SFCityBear said:
Big C said:
I'm not sure what people expect...
1. mostly slim pickin's left from the 2019 prep class
2. new staff, still with damage to repair from the old staff, and not super-highly regarded in their own right
3. hard as heck to get grad transfers here
4. wary (and rightly so) of "pulling a Chauca/Winston/McCullough"
We'll be lucky to fill 1-2 holes this spring. A big guy and a shooter who could both crack next year's rotation would be great.
I agree with all of this. As for #3, it is hard , but it is doable. Cuonzo got Tarwater in his first season and Mullins in his final season as coach. Mullins was a good player.
Historically speaking, if you're looking at Cal, it has been difficult for coaches in their first season to land an impact player. Freshmen were first allowed to play in the 1972-3 season, which happened to be Dick Edwards' first season as coach. He landed Ricky Hawthorne, and exciting player who became an immediate starter. Dick Kuchen landed Kevin Sparks, who also became a starter as a freshman. Campanelli did not land any recruits of note in his first season, except possibly Jon Wheeler, who was a starter in his second and final season at Cal. Ben Braun landed only part time player Sean Jackson and several walk-ons. Mike Montgomery landed only Jorge Gutierrez who turned out to be a diamond in the rough, the best recruit ever landed by a Cal coach in his first year, IMO. Cuonzo Martin landed a decent project in Kinglsey Okoroh, and a real bust in Brandon Chauca. Wyking Jones landed a decent player in McNeill, along with McCollugh and Winston, who were busts.
So it is a short list, and if we look at history, a Cal coach in his first season would be fortunate to get one player who could contribute. On the other hand, it has been done. It is possible to get an impact player like Hawthorne, Jorge, or Sparks. I don't know who is starting with a weaker roster, Jones or Fox, but if Fox adds one good impact recruit, plus a couple of walkons, that would make a 10-12 man roster. He is a likely a few years away from having a rotation of decent D1 players, unless he gets the portal players back. I hope they are still talking with him.
You are generally correct, but your point is even more correct point if you don't overstate the contribution of a player recruited for the first season of a coach. It is kind of funny to see you list Kevin Sparks as an "impact" player in the same sentence with Jorge Gutierrez or even Ricky Hawthorne. While Sparks was a starter off and on during the 78-79 season, it wasn't due to his being an "impact player" so much as the absence of anyone of quality to play PG (when Kuchen was hired, Gene Ransom and Tyrone Davis were both expected to be playing in 78-79 but both were lost to academics).
Sparks got starts out of desperation, not out of being an impact player. Sparks was still on the team in 79-80, but he didn't get meaningful playing time, even on a team that went 3-15 in conference, and he did not come back after that season.
If you can get lucky to recruit a Ricky Hawthorne or a Jorge Gutierrez before the first season of coaching, great. If you're getting Kevin Sparks level players, well, that may be a
little better than Chauca or McCullough or Winston, but surely not much.
I will say, however, that given the lack of point guards on the team, I was truly concerned when, over winter break 78-79, I almost killed Kevin Sparks. I was turning right to go northbound onto College Avenue from Forrest Ave. at night. I'm looking for vehicles to my left, and when it was clear, I turned. As I'm accelerating making my turn coming onto College, there was a bicyclist riding on the wrong side of the road going southbound on College in the dark, with dark clothing and no lights, and we're about to collide. As we both made sudden maneuvers to avoid a collision and both stopped, having barely avoided a crash, I realized that the guy riding the wrong way in the dark with no lights was Kevin Sparks. Yeah, he wasn't very good, but still, we needed him, and it would have hurt the team if he had been killed or seriously injured. My quick reaction that night was probably my greatest contribution to Cal basketball in 45 seasons of being a fan.