So impressive v the Zags. Best player on the court. Good job Fox.
Mahaney taking over
6,608 Views |
54 Replies |
Last: 1 yr ago by stu
Unforgivable that we whiffed on him. how can Fox's strategy for recruiting be to 'narrow' the field and focus on guys 'we can get', and then whiff on someone we could've gotten in our own backyard? pathetic and sad and what a failure on our part.
The last 5 minutes of the game, I think Mahaney scored 10 straight points. Great player, great game.
Fox is an idiot.
Fox is an idiot.
Start Slowly and taper off
eastcoastcal said:
Unforgivable that we whiffed on him. how can Fox's strategy for recruiting be to 'narrow' the field and focus on guys 'we can get', and then whiff on someone we could've gotten in our own backyard? pathetic and sad and what a failure on our part.
Mahaney was actually in St. Mary's backyard...but yeah.
My nephew is on the team at St. Mary's. What a difference their program is compared to Cal's.
Aiden has ice in his veins. Who has that with Cal?
Cal BB is a laughing stock. The Bay is run by St. Mary's. They are too 10 in the country.
Aiden has ice in his veins. Who has that with Cal?
Cal BB is a laughing stock. The Bay is run by St. Mary's. They are too 10 in the country.
I knew it was the final straw for the current regime when we whiffed on Mahaney, then also whiffed on the guy that Fox supposedly wanted as much or more than Mahaney.
Please don: Somebody's gonna post that they knew it was the final straw for the current regime when the current regime was first hired. Whatever (but me too).
Looking ahead to better days!
Part of the Campolindo High School pipeline. Their FB team has done very well also for many years, they have 2 state titles. Great place to go to high school for both athletes and academics. A member myself, but not in athletics. LOL
Start Slowly and taper off
Civil Bear said:eastcoastcal said:
Unforgivable that we whiffed on him. how can Fox's strategy for recruiting be to 'narrow' the field and focus on guys 'we can get', and then whiff on someone we could've gotten in our own backyard? pathetic and sad and what a failure on our part.
Mahaney was actually in St. Mary's backyard...but yeah.
Mahoney has had a long connection with Kyle Smith and considered WSU. If had hired Smith, or Golden or any of the other guys in Bennet's coaching tree (yeah, even Magpayo) we probably land him.
What's crazy is supposedly his mom wanted him to go to Cal. And according to the BI report if we'd made contact 6 months earlier, we'd have gotten him. It's even crazier that this happened with our recruiting strategy being to NOT relentlessly recruit and cast a wide net, but instead keep a narrow focus on kids we can get. So what the hell were our staff doing??calumnus said:Civil Bear said:eastcoastcal said:
Unforgivable that we whiffed on him. how can Fox's strategy for recruiting be to 'narrow' the field and focus on guys 'we can get', and then whiff on someone we could've gotten in our own backyard? pathetic and sad and what a failure on our part.
Mahaney was actually in St. Mary's backyard...but yeah.
Mahoney has had a long connection with Kyle Smith and considered WSU. If had hired Smith, or Golden or any of the other guys in Bennet's coaching tree (yeah, even Magpayo) we probably land him.
It just makes me unbelievably mad because there is no good reason why our program can't be in Saint Mary's position- a top 25 team that can compete and win vs programs like Gonzaga while recruiting top 100 players and maintaining a great international pipeline. Unfortunately we're stuck with a head coach who's answer to everything is injuries and a staff who clearly can't identify, develop, or retain talent.
I'm counting the days til we fire everyone involved in this pathetic endeavor and clean house completely
eastcoastcal said:What's crazy is supposedly his mom wanted him to go to Cal. And according to the BI report if we'd made contact 6 months earlier, we'd have gotten him. It's even crazier that this happened with our recruiting strategy being to NOT relentlessly recruit and cast a wide net, but instead keep a narrow focus on kids we can get. So what the hell were our staff doing??calumnus said:Civil Bear said:eastcoastcal said:
Unforgivable that we whiffed on him. how can Fox's strategy for recruiting be to 'narrow' the field and focus on guys 'we can get', and then whiff on someone we could've gotten in our own backyard? pathetic and sad and what a failure on our part.
