Bear Rugby trounced in playoff

1,382 Views | 3 Replies | Last: 2 yr ago by TomBear
TomBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The Cal Rugby team was trounced yesterday by St. Marys 34-16.

It wasn't for lack of effort. Cal played hard. And so did the Gaels. But the Gaels are just really impressive in open play, and there was one truly spectacular play the Gaels did late in the match that, when I saw it I said to myself "this is over". Gaels were attempting a clearing kick from deep inside their territory. The kick was blocked by a Cal player and the ball was in the air when a Gael alertly picked it out of the air, had a nice break, and through a series of runs/offloads, St. Marys ran the ball past the last few Cal defenders and scored the try which I think sealed the deal for St. Marys. It was one of the best plays I have seen in collegiate rugby and was testimony to how the Gaels are so dangerous when things break down. Cal is very structured, whereas St. Marys thrives on open play, and the Gaels used that character at the most opportune times yesterday.

Cal just couldn't get any consistency offensively. They certainly had their chances and managed to drive very close to the St. Marys try line on a few occasions. But the Gael defense was stiff. And again, it seemed to me (and I'd be interested in someone else's perspective) that Cal just killed itself with penalties, again! Maybe I'm hypersensitive and just don't notice the penalties against opponents as closely as I should. But it seemed to me that Cal would finally seem to get some traction and would have a whistle blown against them at very bad times.

Cal played some really effective defense, especially near their try zone. But the Gaels were relentless when they got near the Cal try zone, and as well as the Bears played, they just couldn't hold St. Marys out forever.

This is the first time I can remember (at least recently) where the Bears lose 4 matches and the Gaels defeat them twice in one year. It's not that Cal is degrading. It is simply that, as I have posted before, more and more programs are improving. High School rugby is gaining rapidly, especially in the Bay Area and on the East Coast. Cal is exporting players who are becoming coaches elsewhere (Tim O'Brien at St. Marys is a good example), and they're building solid programs that started with their influences at Strawberry Canyon. And the number of coaches from overseas, along with players from overseas is improving the game here in the states measurably. And as more and more high school players exit from football to rugby, they are bringing a physicality that is making even smaller schools more and more of a force to be reckoned with.

So now St. Marys will play BYU in Moraga next weekend. If the Gaels can handle the Cougars lineouts, they've got a real shot at facing the East champion (who I THINK will be Navy, who trounced Arkansas State convincingly).

Tough year. But there are young players who have looked impressive in competition, and the Bears are never to be dismissed in the future.
chalcidbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yes, Cal did get stymied by penalties, but St. Marys got their fair share as well. Additionally, St. Marys' lineouts were pretty bad, at least in the first half. But the telling moment for me was rather early in the first half. St. Marys had a slight lead (2 or 5 points), and lost a player for 10 minutes to a yellow card. And in that time, even though the Gaels were a man down, Cal just couldn't capitalize - they best we could do was to not fall back further. And when the St. Marys player came back, the Gaels slowly and steadily pulled away. There is no doubt these two squads are fairly evenly matched, and in cases like this, momentum and morale play a big part. Two weeks ago, Cal opened up a nice lead (20-0, I think) over St. Marys, but the Gaels overcame that deficit to outscore the Bears 38-31 at the end of the match. This time, Cal never had the lead, and so I wasn't surprised as St. Marys steadily pulled ahead of us, as Cal started playing desperate while St. Marys played with confidence.

I agree with the you regarding the tenor of the whole sport. Whereas Cal used to be the one superpower, other schools have caught up with us, which was bound to happen in the long run. I'm glad that the Bears still field a powerful team that reliably reaches the playoff stage. But the competition from St. Marys, BYU and the service academies has now reached (if not eclipsed) our level, so it is unrealistic for us to expect to waltz in to the NC year after year. As Jack Clark must be nearing retirement age, I was hoping he could be sent off with a final NC to cap his time here (who knows, maybe we'll get one in the 7's,although that is a longer shot), but at this point that is looking more and more problematic.
oskiswifeshusband
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rugby -> club sport (soon)!
TomBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?

I don't think so. Especially with more and more schools elevating to varsity level.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.