Is Garbers really coming?

10,742 Views | 53 Replies | Last: 8 yr ago by FLC
barabbas
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Heard from some folks close to Chase Garberse, he still wants USC. Cal better keep recruiting QB's
beeasyed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
barabbas;842710953 said:

Heard from some folks close to Chase Garberse, he still wants USC. Cal better keep recruiting QB's


then we better hope Sears commits to $C soon.
going4roses
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Hmm
hanky1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
we should not be taking commits from QBs who are wavering. If this is true then we should just cut him loose.
socaliganbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Been a while since a good woe is Cal post. Probably a whole day.
OdontoBear66
How long do you want to ignore this user?
hanky1;842710962 said:

we should not be taking commits from QBs who are wavering. If this is true then we should just cut him loose.


Would have to agree with this. Why should we be kept dangling? Take players who want Cal. Note that CDM is the heart of $C territory in the OC too.
PtownBear1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Does SC want him?
packawana
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SFBear2012;842710966 said:

Does SC want him?


SC seems to want whoever UCLA doesn't take and vice-versa. But Chase doesn't seem to want UCLA so for him its likely between SC and Cal if SC offers him.

Also it seems pretty clear that we don't have a quarterback that is naturally drawn to us as a first choice this cycle, likely for a variety of reasons ranging from uncertainty over our consistency to the fact that we already have four QBs on scholarship not including Davis Webb.
going4roses
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Spav needs to prove himself here. Tony and his 1st rd QB are gone
burritos
How long do you want to ignore this user?
None of SC's millions of fives star qb's are panning out?
moonpod
How long do you want to ignore this user?
burritos;842710985 said:

None of SC's millions of fives star qb's are panning out?


Lol. If you want to be critical about their recruiting that would be the position
hanky1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
USC insiders are saying they're waiting on Sears as the #1 choice. If he doesn't go to USC then they'll make a run at their #2 option who appears to be Alabama commit Tua Tagovailoa. After that who knows...probably Garbers I would imagine is in that group.
going4roses
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bama has two QB commits
burritos
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Who is SC's best QB rep in the NFL? Carson Palmer? The guy who lost to Holmoe 3 times?
MoragaBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Seriously, people? It's as if no one's ever heard any baseless recruiting rumors before. We shouldn't be taking ccommitments from QB's who are wavering? We shouldn't have to be kept dangling?

Sounded like bs to me so I went to Garbers to see what he had to say.

His answer?

I'm not sure where you heard that but that's 1,000% false... I'm a Cal Bear hands down, USC hasn't offered and why would I leave Cal. Cal is a tremendous place at all angles. If USC offered that would be sweet cause it's a home town school but at this point it would take a natural disaster to wipe out Cal or something really drastic for me to change my mind! I don't mean to offend the USC program in any way by saying this but I'm a Cal Bear, a Cal Quarterback and I'm trying to build my class to be the best! I'm all Cal.
going4roses
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nuff said
stanfurdbites
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MoragaBear;842711015 said:

Seriously, people? It's as if no one's ever heard any baseless recruiting rumors before. We shouldn't be taking ccommitments from QB's who are wavering? We shouldn't have to be kept dangling?

Sounded like bs to me so I went to Garbers to see what he had to say.

His answer?

I'm not sure where you heard that but that's 1,000% false... I'm a Cal Bear hands down, USC hasn't offered and why would I leave Cal. Cal is a tremendous place at all angles. If USC offered that would be sweet cause it's a home town school but at this point it would take a natural disaster to wipe out Cal or something really drastic for me to change my mind! I don't mean to offend the USC program in any way by saying this but I'm a Cal Bear, a Cal Quarterback and I'm trying to build my class to be the best! I'm all Cal.


Sounds like a lot of ambiguity and uncertainty. I can see where the rumors are coming from
85Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
stanfurdbites;842711019 said:

sounds like a lot of ambiguity and uncertainty. I can see where the rumors are coming from


lol
Meister Petz
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MoragaBear;842711015 said:

Seriously, people? It's as if no one's ever heard any baseless recruiting rumors before. We shouldn't be taking ccommitments from QB's who are wavering? We shouldn't have to be kept dangling?

Sounded like bs to me so I went to Garbers to see what he had to say.

His answer?

I'm not sure where you heard that but that's 1,000% false... I'm a Cal Bear hands down, USC hasn't offered and why would I leave Cal. Cal is a tremendous place at all angles. If USC offered that would be sweet cause it's a home town school but at this point it would take a natural disaster to wipe out Cal or something really drastic for me to change my mind! I don't mean to offend the USC program in any way by saying this but I'm a Cal Bear, a Cal Quarterback and I'm trying to build my class to be the best! I'm all Cal.
Does Sonny Dykes leaving for the Baylor HC job qualify as a natural disaster? Just in terms of recruiting.
MoragaBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
When camp's starting in days?