Mahaney was actually in St. Mary's backyard...but yeah.
Mahoney has had a long connection with Kyle Smith and considered WSU. If had hired Smith, or Golden or any of the other guys in Bennet's coaching tree (yeah, even Magpayo) we probably land him.
It just makes me unbelievably mad because there is no good reason why our program can't be in Saint Mary's position- a top 25 team that can compete and win vs programs like Gonzaga while recruiting top 100 players and maintaining a great international pipeline. Unfortunately we're stuck with a head coach who's answer to everything is injuries and a staff who clearly can't identify, develop, or retain talent.
I'm counting the days til we fire everyone involved in this pathetic endeavor and clean house completely
One of the reasons we were told we took Bowser and Robertson was to get Lewis and Mahaney. But no one bothered to contact Mahaney?
Mark Few on #SMC’s Aidan Mahaney (16 pts. after half): “He hit some tough runners & we tried everybody on the roster on him & he hit them over our best defender, which is Anton. He hit three of them over him. Those are tough shots & he hit them, so he deserves a lot of credit.” pic.twitter.com/ZPJanuLkyp
— Theo Lawson (@TheoLawson_SR) February 5, 2023
irvinebear said:
My nephew is on the team at St. Mary's. What a difference their program is compared to Cal's.
Aiden has ice in his veins. Who has that with Cal?
Cal BB is a laughing stock. The Bay is run by St. Mary's. They are too 10 in the country.
Can you confirm this: a buddy of mine allegedly in the know told me Bennett had Mahaney locked up to be a Gael as far back as grammar school and Cal was never going to be in the equation.
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside
bearister said:irvinebear said:
My nephew is on the team at St. Mary's. What a difference their program is compared to Cal's.
Aiden has ice in his veins. Who has that with Cal?
Cal BB is a laughing stock. The Bay is run by St. Mary's. They are too 10 in the country.
Can you confirm this: a buddy of mine allegedly in the know told me Bennett had Mahaney locked up to be a Gael as far back as grammar school and Cal was never going to be in the equation.
This makes a lot more sense. The reality is their program is light years ahead of ours. If a kid in the class of 2022 wanted to stay in the Bay, we would be lucky to be the third choice.
Lets see:
St Marys - your best friend's dad is the coach, you can walk home in 5 minutes and do your laundry, they have a good team
CAL - team sucks, coach is about to be fired
choices, choices
St Marys - your best friend's dad is the coach, you can walk home in 5 minutes and do your laundry, they have a good team
CAL - team sucks, coach is about to be fired
choices, choices
Perhaps Associate HC, UCSB grad, and Bay Area native Justin Joyner is one to keep an eye on.calumnus said:Civil Bear said:eastcoastcal said:
Unforgivable that we whiffed on him. how can Fox's strategy for recruiting be to 'narrow' the field and focus on guys 'we can get', and then whiff on someone we could've gotten in our own backyard? pathetic and sad and what a failure on our part.
Mahaney was actually in St. Mary's backyard...but yeah.
Mahoney has had a long connection with Kyle Smith and considered WSU. If had hired Smith, or Golden or any of the other guys in Bennet's coaching tree (yeah, even Magpayo) we probably land him.
https://smcgaels.com/sports/mens-basketball/roster/coaches/justin-joyner/1423
My understanding is that Cal was in the mix. But lots of significant connections to SMC for a long time, as you mention.
SMC's program just does so many things right. At present moment, there just really isn't a comparison to be drawn to Cal and it's a shame.
At least 3 of Cal's FB players (Anderson, Ott and Hunter) were all at the SMC game last night. How disappointing they can't see a game of that caliber at Haas.
SMC's program just does so many things right. At present moment, there just really isn't a comparison to be drawn to Cal and it's a shame.
At least 3 of Cal's FB players (Anderson, Ott and Hunter) were all at the SMC game last night. How disappointing they can't see a game of that caliber at Haas.
It could be worse:graguna said:
Lets see:
St Marys - your best friend's dad is the coach, you can walk home in 5 minutes and do your laundry, they have a good team
CAL - team sucks, coach is about to be fired
choices, choices
CAL - team sucks, coach is about to be extended
irvinebear said:
My understanding is that Cal was in the mix. But lots of significant connections to SMC for a long time, as you mention.
