I still don't know what was the reasoning behind the "illegal touching" penalty on that play where Wharton was receiving the punt and our guy ran into him.
If I'm remembering correctly, Wharton had waved for a fair catch. As the ball came near, a Cal blocker engaged with a BYU defender ran into Wharton, with the ball going past them both (neither touched the ball). Further back, a BYU player grabbed the ball and started to run. Whistled dead, with an "illegal touching" penalty called, reviewed, and confirmed.
So, what exactly was the infraction? Seems like if we had touched it, they could've taken possession and run with it. If we didn't touch it, they can touch the ball to down it (but not run with it). The commentators had no explanation that I heard... can any of you rules experts explain?
If I'm remembering correctly, Wharton had waved for a fair catch. As the ball came near, a Cal blocker engaged with a BYU defender ran into Wharton, with the ball going past them both (neither touched the ball). Further back, a BYU player grabbed the ball and started to run. Whistled dead, with an "illegal touching" penalty called, reviewed, and confirmed.
So, what exactly was the infraction? Seems like if we had touched it, they could've taken possession and run with it. If we didn't touch it, they can touch the ball to down it (but not run with it). The commentators had no explanation that I heard... can any of you rules experts explain?