I don't think so.
moonpod
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MoragaBear;842711025 said:

When camp's starting in days?

I don't think so.


I think maybe he meant before Garbers signs in the winter.
beeasyed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
moonpod;842711068 said:

I think maybe he meant before Garbers signs in the winter.


pretty sure Garbers said he has no intention of enrolling early. would be first one since before Goff not to, right?
(goff, chase, ross, max, vic all were EEs?)
MoragaBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Who knows what will happen in coming years? I wonder when Baylor's going to try and make a permanent hire or how open they are to hiring Grobe permanently if they have a solid to good season.

And no, Garber's won't come in early but LOI day is in the winter, too.
moonpod
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MoragaBear;842711075 said:

Who knows what will happen in coming years? I wonder when Baylor's going to try and make a permanent hire or how open they are to hiring Grobe permanently if they have a solid to good season.

And no, Garber's won't come in early but LOI day is in the winter, too.


meant that and yup who knows what happens in the NEXT off season
heartofthebear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
moonpod;842710987 said:

Lol. If you want to be critical about their recruiting that would be the position


Their OL has tended to underperform as well.
OdontoBear66
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MoragaBear;842711015 said:

Seriously, people? It's as if no one's ever heard any baseless recruiting rumors before. We shouldn't be taking ccommitments from QB's who are wavering? We shouldn't have to be kept dangling?

Sounded like bs to me so I went to Garbers to see what he had to say.

His answer?

I'm not sure where you heard that but that's 1,000% false... I'm a Cal Bear hands down, USC hasn't offered and why would I leave Cal. Cal is a tremendous place at all angles. If USC offered that would be sweet cause it's a home town school but at this point it would take a natural disaster to wipe out Cal or something really drastic for me to change my mind! I don't mean to offend the USC program in any way by saying this but I'm a Cal Bear, a Cal Quarterback and I'm trying to build my class to be the best! I'm all Cal.


Well, I don't get to go to Garbers or in BB Matthews, so unless someone dispels those rumors over time you don't necessarlly believe them, but combining a lot of dots you may guess at things. I didn't hear anybody saying it was true. Just hearing. So the more you, MB, disseminate, the more we know, the less we guess. Until confirmed or denied there is reason to question. But yes, rumors they are.

Things I can't figure is that Matthews was in the sweet spot at Cal. He was to be a senior, a much valued player, much loved by Cal fans (myself included), with the prospects of a great senior year. Somehow that crashed. Can you tell me emphatically that Matthews, all by himself, just up and wanted to leave Cal in his senior year when he was a highlight player? And if he did, can you even admit that it is a bit implausible to those who are not in "the know". In that you do know, I realize it is not up to you to reveal all, but at the same time don't make light of Cal fans who "wonder out loud". I hope you can appreciate that.
moonpod
How long do you want to ignore this user?
heartofthebear;842711114 said:

Their OL has tended to underperform as well.


JMO more to do with their joke of an OL coach the last few years. I think Helton replaced him
MoragaBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
OdontoBear66;842711120 said:

Well, I don't get to go to Garbers or in BB Matthews, so unless someone dispels those rumors over time you don't necessarlly believe them, but combining a lot of dots you may guess at things. I didn't hear anybody saying it was true. Just hearing. So the more you, MB, disseminate, the more we know, the less we guess. Until confirmed or denied there is reason to question. But yes, rumors they are.

Things I can't figure is that Matthews was in the sweet spot at Cal. He was to be a senior, a much valued player, much loved by Cal fans (myself included), with the prospects of a great senior year. Somehow that crashed. Can you tell me emphatically that Matthews, all by himself, just up and wanted to leave Cal in his senior year when he was a highlight player? And if he did, can you even admit that it is a bit implausible to those who are not in "the know". In that you do know, I realize it is not up to you to reveal all, but at the same time don't make light of Cal fans who "wonder out loud". I hope you can appreciate that.


There's a vast middle ground between someone hearing a rumor and saying I hope it's not true to saying Cal blew it by taking a commitment from a quarterback who was wavering and complaining about leaving fans dangling when it was a bs rumor to begin with. It's called jumping to conclusions and believing everything you hear and it has nothing to do with Mathews' situation.
beeasyed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
well here's something yall can freak out about re: Garbers

Garbers just followed Furd's David Shaw, Mike Bloomgren (OC), and Tavita Pritchard (QB) on twitter.
moonpod
How long do you want to ignore this user?
beeasyed;842711125 said:

well here's something yall can freak out about re: Garbers

Garbers just followed Furd's David Shaw, Mike Bloomgren (OC), and Tavita Pritchard (QB) on twitter.


Aaaagghhhhhhhhhh
OdontoBear66
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MoragaBear;842711124 said:

There's a vast middle ground between someone hearing a rumor and saying I hope it's not true to saying Cal blew it by taking a commitment from a quarterback who was wavering and complaining about leaving fans dangling when it was a bs rumor to begin with. It's called jumping to conclusions and believing everything you hear and it has nothing to do with Mathews' situation.