SMC's program just does so many things right. At present moment, there just really isn't a comparison to be drawn to Cal and it's a shame.
At least 3 of Cal's FB players (Anderson, Ott and Hunter) were all at the SMC game last night. How disappointing they can't see a game of that caliber at Haas.
Now that is truly sad. I remember in the Montgomery years there was a game against UCLA where the entire football team was right behind one of the baskets....and we won that game.
With regards to mahaney - it would not have mattered...he would not have grown as a player under fox and we would have labeled him a bust.
Ask Knowlton who Mahaney is and he won't even know. He doesn't follow the sport closely.
40 year decision though.graguna said:
Lets see:
St Marys - your best friend's dad is the coach, you can walk home in 5 minutes and do your laundry, they have a good team
CAL - team sucks, coach is about to be fired
choices, choices
https://www.forbes.com/top-colleges/
If Mahaney was at Cal, he'd probably be sitting on the bench "injured".
Gael donor base is hoops focused. Cal donors are primarily interested in football and then spread around. So in comparison perhaps out of touch basketball-wise. To overcome this, leadership has to come from the AD, an ex hockey player military engineer from Massachusetts.irvinebear said:
SMC's program just does so many things right. At present moment, there just really isn't a comparison to be drawn to Cal and it's a shame.
Yeah, and during that time I remember seeing Tedford and Dykes occasionally attending a Cal basketball game in Haas. In fact, a couple of times Dykes was attending with his entire family. I have never seen Wilcox at a Cal basketball game.Econ141 said:
Now that is truly sad. I remember in the Montgomery years there was a game against UCLA where the entire football team was right behind one of the baskets....and we won that game.
bearister said:irvinebear said:
My nephew is on the team at St. Mary's. What a difference their program is compared to Cal's.
Aiden has ice in his veins. Who has that with Cal?
Cal BB is a laughing stock. The Bay is run by St. Mary's. They are too 10 in the country.
Can you confirm this: a buddy of mine allegedly in the know told me Bennett had Mahaney locked up to be a Gael as far back as grammar school and Cal was never going to be in the equation.
Well, the Gaels obviously had a major "in" with Mahaney, being right in his backyard, him growing up playing and goofing around with Bennett's son and playing pick-up in their gym.
But as far as him being "locked up", no way. It's a wonderful place to grow up (and to live), but by the time a kid's a senior at Campo, they're often looking to spread their wings and experience life away from Moraga.
Unfortunately, the Cal Basketball program is just too much in the doldrums right now to appear attractive. Mahaney's been keeping an eye on a lame Cal program now for six years, almost a third of his life. To him, the days when guys like Ivan Rabb and Jaylen Brown would come to Cal must seem like eons ago.
Golden One said:Yeah, and during that time I remember seeing Tedford and Dykes occasionally attending a Cal basketball game in Haas. In fact, a couple of times Dykes was attending with his entire family. I have never seen Wilcox at a Cal basketball game.Econ141 said:
Now that is truly sad. I remember in the Montgomery years there was a game against UCLA where the entire football team was right behind one of the baskets....and we won that game.
Well to be fair to Wilcox, the basketball offense is harder to watch than his.
Joined:
Jul 13, 2008
Posts:
53,772
User Profile
Private Message
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
Not here to defend Fox as a coach or recruiter in the slightest but they recruited Mahaney hard from the earliest they were able to do so according to NCAA rules. As some have alluded to, he grew up playing hoops with Bennett's sons and spent a lot of time at the Bennett house over the years.
Maheney's mom went to Stanford so I doubt she was hoping he'd go to Cal.
A friend and I talked to Bennett for around a half hour a few months ago when we ran into him in Moraga and the way he talked, he would have been very surprised if they didn't get him.
Here's a video interview I did with Mahaney in 2020:
Maheney's mom went to Stanford so I doubt she was hoping he'd go to Cal.
A friend and I talked to Bennett for around a half hour a few months ago when we ran into him in Moraga and the way he talked, he would have been very surprised if they didn't get him.
