dimitrig said:
Big C said:
Wow, I started this thread four months ago, but it also could've been two weeks ago. Cases are SURGING, nationally. (Hell, internationally.) Not sure how much longer California can stay in its good-behavior bubble. Sucks, as my daughter is tentatively scheduled to return to the classroom part-time in a few weeks. Not to mention the return of California Football.
I would like to play devil's advocate to defend one thing Cal88 wrote back in June. In France right now, the case counts have been going through the roof for the past several weeks, but the fatalities have not increased commensurately, even taking into account the fact that fatalities lag about 3 weeks behind case counts...
One factor to explain this is that increased testing is revealing more cases. Another is that improved treatment is lowering the fatalities. Yet a third might be that younger people are getting the disease and the vulnerable population is being better-protected. And yet, it is almost like that one doctor was saying in Italy a few months ago, that COVID just doesn't seem as deadly as it was before.
Fascinating how we're still learning as we go. What will be next?
I think the virus has blown through most of the weakest of the population already and also that treatment has improved.
This is antidotal, but I think this is true to some degree. If you ask experts like Fauci, they will also say that protocols have changed to protect sensitive receptors like those in retirement homes, which is a variant of what you said.
That said, there is second waive occurring right now in much of Western Europe, other counties and portions of the US. Not all numbers are equal. For example, Switzerland, which had almost eradicated COVID, has recently declared an emergency, re-closed its borders, and reestablished COVID restrictions. Now they test and trace most of their population, so the probably have a sense what the numbers actually are. The US is just a crap shoot depending on where you are. Testing and tracing is all over the place, so is compliance or even levels of restrictions. You can't shut down borders. Time lags in reporting are very different. Without a national approach, we have no clue as a country what is really happening. Arguably, one area is facing an unreported surge due to lags in reporting while another may be over reporting due to lags in reporting. And some areas just are not reporting much. My suspicion is this is true of some otter counties (India comes to mind), but bad information is not the way to marshall assets to fight a pandemic or set restrictions on conduct. A sample of the COVID numbers for the EU vs the US adjusted for population seems to suggest the US is being hit harder, but when you throw out places like Switzerland and probably Germany, it is probably hard to tell how accurate the numbers really are in the rest of the countries. For example. the UK and France are probably worse than the US overall in collecting data. But recalling the comments that COVID would be over the day after the election, the numbers in aggregate, don't appear to be saying that, but the seriousness of the average case appears to be diminishing (hospitalizations and deaths as a percent of cases is trending down for a long time). Absent vaccine immunity (if and whenever that occurs), Biden is going to need to develop a national policy because COVID is not going away before he takes office.