Roxie on 95.7 The Game says Keenan played with broken wrist

2,971 Views | 12 Replies | Last: 12 yr ago by calumnus
calgldnbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
His whole sophomore year and they kept it hidden.

Also, funny comment about his QB throwing to him ... To which Greg Papa said "it was his brother!!!!!"

Discuss

GO BEARS!!!!!!
concordtom
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Well, that's a funny response by Papa!
But I don't understan how a guy could play football with a broken wrist and keep that info "hidden".
Did he have a cast on it or anything?
You don't go running around the field with a broken bone in your arm and no protection - especially WR where you get tackled and have to land hard on your hands to break the fall.
bigcocoon007
How long do you want to ignore this user?
impressive bcuz he was a beast soph year
Beardog26
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Lots of guys play through broken bones and similarly restricting ailments. It is fairly common. My junior year at Cal one of our starting OL rarely practiced during the season due to weekly draining of his knee but never missed a game. He would play 50-70 OL snaps on Saturday and come back Sunday with a knee the size of small watermelon. He ended up playing 9 years as Elway's center in Denver.

If KA's wrist was not casted and/or heavily wrapped during games, I imagine the break was to a small bone that didn't impact range of motion and strength to a great extent. Not only is it not hard to keep that hidden, but you really do NOT want opponents knowing about it. They will target it repeatedly.

That said, you are right that a broken wrist is a very tough injury for a receiver as they use the wrist for everything from catching balls to blocking (frankly, every position does). Try catching a hard thrown ball with a broken wrist, it ain't easy.

I broke my wrist in high school and missed several weeks of the season in a cast. Of course, I was not a potential first round NFL pick and my high school did not make boatloads of money from our team's performance, so my absence was not as impactful either on or off the field as KA's would've been to Cal.
CALiforniALUM
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Beardog26;842117232 said:

Lots of guys play through broken bones and similarly restricting ailments. It is fairly common. My junior year at Cal one of our starting OL rarely practiced during the season due to weekly draining of his knee but never missed a game. He would play 50-70 OL snaps on Saturday and come back Sunday with a knee the size of small watermelon. He ended up playing 9 years as Elway's center in Denver.

If KA's wrist was not casted and/or heavily wrapped during games, I imagine the break was to a small bone that didn't impact range of motion and strength to a great extent. Not only is it not hard to keep that hidden, but you really do NOT want opponents knowing about it. They will target it repeatedly.

That said, you are right that a broken wrist is a very tough injury for a receiver as they use the wrist for everything from catching balls to blocking (frankly, every position does). Try catching a hard thrown ball with a broken wrist, it ain't easy.

I broke my wrist in high school and missed several weeks of the season in a cast. Of course, I was not a potential first round NFL pick and my high school did not make boatloads of money from our team's performance, so my absence was not as impactful either on or off the field as KA's would've been to Cal.



It probably wasn't all that bad for Keenan. His brother was slinging him the ball, which always hit him in the numbers. :sarc:
Beardog26
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Funny side story. After the Big Game we were invited to the Bearants/players weekly post-game tailgate. After a couple hours of rubbing wide-eyed interaction with some of their idols, my twin 11 year old sons engaged in a friendly game of catch with Maynard in the parking lot.

When we got in the car to head home, I told them I thought it was cool that they had met several of the Cal players and asked them what it was like to throw and catch with the Cal QB.

One of the boys said, "Yeah, it was really cool but Maynard kept overthrowing and underthrowing me." Apparently things hadn't changed much from earlier in the day.

There were eight of us in the car. The laughter didn't stop until we were on Highway 24.
NVGolfingBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CALiforniALUM;842117233 said:

It probably wasn't all that bad for Keenan. His brother was slinging him the ball, which always hit him in the numbers. :sarc:

And because it was thrown with Elway-like pace, it was good that it hit him in the numbers!
tommie317
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It's always good until he hurts it again while being broken and makes it in to a permanent injury. that's all.
run2win
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Pretty sure that same OL player also battled cancer----he was a tough player that wasnt about to let some knee pain bother him when he had faced more serious conditions earlier.
WoodlandBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yes, same guy.
John Payeback
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Keith Kartz.
BearlyClad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Not sure that'd work nowadays, where if you don't practice, you just ain't gonna play.
MiZery
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Beardog26;842117237 said:

Funny side story. After the Big Game we were invited to the Bearants/players weekly post-game tailgate. After a couple hours of rubbing wide-eyed interaction with some of their idols, my twin 11 year old sons engaged in a friendly game of catch with Maynard in the parking lot.

When we got in the car to head home, I told them I thought it was cool that they had met several of the Cal players and asked them what it was like to throw and catch with the Cal QB.

One of the boys said, "Yeah, it was really cool but Maynard kept overthrowing and underthrowing me." Apparently things hadn't changed much from earlier in the day.

There were eight of us in the car. The laughter didn't stop until we were on Highway 24.


Wow laughing at a player who was kind enough to play ball with your son
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Keenan was a beast for us. Especially in 2011, a lot of those catches were in traffic where he had to go high for the ball and was hit--amazing he was playing with a broken wrist.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.