We've got two true lights-out sprinters at the top of a class that's ultimately built on distance swimmers with scary-good improvement curves.WAY TOO EARLY NCAA RECRUIT RANKS: GIRLS HIGH SCHOOL CLASS OF 2021THIS CLASS- Not as good as last year's but that's hardly a fair comparison
- A few outstanding sprinters at the top
- Much more thin in backstroke than last year
- A good class for distance free particularly fast-rising talents
- Deep breaststroke class but who will be the top one?
This class isn't as dominant as last year's group but that's to-be-expected, considering the class of 2020 is easily the best recruiting class we've seen since the high school crew of 2014, and might even be the best we've ever ranked. This 2021 group does offer some great value, though, as its strengths complement the 2020 class very well.
Where the 2020 class is built on fly/back types who can also sprint in free, the 2021 class has two elite true sprint recruits at the top:
Gretchen Walsh and
Torri Huske. Both are already sub-22 in the 50 free, and even considering we ranked most of these classes as juniors, we haven't seen a 21-second sprint prospect out of high school (through their junior year) since Abbey Weitzeil in the class of 2015. Huske is probably best in the 100 fly and Walsh a more true 50/100 free sprinter, but both are excellent through the relay distance freestyles and strokes.
On the other hand, it seems like most of the great backstrokers in this age bracket congregated together in the class of 2020. Beyond Walsh (a 51.5 backstroker) the backstrokes are relatively thin in this class, especially for true two-distance backstrokers. That's actually true of most strokes there aren't a lot of standouts in both the 100 and 200, but a lot of great times in one or the other, which suggests some ability to bring around either the speed or the endurance over the remaining two years of high school.
The 2020 class was also thin in distance free, and this class is the opposite. We've got two distance types in our top 5, and three more inside the top 20. A lot of the top distance talents are either relatively new to the mile, or have dropped significant time in the past year, so keep an eye on this class to potentially become historically good in the distances.
There's no clarity in breaststroke it's a deep class without one true standout. The class in general is better at the 100 breast than the 200, but there are still no sub-minute nor sub-2:10 breaststrokers as of yet. The door is certainly open for one of the current top talents to break out and take charge of the top breaststroker mantle, and the resulting bump in recruiting value.
TOP TIMES IN THE CLASS OF 202150 Free | #1 Gretchen Walsh | 21.82
100 Free | #1 Gretchen Walsh | 47.49
200 Free | #1 Gretchen Walsh | 1:44.91
500 Free | #4 Paige McKenna | 4:41.21
1000 Free** | #4 Paige McKenna | 9:35.99
1650 Free | #4 Paige McKenna | 15:48.07
100 Back | #1 Gretchen Walsh | 51.57
200 Back | #6 Riley Tiltmann | 1:54.18
100 Breast | #11 Asia Minnes | 1:00.61
200 Breast | #8 Brooke Zettel | 2:12.00
100 Fly | #2 Torri Huske | 51.29
200 Fly | #1 Grace Sheble | 1:54.18
200 IM | #3 Grace Sheble | 1:57.00
400 IM | #3 Grace Sheble | 4:06.35
TOP 20 SWIMMERS FROM THE CLASS OF 20211.
Gretchen Walsh: Nashville Aquatic Club - Harpeth Hall High School - Nashville, TN
Best Times: 50 free 21.82, 100 free 47.49, 200 free 1:44.91, 100 back 51.57, 100 fly 52.23, 200 IM 1:58.15It's the second straight year we've got a Walsh sister in our top two. Gretchen is the top value in this class, in part because she already has two times that would have made NCAA A finals this past year, and in part because of how valuable those two events the 50 and 100 free are in the NCAA format. Between her class-best 100 back and 200 free, Walsh is a three-event, four-relay powerhouse coming in the door, and should be a massive, massive recruiting pull for whichever program can sign her.
2.
