Rod Benson article

5,595 Views | 56 Replies | Last: 1 yr ago by stu
cal83dls79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Good to hear from him but boy. Nothing we haven't witnessed but coming from Rod drives it home. Fox is clueless

https://www.sfgate.com/collegesports/article/cal-mens-basketball-column-17670025.php
Priest of the Patty Hearst Shrine
BC Calfan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Good Ol' Rod took it very easy on us. I wonder if Fox and Knowlton even knew who he was.
KoreAmBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wow spot on for everything except saying that we are small. We are not. But we still get outrebounded. It is the coaching.
socaltownie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wow!! Maybe jimbo pays attention to that!!!
Take care of your Chicken
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KoreAmBear said:

Wow spot on for everything except saying that we are small. We are not. But we still get outrebounded. It is the coaching.


Agreed, though the Cal teams he was on had a lot of bigs, he was usually one of the two tallest. Braun loved to stockpile bigs, but then played small. But yeah, overall agree with Rod. The coaching is bad, offense especially and that is compared with Braun who was no X's and O's wizard.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?

I thought Benson went out of his way to be fair to Fox. What he noticed about our offense is exactly what I've seen this season. Part of it is the players themselves and their skill sets, part of it is that the staff has assembled these players and the biggest part is that it's up to the coaches to coach 'em up... and these guys are demonstrating game in and game out that they have no clue.
rkt88edmo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BC Calfan said:

Good Ol' Rod took it very easy on us. I wonder if Fox and Knowlton even knew who he was.
Well, when he was on field with Marshawn and Justin they failed to identify him as a Cal BB alum, but I think they did recognize him as the artist of the poster giveaway (and if anyone has an extra they don't want pls lmk), I wasn't at the game.
concernedparent
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KoreAmBear said:

Wow spot on for everything except saying that we are small. We are not. But we still get outrebounded. It is the coaching.
When Thiemann goes out we're quite small in the front court.
HoopDreams
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however
dimitrig
How long do you want to ignore this user?

BOOMTHO!

calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
concernedparent said:

KoreAmBear said:

Wow spot on for everything except saying that we are small. We are not. But we still get outrebounded. It is the coaching.
When Thiemann goes out we're quite small in the front court.


Okafor 6'9
Kuany 6'9
Newell 6'8

We have 9 players listed at 6'7 or more.

Rod Bentsen was listed at 6'10
HKBear97!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
eastcoastcal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.

Mind you, in the bay area itself, USF and St. Mary's have better records (and have even beat us out for prospects!) while having far less funds/resources, less academic caliber to sell recruits on, no practice facility for USF.

The truth is, for the better part of 3 decades, Cal made the tournament more often than every other year. Some of the best teams in college basketball are academic brands: Duke, UVA, Michigan, UNC, UCLA, etc. We have a very loud basketball fanbase that will show up for a winner. During Shocky's monster class years, we were competing with blue bloods like UNC for recruits! Haas is a nice place to play. We are a top academic brand in the world. Beautiful weather year-round. We even have donors who've stepped up in the housing department (thanks 4thGen!), albeit that's a more recent development.

College basketball is so unbelievably winnable for a school like Cal, yet here we are, the worst high major team in the nation and a bottom 60 team in D1 most likely. The level of losing over the past 5 years is just inexcusable, and I understand the limitations with NIL + housing + practice facility but the truth is, that doesn't even come close to meriting how bad of a program we've run. At nearly any other power program, these results get the AD, coaches, and all staff canned.

I understand we'll almost certainly move on from Fox after this season. And hopefully the next coach will right the ship. But I truly hate hearing, especially from Knowlton & Fox, how "difficult of a situation" it is. How can you sell fans, prospective coaching hires, recruits, and parents on Cal if you internally believe this is a bad situation? It will inevitably show up in the way you sell Cal to all these people and I am willing to bet that is the issue Knowlton has. He remarked about how all his coaching interviews mentioned how difficult it will be to turn Cal around- really? You're telling me Gates was that reluctant? You're telling me Kidd, even if he wasn't truly interested, was willing to publicly state Cal is the only college job he'd take even though he believed the job sucks? My honest theory is that Knowlton doesn't realize the level of success Cal has had in basketball. We're not just an average school- historically in the preceeding 3 decades, we were a good basketball school. I think Knowlton just views us as a loser that at best can compete for the middle of the conference. That's ridiculous and we should consistently be in the upper 3rd. Sure, UCLA, Arizona might be in a different echelon. But no reason why we can't place ourselves in the tier below on an annual basis.