Here's a video interview I did with Mahaney in 2020:
Econ141 said:Golden One said:Yeah, and during that time I remember seeing Tedford and Dykes occasionally attending a Cal basketball game in Haas. In fact, a couple of times Dykes was attending with his entire family. I have never seen Wilcox at a Cal basketball game.Econ141 said:
Now that is truly sad. I remember in the Montgomery years there was a game against UCLA where the entire football team was right behind one of the baskets....and we won that game.
Well to be fair to Wilcox, the basketball offense is harder to watch than his.
Hopefully both will be MUCH better with new coaches leading them this Fall.
MoragaBear said:
Not here to defend Fox as a coach or recruiter in the slightest but they recruited Mahaney hard from the earliest they were able to do so according to NCAA rules. As some have alluded to, he grew up playing hoops with Bennett's sons and spent a lot of time at the Bennett house over the years.
Maheney's mom went to Stanford so I doubt she was hoping he'd go to Cal.
A friend and I talked to Bennett for around a half hour a few months ago when we ran into him in Moraga and the way he talked, he would have been very surprised if they didn't get him.
Here's a video interview I did with Mahaney in 2020:
It is just such a "what if" situation. We will never know how attractive a different coach, maybe even one who has also known Mahaney for years when he was an assistant at St. Mary's, and a winning, exciting Cal program would be to him. As it stands, it was no contest.
Joined:
Jul 13, 2008
Posts:
53,772
User Profile
Private Message
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
The fact that Cal plays in the Pac-12 and had his teammate and friend Roberson committed helped but not as much as a winning program and good coach would've helped.calumnus said:MoragaBear said:
Not here to defend Fox as a coach or recruiter in the slightest but they recruited Mahaney hard from the earliest they were able to do so according to NCAA rules. As some have alluded to, he grew up playing hoops with Bennett's sons and spent a lot of time at the Bennett house over the years.
Maheney's mom went to Stanford so I doubt she was hoping he'd go to Cal.
A friend and I talked to Bennett for around a half hour a few months ago when we ran into him in Moraga and the way he talked, he would have been very surprised if they didn't get him.
Here's a video interview I did with Mahaney in 2020:
It is just such a "what if" situation. We will never know how attractive a different coach, maybe even one who has also known Mahaney for years when he was an assistant at St. Mary's, and a winning, exciting Cal program would be to him. As it stands, it was no contest.
I'll also add that I would know a lot more about Cal hoops recruiting but I've never been allowed to talk to a single assistant even once in Fox's whole tenure at Cal and as far as I know, that's the case with all media.
Thanks for posting the video MB! Is this non-access policy the norm for college basketball and/or past Cal HCs? Or is this a Fox policyMoragaBear said:The fact that Cal plays in the Pac-12 and had his teammate and friend Roberson committed helped but not as much as a winning program and good coach would've helped.calumnus said:MoragaBear said:
Not here to defend Fox as a coach or recruiter in the slightest but they recruited Mahaney hard from the earliest they were able to do so according to NCAA rules. As some have alluded to, he grew up playing hoops with Bennett's sons and spent a lot of time at the Bennett house over the years.
Maheney's mom went to Stanford so I doubt she was hoping he'd go to Cal.
A friend and I talked to Bennett for around a half hour a few months ago when we ran into him in Moraga and the way he talked, he would have been very surprised if they didn't get him.
Here's a video interview I did with Mahaney in 2020:
It is just such a "what if" situation. We will never know how attractive a different coach, maybe even one who has also known Mahaney for years when he was an assistant at St. Mary's, and a winning, exciting Cal program would be to him. As it stands, it was no contest.
I'll also add that I would know a lot more about Cal hoops recruiting but I've never been allowed to talk to a single assistant even once in Fox's whole tenure at Cal and as far as I know, that's the case with all media.
Joined:
Jul 13, 2008
Posts:
53,772
User Profile
Private Message
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
eastcoastcal said:Thanks for posting the video MB! Is this non-acess policy the norm for college basketball and/or past Cal HCs? Or is this a Fox policyMoragaBear said:The fact that Cal plays in the Pac-12 and had his teammate and friend Roberson committed helped but not as much as a winning program and good coach would've helped.calumnus said:MoragaBear said:
Not here to defend Fox as a coach or recruiter in the slightest but they recruited Mahaney hard from the earliest they were able to do so according to NCAA rules. As some have alluded to, he grew up playing hoops with Bennett's sons and spent a lot of time at the Bennett house over the years.