Torri Huske: Arlington Aquatic Club - Yorktown High School - Arlington, VA
Best Times: 100 fly 51.29, 50 free 21.95, 200 fly 1:56.18, 100 free 48.70, 200 free 1:46.66, 200 IM 1:58.13Huske is another huge sprint talent in this class. She projects more as a two-distance flyer who could also cross over into freestyle perhaps a Kelsi Dahlia type. She's got the best 100 fly in the class by more than a full second, and her 50 free is only a tenth behind Walsh. As we noted above, 21-second freestylers are exceedingly rare out of high school, much less this early in their high school careers. Huske is also improving very fast her freestyles have dropped from 22.3/50.3/1:49.1 over the past year, and her 200 fly from 2:01.1.
3.
Grace Sheble: NOVA of Virginia - James River High School - North Chesterfield, VA
Best Times: 200 fly 1:54.84, 400 IM 4:06.35, 200 IM 1:57.00, 200 free 1:46.88, 100 free 50.61, 500 free 4:45.26, 200 breast 2:15.32, 100 breast 1:01.75Where Walsh and Huske handle the sprintier events, Sheble is the class's premiere mid-distance stroker and IMer. She's got times that would've already scored at NCAAs in the 400 IM and 200 fly, and is only about a second off of A final level in the IM. Sheble has remarkable versatility she should be an 800 free relay threat down the road, and could even fill in on medley relays as a breaststroker for a team really in a pinch. She's got a very natural NCAA event combo: 200/400 IM and 200 fly, and she's the best in her class in all three events.
4.
Paige McKenna: Nation's Capital Swim Club - Easton, PA
Best Times: 1650 free 15:48.07, 1000 free 9:35.99, 500 free 4:41.21, 200 free 1:47.36The top four in our rankings cover the top times in the class in 11 of 14 events. The three distance free events come courtesy of McKenna, a rare sub-16:00 miler out of high school. We haven't seen a
junior go this fast in distance since Erica Sullivan in the class of 2018, and the sophomore McKenna is only seven tenths behind what Sullivan went when we ranked her junior class. She's got the class's best mile, 1000 and 500 frees, including a time in the mile that would've been 5th at NCAAs this year. She's about two seconds out of scoring range in the 500 free, and even has the range to contribute, eventually, on an 800 free relay. She's another very fast riser, dropping 48 seconds in her mile, 14 in her 500 and almost three in her 200 free over the past calendar year.
5.
Ashley Strouse: Scottsdale Aquatic Club - Chaparral High School - Cave Creek, AZ
Best Times: 1650 free 16:01.20, 1000 free 9:40.58, 500 free 4:41.41, 200 free 1:45.44, 100 free 49.24, 50 free 23.32, 100 fly 54.8949.2 to 16:01 that's some otherworldly range. Strouse could easily develop as a 100/200/500 type in the mid-distances, or specialize as a miler/500 freestyler who can come down to 800 and even 400 free relays. Strouse is a bit behind the top four in this class after putting up only moderate drops in her sophomore year, but has the event range to be a monster in the NCAA with even small improvements across the board the next two years. It's fair to say we haven't seen a true distance swimmer who can sprint this well since the great Katie Ledecky in the Class of 2015.
6.
Reilly Tiltmann: Elmbrook Swim Club - Brookfield East High School - Brookfield, WI
Best Times: 200 back 1:54.18, 100 back 52.93, 100 fly 53.55, 100 free 49.54The best true two-distance backstroker in the class, Tiltmann comes in within about a second of NCAA scoring level in both back events. She's also got a great 100 fly for event coverage, and has proven she can handle a 100 fly/100 back double she swam her lifetime-bests in both of those events on the same day of NCSA Juniors this spring. She's also on a massive improvement curve. At this time last year, Tiltmann was 55/2:03 in backstroke and 55 in fly. A 9-second drop in the 200 back has to bode well for a swimmer who is still relatively new to that event.
7.
Annabel Crush: Lakeside Swim Team - Sacred Heart Academy - Louisville, KY
Best Times: 100 back 52.31, 200 back 1:55.50, 50 free 22.71, 100 free 48.97, 200 free 1:47.55, 200 IM 1:58.89, 400 IM 4:19.73, 100 fly 54.21A great name that will give sportswriters everywhere so many headline possibilities. Crush has a wide event range and a good improvement curve pretty much exactly what you're looking for in a sophomore prospect. Her backstrokes are probably her calling card at this point (her 100 back is four tenths out of NCAA scoring range), but her freestyles are improving faster. Crush was 23.4/50.1/1:49.3 at this point last year. She's also got good IM speed and a nice butterfly, and no matter which way she develops event-wise, she'll be an NCAA factor early in her career.
