by better teams, and somehow, they held my interest more than last Saturday.
For me, a truly bad game is where I am bored out of my mind by the game, wondering, why the hell am I here watching this, actually being tempted to leave the game early (which I don't do). So for me, it is a close call to the worst game I've been to at Memorial, 1998 Big Game or last Saturday.
I have hope this won't be the worst season of Cal football I've been through. We've seen some bad seasons. In the 21st Century alone, we've had 2001 and 2013 as truly horrific seasons. Those are pretty low bars, but there's time to exceed those low bars -- I'm not sure we can sink lower than those two bars, but there is danger of equaling them. I always find it funny to see people say that it was never worse than Holmoe even though Holmoe went 3-2 against U$C (and 2-3 against fUCLA). Perhaps it was never worse than 2001 (some games in 2001 might compete for the worst at Memorial, and there's an argument for 2013 being the worst season with some of the worst home games), and the final story is not yet written on 2021.
It doesn't really matter whether last Saturday was the worst Memorial game since I started attending games in 1974. As SebastaBear pointed out, perhaps on the Insider Board, if the game is seriously in the conversation for worst Cal game, that is a horrible sign, even if the game won't win the "Worst. Game. Ever." Award. Last Saturday, while only one game, was truly bad. It is 23 years since the 1998 Big Game, and I hope it is at least another 23 years before we see a game as uninspiring as the one last Saturday.