Maheney's mom went to Stanford so I doubt she was hoping he'd go to Cal.
A friend and I talked to Bennett for around a half hour a few months ago when we ran into him in Moraga and the way he talked, he would have been very surprised if they didn't get him.
Here's a video interview I did with Mahaney in 2020:
It is just such a "what if" situation. We will never know how attractive a different coach, maybe even one who has also known Mahaney for years when he was an assistant at St. Mary's, and a winning, exciting Cal program would be to him. As it stands, it was no contest.
I'll also add that I would know a lot more about Cal hoops recruiting but I've never been allowed to talk to a single assistant even once in Fox's whole tenure at Cal and as far as I know, that's the case with all media.
It's pretty unusual. I doubt there are any other HCs or at best more than a handful of HCs in the country that handle the media this way. I've been doing this 20 years and have had far more access to any other staff than this one. When he took over at Cal, I talked to the editor of the Georgia site in our network who was actually a former player who was tied in with lots of other former players and he completely shut them out, too.
They should have tied it to his contract and then cut his pay each time he violated the media access terms …ultimately leading to the doomsday sanction of termination for cause.
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside
Ok. I get that this is a fan board but my membership is on par with a newspaper subscription. Staff wrote
"According to multiple sources, despite growing up in Cal's backyard, Fox slow-played Mahaney as he was unsure he was a Pac-12-level player. Only when Fox missed on two other combo guards he coveted more highly than Mahaney did he turn his attention to the Campolindo star. It was too little, too late as Mahaney felt far more comfortable with Randy Bennet who had made him a priority going back to his sophomore year in high school. One source close to Mahaney shared that had Fox gone all in on Mahaney just 6 months earlier, the Gaels' leading scorer would now be in Berkeley:"
If the editor/owner doesn't believe that is correct it shouldn't be published. If it is a situation that you have different sources than eric than you should have asked him to include. As is we have no ability to know what is true. Honestly. Do better.
"According to multiple sources, despite growing up in Cal's backyard, Fox slow-played Mahaney as he was unsure he was a Pac-12-level player. Only when Fox missed on two other combo guards he coveted more highly than Mahaney did he turn his attention to the Campolindo star. It was too little, too late as Mahaney felt far more comfortable with Randy Bennet who had made him a priority going back to his sophomore year in high school. One source close to Mahaney shared that had Fox gone all in on Mahaney just 6 months earlier, the Gaels' leading scorer would now be in Berkeley:"
If the editor/owner doesn't believe that is correct it shouldn't be published. If it is a situation that you have different sources than eric than you should have asked him to include. As is we have no ability to know what is true. Honestly. Do better.
Take care of your Chicken
Joined:
Jul 13, 2008
Posts:
53,772
User Profile
Private Message
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
Note that I said that I have no contacts at all on staff regarding recruiting so there was no way of knowing how much of a priority he was during the recruiting process or if he was being slow played. My post was mainly to counter the idea that he wasn't recruited at all that some seem to be expressing and obviously from the interview that wasn't the case.
MoragaBear said:
Note that I said that I have no contacts at all on staff regarding recruiting so there was no way of knowing how much of a priority he was during the recruiting process or if he was being slow played. My post was mainly to counter the idea that he wasn't recruited at all that some seem to be expressing and obviously from the interview that wasn't the case.
Fair. I know you guys are not journalists by profession. It is a pet peeve that a lot of things taken for granted in the news sections (multiple sourcing, editorial approval, etc) get tossed in sports. I appreciate you guys trying
Take care of your Chicken
Featured Stories
See All
Mendoza Named ACC Quarterback Of The Week
by Cal Athletics
Bears Slip By Sac State, 83-77
by Jim McGill
The Rodcast: The Greatest Drive Ever?
by Rod Benson
Cal Hosts Stanford In 127th Big Game
by Cal Athletics