8.
Brooke Zettel: TAC Titans - Apex Friendship High School - Holly Springs, NC
Best Times: 200 breast 2:12.00, 100 breast 1:01.89, 400 IM 4:12.39, 200 IM 1:57.93, 200 free 1:47.73, 200 fly 1:58.20, 100 fly 54.81, 200 back 1:57.43, 100 back 54.40The top 200 breaststroker in the class, Zettel maybe projects even better as an IMer. She definitely fits better in the 200/400 distances, but isn't in any way bereft of speed, with 54s in fly and back and a 1:01 breaststroke. Zettel gets a real versatility bump, with lots of avenues to NCAA contribution. She needs to develop one or two of these events into NCAA scoring range to push the three recruits ahead of her, and her events don't make it easy. (It took 59.5/2:08 to score in breaststroke last year and 1:56/4:08 in IM).
9.
Letitia Sim: TNT Swimming - Spanish Fort High School - Montrose, AL
Best Times: 100 breast 1:00.65, 200 breast 2:13.34, 200 IM 2:01.34, 100 fly 54.50Sim is a few hundredths out from being the best 100 breaststroker in the class, and she cracks the top 10 here despite having quite a ways to go to reach NCAA scoring levels. Why? Her improvement curve is off the charts. At this time last year, Sim was 1:03/2:18 in breaststroke. A year before that, she was 1:08/2:29. It's not a stellar class of breaststrokers yet, but Sim looks primed to take over as the class's top option in recruiting, especially if she can smash through a minute and 2:10 over the next year.
10.
Ellie Waldrep: Baylor Swim Club Baylor School Chattanooga, TN
Best Times: 100 back 52.42, 200 back 1:56.76, 100 fly 53.87Waldrep is one of the better fly/back types in this class, taking a bit after the recruiting class before her. Her 52.4 backstroke is right in the mix with Tiltmann and Crush, even if she doesn't yet have the 200 range to stick with them overall. Waldrep carries her speed out of the wall on breakouts very well, which makes her a tailor-made short course yards talent. She's also on a nice track of time drops, including from 1:59.1 to 1:56.7 in the 200 back and 53.5 to 52.4 in the backstrokes over the past year. Maybe more impressive is a 56.1-to-53.8 drop in butterfly that suggests Waldrep is starting to figure out how to use her walls and underwaters outside of backstroke.
11.
Asia Minnes: Virginia Gators - Roanoke, VA
Best Times: 100 breast 1:00.61, 200 breast 2:16.70, 200 IM 1:58.65, 100 back 53.87, 100 free 49.97Minnes is a Canadian national, but has done most of her age group swimming in the U.S., between the Virginia Gators and Swim Neptune in Arizona. She's the best 100 breaststroker in this class, with a shot to be under a minute in short order. Minnes has a lot of work to do in the 200 breast, but a good 200 IM (1:58.6) suggests she's got the endurance to excel there. She's made some massive time drops in short course, but that feels more a product of a focus on long course than overall improvements in her speed. Sprint freestyles are a nice bonus for Minnes, who could pull overtime with some free relay legs at the college level with a few years of improvements.
12.
Ella Bathurst: Greater Tampa Swimming Association - H.B. Plant High School - Tampa, FL
Best Times: 200 free 1:46.82, 100 back 53.72, 100 free 49.81, 200 back 1:58.09, 100 breast 1:01.75, 200 breast 2:14.67, 200 IM 1:59.76I have absolutely no idea where Bathurst projects as a college swimmer. But she catches our eye in these ranks through a combination of versatility and rapid improvement that would suggest a high ceiling, or at least plenty of scoring opportunities in the NCAA format. Right now, the 1:46.8 200 free is most eye-catching, and that's dropped from 1:48.7 over the past year. Bathurst has also gone from 55.8/2:03.7 to 53.7/1:58.0 in backstroke and 2:07 to 1:59 in IM. Maybe 200 IM/200 free/200 back would be a good NCAA combo for a 200-yard specialist? She's also just fine swimming crowded event lineups she logged 16 swims at NCSA Juniors this spring across four days.