My point is, I really hate hearing from the people who run our department & program how terrible of a job the Cal basketball program is. It's not. We expect our academic programs to be top 5 in the country. We have the best aquatics programs in the nation. Our golf team just recruited the top recruiting class. Our researchers discover new elements and energy sources. Our graduates found multi-billion dollar companies. Striving for mediocrity and acceptance of poor results enrages me, especially when Knowlton & his hire parrots the same nonsense over and over again
BearSD
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Big C said:


I thought Benson went out of his way to be fair to Fox. What he noticed about our offense is exactly what I've seen this season. Part of it is the players themselves and their skill sets, part of it is that the staff has assembled these players and the biggest part is that it's up to the coaches to coach 'em up... and these guys are demonstrating game in and game out that they have no clue.
It's not the biggest part.

The biggest part is recruiting. Recruiting, recruiting, recruiting. It's bringing in players who have both a lot of talent when they first arrive, and have a high ceiling. If a recruit is meh in the first place, and/or is someone who looked good in high school but peaked in 11th grade, then there's no amount of coaching them up that will turn a roster full of players like that into an NCAA tournament team.
BC Calfan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Well said Eastcoast. It truly is rage inducing.

Simply put he's an idiot. Look at the women's team. They operate under the same "disadvantages" and they seem to be doing fine.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BearSD said:

Big C said:


I thought Benson went out of his way to be fair to Fox. What he noticed about our offense is exactly what I've seen this season. Part of it is the players themselves and their skill sets, part of it is that the staff has assembled these players and the biggest part is that it's up to the coaches to coach 'em up... and these guys are demonstrating game in and game out that they have no clue.
It's not the biggest part.

The biggest part is recruiting. Recruiting, recruiting, recruiting. It's bringing in players who have both a lot of talent when they first arrive, and have a high ceiling. If a recruit is meh in the first place, and/or is someone who looked good in high school but peaked in 11th grade, then there's no amount of coaching them up that will turn a roster full of players like that into an NCAA tournament team.

You are correct. of course, about the importance of recruiting. My comment about coaching them up was strictly about how incompetent (for lack of a better word) we look when we run this "offense". But yes, even then, if we had recruited a Theo instead of an Alajiki, the offense would look better.
southseasbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.

Mind you, in the bay area itself, USF and St. Mary's have better records (and have even beat us out for prospects!) while having far less funds/resources, less academic caliber to sell recruits on, no practice facility for USF.

The truth is, for the better part of 3 decades, Cal made the tournament more often than every other year. Some of the best teams in college basketball are academic brands: Duke, UVA, Michigan, UNC, UCLA, etc. We have a very loud basketball fanbase that will show up for a winner. During Shocky's monster class years, we were competing with blue bloods like UNC for recruits! Haas is a nice place to play. We are a top academic brand in the world. Beautiful weather year-round. We even have donors who've stepped up in the housing department (thanks 4thGen!), albeit that's a more recent development.

College basketball is so unbelievably winnable for a school like Cal, yet here we are, the worst high major team in the nation and a bottom 60 team in D1 most likely. The level of losing over the past 5 years is just inexcusable, and I understand the limitations with NIL + housing + practice facility but the truth is, that doesn't even come close to meriting how bad of a program we've run. At nearly any other power program, these results get the AD, coaches, and all staff canned.

I understand we'll almost certainly move on from Fox after this season. And hopefully the next coach will right the ship. But I truly hate hearing, especially from Knowlton & Fox, how "difficult of a situation" it is. How can you sell fans, prospective coaching hires, recruits, and parents on Cal if you internally believe this is a bad situation? It will inevitably show up in the way you sell Cal to all these people and I am willing to bet that is the issue Knowlton has. He remarked about how all his coaching interviews mentioned how difficult it will be to turn Cal around- really? You're telling me Gates was that reluctant? You're telling me Kidd, even if he wasn't truly interested, was willing to publicly state Cal is the only college job he'd take even though he believed the job sucks? My honest theory is that Knowlton doesn't realize the level of success Cal has had in basketball. We're not just an average school- historically in the preceeding 3 decades, we were a good basketball school. I think Knowlton just views us as a loser that at best can compete for the middle of the conference. That's ridiculous and we should consistently be in the upper 3rd. Sure, UCLA, Arizona might be in a different echelon. But no reason why we can't place ourselves in the tier below on an annual basis.

