BleacherBear;842278639 said:
If you do not attend games anymore, and do not observe player-coach interactions, how do you know what's going on?
Well, I attended every WBB home game for 16 years and excluding a couple of games missed due to surgery, that streak would have gone back a few more years. So I bring a lot more past knowledge than just about anyone else on this board. I still watch the games on TV and still talk with fans who do attend all the games and the chalk talks. They are also longtime followers of this program, they are not Pollyannas, they don't believe the BS and the cliches, they read between the lines, and they watch the pregame and sideline interaction. (Sometimes I tell them what to look for and to report back.) Collectively that gives me plenty of current information (though my friends too confess to being blindsided by Hind's departure).
You might also look back at the threads when Joanne left and we were looking for a new coach. While everyone else was wandering around in the dark, I gave everyone a lot of specific info about Gottlieb's performance at UCSB based on actually watching a lot of the Gaucho games. This wasn't just a win-loss report that's typically found on this board, but a report on her interactions with her assistants, her gametime coaching style and ability, what I saw as far as player effort, and a complete report on the players who left the program and why and any mitigating circumstances. Those fans who fawn over Gottlieb and hang on her every word now may feel like they know her, but I still know more based on watching her evolve (and in some respects NOT evolve) from an assistant to a head coach at UCSB to a head coach here. Seeing the ways in which a person has NOT matured can give you some great clues as to her persistent blind spots, problems that have a very real impact on how she runs her team both on and off the court.
Quote:
I don't think many people on this board are basing our impressions of the program based on a Pollyanna view of the program, or have swallowed the Kool Aid wholeheartedly. Many of us have a positive impression of things (mostly) because we actually attend games, can watch these interactions, work on campus so see the kids/staff/coaches informally, and/or actually KNOW some of the players and their families. It's certainly not all unicorns and rainbows, but it says something good about the program that teammates hang out together, in various combos and all together of their volition, and that they all attended the recent We A.R.E. Pride event (along with all of the coaches and many current and former support staff).
That all sounds like Pollyanna to me. The fact that you know some of the players and families means little as far as understanding the team-wide dynamic (and in fact may distort your perspective in favor of certain viewpoints). I don't want to search thru your posting history, but I distinctly recall that your LIMITED interaction with SOME players and families led you to an incorrect assessment of what was going on in Gottlieb's first season. You implied that everyone was happy when in fact it was very clear that at least two players were extremely unhappy at the time (not necessarily the ones who later left). This unhappiness was evident in a very public way at one of the home games. How did you miss that if you are a keen observer of the interactions at the games? I have to think it was because you saw what you wanted to see, and because they were not the players with whom you conversed (at least not in any meaningful way).
Quote:
Also, Wayne, what exactly is "worrisome" about all of our recent transfers? 2 followed Coach G to Santa Barbara (one of whom would never have seen the court in 4 years at Cal); 1 left to become a hairdresser (which would have happened no matter where she went); 1 left to seek greener pastures at Kentucky (and is still friends with many of her teammates and coaches and came to graduation last year); and the 3 are a little more mysterious. Not a one of them would I necessarily want to have back here--their departures gave other players chances (Fu, younger post players) to grow and shine and become key cogs in the Final Four run. How are any of these transfers different from why other people leave other schools?
Wow, I expect that type of summary from others but not you. I'm really disappointed in you. I'm not going to thoroughly describe every circumstance and incident, but can you not see that the key to characterizing player departures is to think back to what happened BEFORE they left? Was there something troubling about the circumstances that led them to believe they had to leave the program, sometimes in mid-semester? If you are a dedicated and knowledgeable fan, I would have believed that you gave each departure a good amount of thought when it happened, but from that summary it seems like you didn't.
But OK, I'll give you some clues to think about. I do remember (but of course do not thoroughly understand) the circumstances of every transfer or early departure from Cal WBB since 1990, and follow many other WBB programs, so I have a good frame of reference for what constitutes a somewhat normal vs. a troubling pattern of departures. Pooh-poohing two departures just because they ended up at UCSB is totally ridiculous. Do you not remember all the bad signs from that 2008-09 season, team divisions at a very personal level that you could see right on the court during gametime? Problems that got worse and worse as the season progressed? Problems that Joanne either ignored or couldn't handle? If you say you're close to some players, then conversations with certain players would have hinted rather openly at the problems. I don't expect people to remember as many details as I do, but that was one long unhappy season for Kelsey Adrian (and anyone who tries to pass it off on the shoulder injury or her stats is just flat-out unobservant). Her later comments after leaving confirmed that and thankfully (for her, not us) she escaped from Cal. Angelei Aguirre is the transfer that troubled me the most, not necessarily for her treatment during the season (she seemed largely ignored) but for what happened afterwards. BleacherBear, if you don't remember or never knew (and if you ignored my hint that I posted way back when) you can still find half the story on the internet. You have to put two-and-two together (and not be a Pollyanna) to figure out the other half. Casey Morris' departure made me sad but was at least more in keeping with a "normal" transfer, and if you know the local players and families I'm sure you've heard the stories (both during her one season and afterwards).
Similarly, you said you knew DeNesha Stallworth's family so you've heard enough of that story. To be honest, I never really felt like you understood how she stood with her teammates at the time, but if everything is happy now then great.
Dismissing Brenna Heater's departure with the hairdresser comment is really beneath you. Again, think back BEFORE her departure - as a keen observer, did you not see there was something wrong with the way she was being treated (and again, don't look at stats - I'm not talking about playing time). You can find hints of the story on the internet but understand that it was much more troubling to watch it unfold as it happened vs. scanning and dismissing it many weeks or months after the fact. And as with Hind, a mid-semester departure is not a normal departure at all.
How on earth you can say Lindsay Sherbert's transfer was mysterious is beyond me. The unobservant have to rely on stats and insults, but if you really attended the games and watched the interaction, how could you say it was mysterious? Think back to the Triple Threat open practice of 11/19/11 (if you attended) and the home game of 11/20/11 (and the incident which made me think that Gottlieb was on her way to losing not just Sherbert but another player who did in fact stay to graduation). Things got even worse, but to Gottlieb's credit she did try briefly and half-heartedly to salvage the situation. To Sherbert's greater credit, she endured the whole awful season and finished the academic year, making Academic All-Pac-12 Honorable Mention. Thank goodness she didn't try to endure more and I'm delighted to see her now playing for a system that suits her (and with teammates who respect her).
I'll admit I don't know why Erika Johnson left but at least I'm in good company because our coaching staff apparently didn't know either. A troubling sign of total non-communication by our staff.
Sorry if I come across harshly, but that speaks more to my expectations based on your past contributions to this board. I hope you post more often, because even though I don't read this board regularly any more, it would still be comforting to know that you're trying to add your thoughtfulness to this public face of the program.