13.
Amy Tang: Pacific Dragons Swim Team - Lakeside High School - Bellevue, WA
Best Times: 100 back 52.75, 200 back 1:57.82, 200 free 1:46.88, 100 free 49.04, 50 free 22.90, 100 fly 54.18Tang has a 100 back that would challenge a lot of the top 10 recruits, and she's got outstanding range into the relay-distance freestyles. That makes her a prime relay recruit in any of the five relay races. The only slightly worrisome piece is that Tang went mostly backwards as a sophomore her season-bests were 53.5/1:59.5 in back and 23.0/49.5 in free. She also put up that huge 1:46.8 in the 200 free in December of 2017, but hasn't logged a swim in that event since March of 2018. At this age, it's not worth putting too much stock into peaks and valleys, as there's still a lot of time to overcome an off season, but the down year is why Tang is ranked 13th and not in the top 10. She's still an outstanding prospect with massive relay value, and she's good in long course, too, going 55.9 in the 100 free in-season this April.
14.
Mackenzie McConagha: Nation's Capital Swim Club - Briar Woods High School - Broadlands, VA
Best Times: 100 back 53.73, 200 back 1:56.65, 100 fly 53.50, 200 fly 1:58.86, 200 IM 2:02.44Another good fly/back type with good range. McConagha hit her lifetime-best 100 fly and 100 back times in a high school state meet double with a 200 free relay in between, showing good toughness. Her backstroke has shown solid improvements from 54.4/1:59.0 a year ago. She doesn't project as a free relay type yet, but could have good medley relay value if her 100 fly and 100 back keep improving. She's also had a good spring in long course, moving to 1:01 in 100-meter fly.
15.
Olivia McMurray: Swim Florida - Fort Myers High School - Fort Myers, FL
Best Times: 1650 free 16:12.25, 1000 free 9:38.72, 500 free 4:44.60, 200 free 1:47.35, 100 free 50.81, 200 fly 1:58.51, 100 fly 54.60, 400 IM 4:14.59, 200 IM 1:59.99This is a really good class of distance swimmers, and McMurray just adds to that depth. In fact, McMurray is roughly comparable to the best distance swimmer in the class of 2020 when we ranked them as sophomores. She's not too far out of scoring in the mile, and is on a rocket ship of a trajectory there. A year ago, McMurray was 16:47 in the mile and 4:46 in the 500 she's cut more than 30 seconds in the mile, 13 in the 1000 and two in the 500 in a year. McMurray also has nice range down to the 200 free, and adds some intriguing times in the 200 fly and 400 IM for a program that wants to complement her free speed with some endurance training in other strokes.
16.
Mia Kragh: Rancho San Dieguito - Torrey Pines High School - San Diego, CA
Best Times: 100 fly 53.32, 200 free 1:48.89, 100 free 50.08, 50 free 23.11Kragh makes this list after a massive sophomore year of time drops. Most impressive is her cut from 57.86 to 53.32 in the 100 fly. Kragh only broke a minute for the first time in early 2017, and has gone from there to one of the best flyers in this class in just over two years. Kragh doesn't have a lot of supporting events yet. But we expect that to change. She's dropped from 1:54 to 1:48 in the 200 free over the past year, and from 51.9/23.9 to 50.0/23.1 in the sprint frees. Kragh just made most of her time drops in March, and has California's high school postseason yet to come later this month.
17.
Micayla Cronk: Blue Dolphins - Flagler Palm Coast High School - Port Orange, FL
Best Times: 200 free 1:46.42, 100 free 49.43, 50 free 23.16Cronk is another relay-type talent who jumps onto the end of our list with an intriguing time and time drop or two. She went from 1:49.40 to 1:46.42 in the 200 free since last spring, finally bringing that swim more in line with her 49-speed in the 100 free. Her 50 still doesn't seem quite on par, but there's time for that to come around. Cronk is also 55 in the 100 back, with a chance to be a pretty good two-stroke sprinter.
18.