My point is, I really hate hearing from the people who run our department & program how terrible of a job the Cal basketball program is. It's not. We expect our academic programs to be top 5 in the country. We have the best aquatics programs in the nation. Our golf team just recruited the top recruiting class. Our researchers discover new elements and energy sources. Our graduates found multi-billion dollar companies. Striving for mediocrity and acceptance of poor results enrages me, especially when Knowlton & his hire parrots the same nonsense over and over again
Knowlton is partially correct. It is difficult at Cal, but not for the reasons he expressed. It is difficult because our current and previous athletic directors were incompetent idiots, as evidenced by the coaches they hired and the contracts they "negotiated" with them.
Fire Knowlton!
Fire Fox!
Put Wilcox in a hot seat!
concernedparent
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

concernedparent said:

KoreAmBear said:

Wow spot on for everything except saying that we are small. We are not. But we still get outrebounded. It is the coaching.
When Thiemann goes out we're quite small in the front court.


Okafor 6'9
Kuany 6'9
Newell 6'8

We have 9 players listed at 6'7 or more.

Rod Bentsen was listed at 6'10
That's small in the front court. Ivan Rabb, listed at 6'11, couldn't stay at C for us even though it would've made our offense so much better.
bluehenbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

I felt myself struggling to stay awake, and I noticed a Utah State staffer full-on falling asleep. If that guy had died of boredom that day, no one would have blamed him.
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Either drop sports or compete. Don't trap us in an expensive ($2M coach salary) Groundhog Day netherworld of sub mediocrity and half a@ssness which shames and disrespects our proud and sacred traditions.

Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside
oskidunker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bearister said:

Either drop sports or compete. Don't trap us in an expensive ($2M coach salary) Groundhog Day netherworld of sub mediocrity and half a@ssness which shames and disrespects our proud and sacred traditions.


Agree totally. Quit embarrassing the university , the alumni and the players. Frankly I am at a point where I wish we would just stop playing
Go Bears!
SFCityBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.

Mind you, in the bay area itself, USF and St. Mary's have better records (and have even beat us out for prospects!) while having far less funds/resources, less academic caliber to sell recruits on, no practice facility for USF.

The truth is, for the better part of 3 decades, Cal made the tournament more often than every other year. Some of the best teams in college basketball are academic brands: Duke, UVA, Michigan, UNC, UCLA, etc. We have a very loud basketball fanbase that will show up for a winner. During Shocky's monster class years, we were competing with blue bloods like UNC for recruits! Haas is a nice place to play. We are a top academic brand in the world. Beautiful weather year-round. We even have donors who've stepped up in the housing department (thanks 4thGen!), albeit that's a more recent development.

College basketball is so unbelievably winnable for a school like Cal, yet here we are, the worst high major team in the nation and a bottom 60 team in D1 most likely. The level of losing over the past 5 years is just inexcusable, and I understand the limitations with NIL + housing + practice facility but the truth is, that doesn't even come close to meriting how bad of a program we've run. At nearly any other power program, these results get the AD, coaches, and all staff canned.

I understand we'll almost certainly move on from Fox after this season. And hopefully the next coach will right the ship. But I truly hate hearing, especially from Knowlton & Fox, how "difficult of a situation" it is. How can you sell fans, prospective coaching hires, recruits, and parents on Cal if you internally believe this is a bad situation? It will inevitably show up in the way you sell Cal to all these people and I am willing to bet that is the issue Knowlton has. He remarked about how all his coaching interviews mentioned how difficult it will be to turn Cal around- really? You're telling me Gates was that reluctant? You're telling me Kidd, even if he wasn't truly interested, was willing to publicly state Cal is the only college job he'd take even though he believed the job sucks? My honest theory is that Knowlton doesn't realize the level of success Cal has had in basketball. We're not just an average school- historically in the preceeding 3 decades, we were a good basketball school. I think Knowlton just views us as a loser that at best can compete for the middle of the conference. That's ridiculous and we should consistently be in the upper 3rd. Sure, UCLA, Arizona might be in a different echelon. But no reason why we can't place ourselves in the tier below on an annual basis.

