71Bear said:
OaktownBear said:
ducky23 said:
71Bear said:
okaydo said:
It's amazing how true this is. (I'm sure many here will disagree, particularly those with advanced degrees.)
It is absolutely true.
I'll only speak for the profession I know, but it absolutely matters for your first job after law school (after that, it doesn't matter).
I also imagine that what medical school you go to might determine residency placement.
Employment statistics demonstrate that it matters a lot. Obviously the more work experience you get, the less your college matters. I tend to think people that say it doesn't matter are just far removed from the time in their lives when it really did.
Speaking as someone who was responsible for hiring people into professional positions, I can say unequivocally that the college of choice did not matter. The only question regarding educational background was do you have a degree not where did you attend college. The interviews I conducted confirmed that those with degrees from Cal, Stanford, UCLA, etc. were no better than interviews with candidates from less "elite" schools. It isn't where you went to school, it is what you did after you graduated.
Having said that, I would agree that it matters in the areas of law, medicine and engineering but otherwise, nope....
See, I knew somebody was going to say "I hired people and it didn't matter". Well, I was involved in interview processes (not just legal) and it DID matter. But that is purely anecdotal. Graduates of elite universities make tons more money over their careers than others. Either they are more talented to start with, they come out better prepared, (and if those are true, then I'd argue that it would be smart for employers to consider it in the hiring process), they have better connections, or employers do in fact care, or most likely all of the above.
You don't think it matters for high level government jobs? Jobs in higher education? Scientists? Mathematicians? San Jose State grads are equaling Cal and Stanford in Silicon Valley? Academic researchers? A degree from Parson's doesn't give you a leg up in art and design over other schools in that field? Degrees in film from NYU or USC don't matter?
I doubt many employers look at a 45 year old with 20 years experience and says "he went to Harvard. Hire him". I also doubt many employers when sifting through 20 resumes of 45 year olds with 20 years experience don't see a resume with Harvard at the top and don't look further than they otherwise might and maybe even interview when they otherwise might not have.
And I have to say, I disagree with you. Yes, I've met plenty of great people in their fields who did not go to elite schools. And certainly I've seen graduates from elite schools be duds. It's not proof of anything. But I flat out disagree that, at least for jobs that involve critical thinking, the pool that draws from elite colleges does not produce on average a higher number of qualified candidates than the pool that does not.
I think the point is, there are some jobs where studying in top programs with top people doesn't really add much value. The job doesn't need a crucible of thought to distinguish you. It is more based on time management, competence, dedication, pride in a job well done. Elite schools don't teach you that. For those jobs, you just need to learn how to do the job. Other jobs it is highly beneficial to have studied with the best. And in those fields, employers intrinsically know it is a benefit. Elite schools excel there And yes, that is a small percentage of jobs, but of course elite university graduates are a small percentage of the population.