Rachel Stege: Fox Valley Swim Team - Neuqua Valley High School - Naperville, IL
Best Times: 1650 free 16:21.50, 1000 free 9:43.09, 500 free 4:43.24, 200 free 1:47.62, 100 free 50.22Yet another phenom of a miler rising fast. Prior to 2019, Stege had never swum a 1650 free. She went 17:08 in her first attempt (January 2019) and has cut it to 16:21 in the four months since then. Over the last year, she's cut 43 seconds from her 1000 (from a 10:26), 16 from her 500 free (from a 4:59) and 6 from her 200 free (from a 1:53). She's got nice range down into the 100/200 free for future relay value, too.
19.
Kate Morris: NW Dupage YMCA - Glenbard West High School - Glen Ellyn, IL
Best Times: 200 free 1:46.75, 100 free 49.83, 50 free 22.81, 100 fly 54.68Morris is a great value through the relay-distance freestyles, and like Cronk and Bathurst, powers her way onto the list with a big 200 free drop. For Morris, it's from 1:48.1 to 1:46.7, which puts her among the better in the class. Morris had a moderate drop of a tenth in the 50 free and pretty much matched her 100 free time during her sophomore year.
20.
Mariah Denigan: Northern Kentucky Clippers Swimming - Barren Academy of Virtual and Expanded Learning - Erlanger, KY
Best Times: 400 IM 4:12.09, 1650 free 16:26.45, 1000 free 9:46.30, 500 free 4:44.25, 200 free 1:48.66, 200 IM 2:01.63Every year, there's a swimmer in the mix who gets ranked way below what their name recognition should call for. Usually we see a lot of disagreement with their rank, and usually we can tell exactly who it's going to be before we publish our ranks. This time around, it's going to be Denigan, who had an awesome long course summer and actually made the U.S. senior travel team for Pan American Games. It's hard to tell right now if Denigan, like many of the other "too-low!" swimmers over the years, is a swimmer whose talent doesn't adequately transfer to the NCAA's sprint-based, short course format, or if Denigan has just put her focus mainly on long course over the past few years. There's no doubt that her 4:40 long course 400 IM time is one of the top few swims of this entire class, but her short course equivalent (put up in November) is still almost four seconds away from NCAA scoring. She's 16:19, 8:28 and 4:12 in long course freestyle, but the corresponding yards events are still behind plenty of others in this class. For now, Denigan is an extremely high-ceiling swimmer, but it remains to be seen if she'll make the leap in short course, or if she'll remain a much better "swimmer" than an "NCAA recruit."
ONES TO WATCHWe're throwing in one more short list a handful of swimmers who piqued our interest. They didn't yet have the full complement of times to make our top 20, but seemed to have enough intrigue that we've earmarked them as names to keep an eye on over the next year, where they could develop into top threats for one reason or another.
- Samantha Tadder (Tide Swimming / First Colonial High School / Virginia Beach, VA) Oh, another fast-dropping miler? How many of these can we fit into our top 20? Tadder is 16:35/9:41/4:46/1:48 still firmly behind the Steges and McMurrays of the world, but she's also dropped from 17:24/9:58/4:55/1:50 over the past year. She's also 4:11 in the 400 IM. Great value here for some distance-oriented program.
- Summer Smith (Bluefish Swim Club / Agawam, MA) A little bit better than Tadder in the mile (16:21), but not as good in the 200 or 500. Smith projects better as a mile/400 IM combo, as she's 4:13.6 in the latter. Has also dropped tons of time in the last year, including from 4:22 in the 400 IM and 17:08 in the mile.
- Meghan Lynch (Greenwich YWCA Dolphins / Greenwich High School / Greenwich, CT) an age group standout in the breaststrokes, Lynch has one of the class's best 200 breaststrokes (2:12.29) and also a good 4:12.0 400 IM. She doesn't have enough breaststroke speed (she's 1:02 in the 100) to crack the list yet, but could get there by improving her 1:59.0 200 IM.
- Annika McEnroe (Y-Spartaquatics Swim Club / Spartanburg High School / Spartanburg, SC) Another distance breaststroker (2:12.43) and IMer (4:12.94) who also has pretty good fly times (1:58.2/53.9). Those don't all fit together great in an NCAA lineup, but the versatility has to be intriguing to college coaches.