My point is, I really hate hearing from the people who run our department & program how terrible of a job the Cal basketball program is. It's not. We expect our academic programs to be top 5 in the country. We have the best aquatics programs in the nation. Our golf team just recruited the top recruiting class. Our researchers discover new elements and energy sources. Our graduates found multi-billion dollar companies. Striving for mediocrity and acceptance of poor results enrages me, especially when Knowlton & his hire parrots the same nonsense over and over again
I wonder why we are all so sure that Knowlton is solely responsible for this debacle. I have wondered from the beginning how often is a manager who makes a million dollar salary, allowed or instructed to hire an employee will be making twice as much as he himself is paid? I should think that those above Knowlton would at least investigate the AD's hiring choices, especially for the head coaches of two major sport programs, football and basketball, and subsequently approve or disapprove them. Isn't it also possible that the choice for these two positions might have been suggested, maybe strongly so, by the Chancellor herself or someone as high or higher up?

A related issue for me was in a post by Beached Bear, I believe, where he said that he had a conversation with an employee on Knowlton's staff. The employee told him that it was the plan of either Knowlton or the the Athletic Department, I don't remember, to deemphasize basketball. I can not believe that a decision to deemphasize a major sport would be made at the AD level. It would have to be approved at least by the AD's boss, wouldn't it? And isn't the very idea of deemphasizing a major sport more likely to have come from the Chancellor of someone higher?

SFCityBear
HoopDreams
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game

stu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:

I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game


Wow! That's weak!

I'd understand putting up a message asking for a round of applause to support Celestine and Clayton in their recoveries from injuries.
MSaviolives
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game


oh woe is us
dimitrig
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MSaviolives said:

HoopDreams said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game


oh woe is us


42 is also how many days ago Fox should have been fired
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
dimitrig said:

MSaviolives said:

HoopDreams said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game


oh woe is us


42 is also how many months ago Fox and Knowlton should have been fired



FIFY
HKBear97!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game




OMFG. They did not put this up! What a fu-king embarrassment. Cal is dead to me…
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game




OMFG. They did not put this up! What a fu-king embarrassment. Cal is dead to me…


Knowlton and Fox should both be fired just for this alone.

Did we do this when Grigsby, Powe, Hardin, Kamp, Bird, Wallace, ie almost any other year when players are hurt? This is CYA excuse making disguised as marketing.
cal83dls79
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game



Absolutely pathetic. Reminds me of Stanford's rugby team bowing out and making excuses not to play us. This should have a thread of its own so it's not buried in my original post.
Priest of the Patty Hearst Shrine
KoreAmBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I love how this is now deeply embedded in Fox and Knowlton's narrative for this season to the extent we draw attention to it on the video screens. So Clayton, Celestine and Hyder play we have, what, 3 more wins? I can't wait until both are gone.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SFCityBear said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.

Mind you, in the bay area itself, USF and St. Mary's have better records (and have even beat us out for prospects!) while having far less funds/resources, less academic caliber to sell recruits on, no practice facility for USF.

The truth is, for the better part of 3 decades, Cal made the tournament more often than every other year. Some of the best teams in college basketball are academic brands: Duke, UVA, Michigan, UNC, UCLA, etc. We have a very loud basketball fanbase that will show up for a winner. During Shocky's monster class years, we were competing with blue bloods like UNC for recruits! Haas is a nice place to play. We are a top academic brand in the world. Beautiful weather year-round. We even have donors who've stepped up in the housing department (thanks 4thGen!), albeit that's a more recent development.

College basketball is so unbelievably winnable for a school like Cal, yet here we are, the worst high major team in the nation and a bottom 60 team in D1 most likely. The level of losing over the past 5 years is just inexcusable, and I understand the limitations with NIL + housing + practice facility but the truth is, that doesn't even come close to meriting how bad of a program we've run. At nearly any other power program, these results get the AD, coaches, and all staff canned.

