I don't know how to define the best recruits. If it is recruit ranking, then that leaves out all the great Cal players who played before recruit rankings were made, or made public. That leaves out about 70 years of Cal basketball players. It should be based on success. Some fans believe it might be individual success, some might believe it is team success, and others might believe it is both individual and team success. I happen to value team success more than individual success, so here is my list of the best Bay Area Cal players I could find. Reference to All-Conference or All-Coast is to the first team awards only.
Bay Area Cal players who won championships, ranked by the championship and their contribution:
Bob Dalton, San Leandro, 2 x PCC Champion, NCAA Champion, NCAA Elite 8
Dick Doughty, Oakland, 2x PCC Champion, NCAA Champion, NCAA Final Four
Bernie Simpson, St Ignatius, PCC Champion, NCAA Champion, NCAA Elite 8
Jim Langley, Salinas High, PCC Champion, NCAA Champion, NCAA Elite 8
Bobby Wendell, Menlo, PCC Champion, NCAA Champion, NCAA Runner Up
Jerry Mann, Washington of SF, 2x PCC Champion, NCAA Champion, NCAA Runner up
Andy Wolfe, Richmond, 1st team All-American 1948, PCC Champion, NCAA Final Four
Bob Hogeboom, Oakland, PCC Champion, NCAA Final Four
Earl Robinson, Berkeley, 2x All-Coast, 2x PCC Champions, 2x NCAA Elite 8, MLB (Historic-first African-American player to start for Cal)
George Sterling, Oakland, PCC Champion, NCAA Elite 8
Ev McKeen, Piedmont, PCC Champion, NCAA Elite 8
Vern Corbin, Piedmont, 1st team All-American 1929, All-PCC, 3x PCC Champions
Theo Robertson, De La Salle, Concord, PAC10 Champion
Other great Bay Area Cal players ranked by the highest individual awards won:
Jason Kidd, Oakland, 1st team All-American, 1994, PAC10 Player of the Year, NBA
Rusty Critchfield, Salinas, 1st team All-American, 1968, 2nd team AA 1967, 2x All-PCC
Bob McKeen, Piedmont, 2nd team All-American, 1953, 3rd team 1954, 1955, All-Coast
Leon Powe, 2nd team All-American, 2006, 2x All-PAC10, NBA
Ryan Anderson, 2nd team All-American, All-PAC10, 2008
Lamond Murray, Fremont, 3rd team All-American 1994, 2x All-PAC10, NBA
Bob Matheny, Lowell of SF, 3rd team All-American, 1954
Kevin Johnson, Sacramento, All-Conference 1986, 1987, NBA
Charles Johnson, Redwood City, All-Conference 1969, NBA
Phil Chenier, Berkeley, All-Conference 1971, NBA
Mark McNamara, Del Ray of San Jose, All-PAC10 Conference 1982, NBA
Ansley Truitt, Wilson of SF, All-Conference, 1972, ABA
Ivan Rabb, Oakland, All-PAC12, 2017, NBA
Doug True, Concord, All-Conference 1980
John Ricksen, Berkeley High, All-PCC Conference, 1953
Ayinde Ubaka, Oakland, All-PAC10, 2006
Some more good to very good Bay Area Cal players, listed alphabetically:
Bob Albo, Berkeley
Jabari Bird, Vallejo
Monty Buckley, Sacramento
John Caselli, South San Francisco
John Coughran, San Jose, NBA
Mike Diaz, Armijo High, Fairfield, (set single season NorCal HS scoring record)
Bill Hagler, SF
Chuck Hanger, Berkeley
Devon Hardin, Fremont
Marquise Kately, Riordan of SF
Grover Klemmer, Galileo
Don Lauer, Berkeley
Denny Lewis, Lincoln of SF
Eric Long, Stockton
Dan Lufkin, Alameda
Ted Ohashi, Stockton (Historic first Japanese-American to start for Cal)
Robby Olson, El Camino
Charlie Perkins, Alameda
Gene Ransom, Berkeley
Rupe Ricksen, Berkeley High
Kevin Singleton, Oakland
Dick Smith, Gilroy
Jim Smith, Santa Cruz
Michael Stewart, Sacramento, NBA
Dick Tamberg, San Francisco
Camden Wall, Los Gatos
There were a lot of good or great Bay Area Cal players from earlier eras which are left out of this list because I could not find either the name of their high school or their town to prove they were Bay Area boys. The list is only a starting point. I probably let out some others by mistake.
Only two of Cal's Bay Area Players who won high individual awards, Vern Corbin and Andy Wolfe, won a conference championship. And Cal's greatest team player, Jason Kidd, IMO, did not win a championship at Cal. He had won consecutive state high school championships before coming to Cal, and won only one championship in his long NBA career. He was seldom blessed with either the coaching and/or the teammates to enable him to win championships, and that was tragic in a basketball sense. Have fun with the list.
SFCityBear