You are totally missing the point MB....There is nothing wrong with people casting about innuendo, or rumor, when in fact, it is not fact, nor do they imply it is fact. This is the internet. If you want to stop that, and if you think Cal fans are stupido for even suggesting rumors, then dispell them in a blink. I think that leaves fans dangling, but then coupling it with believing every thing you hear is absurd. That thinking only serves your purpose of argument. No one sez that.

My example with Matthews serves purpose, which you choose not to answer. Until told I am wrong, wrong, wrong, I think the combination of Phil Matthews being a coach of great repute, of our Matthews seeking transfer at the pinnacle of his career sez something. I am not sure what for no one is talking and basically sez don't worry. Then Jonah chooses to go to SC which can be simply Jonah. But put it all together and it sure as hell suggests possibilities of which we do not speak here.

ps. And the more solid Garbers is the happy I am...

Now, I for one, do not like that, for I think our BB program is on a tremendous upswing with CM (and I loved MM too). But I am on a Bear "Insider" network and we just don't discuss the real "why". Your stage, your call, but I don't have to like it. So do what you've gotta do, but I have hung here back from early Cyberbears days and really just want to know what is going on at my alma mater.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
OdontoBear66;842711135 said:

You are totally missing the point MB....There is nothing wrong with people casting about innuendo, or rumor, when in fact, it is not fact, nor do they imply it is fact. This is the internet. If you want to stop that, and if you think Cal fans are stupido for even suggesting rumors, then dispell them in a blink. I think that leaves fans dangling, but then coupling it with believing every thing you hear is absurd. That thinking only serves your purpose of argument. No one sez that.

My example with Matthews serves purpose, which you choose not to answer. Until told I am wrong, wrong, wrong, I think the combination of Phil Matthews being a coach of great repute, of our Matthews seeking transfer at the pinnacle of his career sez something. I am not sure what for no one is talking and basically sez don't worry. Then Jonah chooses to go to SC which can be simply Jonah. But put it all together and it sure as hell suggests possibilities of which we do not speak here.

ps. And the more solid Garbers is the happy I am...

Now, I for one, do not like that, for I think our BB program is on a tremendous upswing with CM (and I loved MM too). But I am on a Bear "Insider" network and we just don't discuss the real "why". Your stage, your call, but I don't have to like it. So do what you've gotta do, but I have hung here back from early Cyberbears days and really just want to know what is going on at my alma mater.

Jordan wanted to join his dad--get a grad degree. He is not athletic enough to make it at the next level and instead wants to become a coach so in the following year he will be the GA. He will have played for multiple great coaches and that will be great on his resume. He will have a B.A. from Cal and an M.A. from Gonzaga all paid for through basketball. Smart for him, kinda sucks for us, but we will be over it a year from now. This is his life.

Jonah made his own decision. I am fairly certain it is a matter of a guy from L.A. want ing to stay in L.A.
MoragaBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm not missing any point. Of course message boards are all about rumors. What they're not supposed to be about is buying those rumors with no substantiation and talking about no good QB's seemingly interested in Cal this cycle or saying Cal blew it by taking a commitment from a wishy washy recruit. Don't know how that distinction isn't obvious.

We don't discuss the real why? I posted the second I talked to Garbers (and for that matter, Matthews, too). Yet somehow Garber's great response isn't definitive enough for you and I'm holding back and telling people no one should talk about rumors? Of course they should talk about rumors, unless they're of an inappropriate nature.

And this thread isn't about Matthews. That's already been fully-dissected in several threads in which you and I posted several times.
Shocky1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus;842711138 said:

Jordan wanted to join his dad--get a grad degree. He is not athletic enough to make it at the next level and instead wants to become a coach so in the following year he will be the GA. He will have played for multiple great coaches and that will be great on his resume. He will have a B.A. from Cal and an M.A. from Gonzaga all paid for through basketball. Smart for him, kinda sucks for us, but we will be over it a year from now. This is his life.

Jonah made his own decision. I am fairly certain it is a matter of a guy from L.A. want ing to stay in L.A.


100% inaccurate, j mat thinks he has nba potential & that playing for mark few & his godfather in spokane will help him achieve that...there were also family issues with he cal staff
OdontoBear66
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus;842711138 said:

Jordan wanted to join his dad--get a grad degree. He is not athletic enough to make it at the next level and instead wants to become a coach so in the following year he will be the GA. He will have played for multiple great coaches and that will be great on his resume. He will have a B.A. from Cal and an M.A. from Gonzaga all paid for through basketball. Smart for him, kinda sucks for us, but we will be over it a year from now. This is his life.

Jonah made his own decision. I am fairly certain it is a matter of a guy from L.A. want ing to stay in L.A.


Thank you Calumnus. When you do not know, when decisions are protected for good reasons or other, one is left but to guess.
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.