I understand we'll almost certainly move on from Fox after this season. And hopefully the next coach will right the ship. But I truly hate hearing, especially from Knowlton & Fox, how "difficult of a situation" it is. How can you sell fans, prospective coaching hires, recruits, and parents on Cal if you internally believe this is a bad situation? It will inevitably show up in the way you sell Cal to all these people and I am willing to bet that is the issue Knowlton has. He remarked about how all his coaching interviews mentioned how difficult it will be to turn Cal around- really? You're telling me Gates was that reluctant? You're telling me Kidd, even if he wasn't truly interested, was willing to publicly state Cal is the only college job he'd take even though he believed the job sucks? My honest theory is that Knowlton doesn't realize the level of success Cal has had in basketball. We're not just an average school- historically in the preceeding 3 decades, we were a good basketball school. I think Knowlton just views us as a loser that at best can compete for the middle of the conference. That's ridiculous and we should consistently be in the upper 3rd. Sure, UCLA, Arizona might be in a different echelon. But no reason why we can't place ourselves in the tier below on an annual basis.

My point is, I really hate hearing from the people who run our department & program how terrible of a job the Cal basketball program is. It's not. We expect our academic programs to be top 5 in the country. We have the best aquatics programs in the nation. Our golf team just recruited the top recruiting class. Our researchers discover new elements and energy sources. Our graduates found multi-billion dollar companies. Striving for mediocrity and acceptance of poor results enrages me, especially when Knowlton & his hire parrots the same nonsense over and over again
I wonder why we are all so sure that Knowlton is solely responsible for this debacle. I have wondered from the beginning how often is a manager who makes a million dollar salary, allowed or instructed to hire an employee will be making twice as much as he himself is paid? I should think that those above Knowlton would at least investigate the AD's hiring choices, especially for the head coaches of two major sport programs, football and basketball, and subsequently approve or disapprove them. Isn't it also possible that the choice for these two positions might have been suggested, maybe strongly so, by the Chancellor herself or someone as high or higher up?

A related issue for me was in a post by Beached Bear, I believe, where he said that he had a conversation with an employee on Knowlton's staff. The employee told him that it was the plan of either Knowlton or the the Athletic Department, I don't remember, to deemphasize basketball. I can not believe that a decision to deemphasize a major sport would be made at the AD level. It would have to be approved at least by the AD's boss, wouldn't it? And isn't the very idea of deemphasizing a major sport more likely to have come from the Chancellor of someone higher?




Knowlton is the Athletic Director, head of the department paid over $1 million per year. His boss is the Chancellor, Carol Christ, a Victorian Literature professor who was hired from all-women's Smith College. The only person above her is the UC President. Christ says she defers to Knowlton who is a retired Army officer who played hockey at West Point and was the AD for 3 years at Air Force before coming to Cal. Knowlton explained his process in hiring Fox, other than the consulting firm, he relied on no one else. He fired Jones, then hired Fox in 4 days. He said he interviewed DeCuire and Fox, but he hired Fox because they connected and he felt comfortable with him. There is no reason to doubt his account, especially given the results and the extent he is going to make excuses for our 1-12 record, with the rest of the season likely similar results as the level of competition will only be greater.
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:

eastcoastcal said:

calumnus said:

HKBear97! said:

HoopDreams said:

I was surprised by the utah state results because the rumor out there was cal did pretty good (although the reference was vague)

utah state is 9-1 however


Well, bear in mind who those rumors came from. Many of them refuse to face reality about Fox and this program. Rod nailed it right off the bat that he didn't think we would win a game. That's as damning as it gets.


The amount of coach/AD propaganda that comes out of our football and basketball programs and is spread by our insiders is disheartening.
This is the fundamental issue I have with Knowlton- he doesn't seem to believe Cal is a great place to win. In my 1 conversation with him, as well as his public remarks, he constantly defaults to "how difficult of a situation" Fox inherited, and then the long list of excuses begin: COVID, no practice facility, NIL, fan apathy.
I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game




Thank God for the software glitch that resulted in the inadvertent deletion of the last line of that message:

"…and the dog ate my homework."
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside
BC Calfan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:



I couldn't believe they put this on the scoreboard before the game


This is the most pathetically sad thing I've ever seen.

You know any opportunity Fox has, he will try and inflate that number. He will be spouting this narrative the rest of his coaching career when anyone ever mentions his 2-3 win season.
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.