The Duke!;842321828 said:
Fact: Alabama's football players have performed much better in the classroom than ours have.
Yes, the University of Alabama is not on the same academic level as Berkeley. But I don't think it is fair to compare the classes that football players tend to take with the classes that normal students tend to take. At both schools, football players tend to eschew the difficult classes and majors.
There is no metric to compare the difficulty of the classes that football players take at different schools. So it is impossible to say how much harder it is to be a football player enrolled in American Studies or African American Studies at Cal, or in the same majors at Alabama.
We are just starting to raise our own academic standards. But I don't think we are in a position to criticize a program with a 978 APR.
I'm sorry, but that is complete BS. No it is not a fact that their players have performed much better in the classroom than ours have. It is a fact that they have a higher APR. Don't confuse that with performing in the classroom.
APR is a joke. All it means is that colleges need to fake it a little more to keep their teams off sanctions. No one needs to do better in the classroom. You just need to have professors willing to put a grade next to the football players' names on a list. Many schools, including Alabama, have been able to paper over every academic requirement the NCAA has ever come up with, with the exception of minimum test scores that are out of the school's control. If you think Alabama football players suddenly became scholars at the advent of APR, I have a bridge to sell you.
Cal has, with a few historical exceptions, never done a good enough job on academics within revenue sports. I am far more concerned with cleaning our own house. And that doesn't mean improving an easily manipulated metric like APR. It means graduating players at a rate consistent with the general student body in normal, non-football majors, neither of which we have ever done.
But I'm not going to put up with schools fraudulently passing guys through to keep their football team going, and then smiling and claiming ethical high ground over schools that won't use those practices to manipulate the statistics. I don't care what they do with their own academic reputation, but I'm not an idiot.