I can't really disagree with you. But I think Cal has had a legacy of less than adequate STs play, particularly coverage teams. We have gone to these very questionable punting and blocking tactics to offset that. But it has not worked. Now we are trying to get bigger, stronger and faster in order to improve our coverage teams and our team overall. We'll see if that works.Cal Strong! said:Cal Strong disagree with Heart of the Bear. It true that sometimes you need to give coaches time to develop. But losing a Big Game never acceptable due to something like this. Working kinks out against UC Davis or Washington State frustrating, but understandable. Not knowing how to block a PAT and losing to furd for this reason WEAK. Weak coaches shouldn't coach at Cal.heartofthebear said:
The punter was dropping the ball too low before kicking it and it allowed for blocked punts. That has been observed and commented on. I trust it is being addressed.
While Rags coaching is questionable at times, his recruiting is off the charts. Sometimes you have to take the bad with the good. Rags has been a stand-up guy and highly motivated. He doesn't make excuses and takes responsibility for problems. He is exactly the kind of Cal Strong guy you keep asking for.
Firing a guy who is strong overall just because he is weak in some areas is an overall weak thing to do. I expect him to improve.
One of the main ways a program gets weakened is by compulsively firing and hiring people every year. That creates instability in the program. Cal already has had a great deal of turnover from last season. So it is best not to expand that any more this season.
Baldwin had 3 years. Rags had a bad year last year. Lets give him at least 2021 before we call for his head.
You should know that I have expressed concern that Cal is too enamored with Australian style punting. I don't think it has really worked for Cal as much as the old school guys like Bryan Anger and others have in the past. And I don't know why it has become a 100% cross over rather than a diversification. I'm okay with an Australian style guy here or there. But we have not had a regular punter in quite some time now.
I know why we like the Australian style. It is to reduce the chance of a run back. But I think that is weak.
Rags has had 4 years. If 3 was enough for Baldwin, then why is 4 not enough for Rags?
What frustrate Cal Strong the most is that head coaches who are not Cal alumni always treat furd like "just another game." But Big Game isn't just another game. Humiliating stanfurd is the primary reason we have a football program. So if you lose the Big Game because you couldn't block a PAT, then someone's head needs to roll.
Stanfurd isn't just another game. Preparing to beat furd is the most important thing a Cal coach will do all year. If you screw it up, then you need to find another job.
We have run ST coaches out of town, only to have them success other places while the replacement does not improve the unit. This suggests that it may not be coaching but something more systematic. I don't know. Who would you hire to replace Rags?