Cal Football

The Head Coaching Search

BearInsider will have unique access and insights to arguably the most important decision in the history of Cal Athletics - the naming of a Head Coach to replace Justin Wilcox.
November 24, 2025
5.5k Views
15 Comments
Story Poster
Photo by Al Sermeno

For updates on the process from this point forward and details on candidates, the retention of JKS, the High School recruiting class as signing day approaches, you will need to be a subscriber to Bear Insider - Join the BearInsider Premium Community

******************************************************************

Hiring a Football Head Coach is far too often an exercise of reflecting on what most recently didn’t work rather than hiring the best possible fit.

Cal is a unique place and is facing a dynamic college football landscape that likely will not be patient with a program that has struggled  12+ years.

Therefore Ron Rivera will need a uniquely curated set of requirements for any potential replacement for Justin Wilcox.

Before we get there, let’s discuss the sources for candidates.   In football at the Power 4 level, programs can succeed with candidates who were former/curent FCS Head Coaches, Current DC/OCs in the Power 4, as well as sitting FBS Head Coaches.

Criteria:

You have to find someone who has the ruthless personality and obsession around winning.  A leader whose north star every moment of every day is what can they do to improve the chances for the team to win.  For Cal fans, Bruce Snyder and Jeff Tedford very obviously had this trait, Tom Holmoe and Justin Wilcox equally as demonstrably did not

The need to win early and often means you likely need to lean into someone who is not the classic culture builder, rather an immediate culture changer.  A bigger personality with a very clear vision about what defines the program.  This becomes the litmus test for recruiting, hiring staff, etc.  The shift in Culture has to be obvious, bold and aggressively implemented

A coach who not only respects Cal’s academic profile but embraces it as a leverage point in recruiting and fund raising.  They have to get the importance of having high character staff and players in the program and understand and relishg this isn’t a “we can admit anyone and the players can do all their classes online” program.  

If the candidate is a sitting head coach, they must have 3+ years of proven success and a clear trend line of improvement.   They need to be able to articulate what has made them successful and how that recipe applies to the unique circumstances in Berkeley.   If they are moving up from FCS or the Group of 5, their recruiting plan has to be incredibly compelling and their plan/access to top tier assistants has to be manifest.    Ideally, any G of 5 or FCS sitting head coach would have experience as a successful position coach/recruiter at the P4 level

if the candidate is a sitting P4 coordinator, it’s critical they have the raw ambition and burning desire to be a Head Coach.  Equally as important is their detailed blueprint of what they would do if they were a head coach at Cal.  They’re also going to need a 3+ year track record of their offense or defense being exceptional at the P4 level and a reputation as a top flight recruiter.  

The next Head Coach has to have to have a robust network with high likelihood of hiring compelling assistants and a ready to roll recruiting plan for those coaches

The candidate need a detailed personnel plan, including players they can bring with them from their current gig, how they plan to retain critical talent at Cal, their approach to HS recruiting and to the portal

West Coast ties/experience is a bonus not mandatory

The Initial Candidates:

Obvious:

Tosh Lupoi - DC at Oregon, Age 44

Brent Brennan - HC at Arizona, Age 52

Jon Sumrall - HC at Tulane, Age 43

Sean Lewis - HC at San Diego State, Age 39

Interesting/Under the Radar:

Bryant Haines - DC at Indiana, Age 40

Eric Morris - HC at North Texas, Age 40

Dan Mullen - HC at UNLV, Age 53

Scott Symons - DC at SMU, Age 40

Pat Fitzgerald - Former HC at Northwestern, Age 50

Worth a Look:

Tim Plough - HC at UC Davis, Age 40

Will Stein - OC at Oregon, Age 36

Troy Taylor - Former HC at Stanford, Age 57

********************************************************************

For updates on the process from this point forward and details on candidates, the retention of JKS, the High School recruiting class as signing day approaches, you will need to be a subscriber to Bear Insider - Join the BearInsider Premium Community

15 Comments
Discussion from...

The Head Coaching Search

4,464 Views | 15 Replies | Last: 20 hrs ago by ducktilldeath
BearGreg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
We've just updated the coaching search on the Premium board to include details on who the lead candidate is at this moment, that candidates level of interest, where things sit with JKS and much more
K1min8r
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Why and how do teams win?

Why and how do players choose where to play?

Not including DJax is short-sighted and foolish.
CalBarn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Why so many current DC's? We have a terrific young QB.
Get somebody who can continue to develop JKS and
recruit better offensive talent around him.
PAC-10-BEAR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Here is what Grok AI says:

Grok AI: My Pick: Hire Tosh Lupoi

Cal should aggressively pursue Tosh Lupoi as the No. 1 target he's the consensus frontrunner and a no-brainer fit. As a former Bear who thrived under Wilcox early on, Lupoi brings instant credibility, elite recruiting (critical for California's talent wars), and a defense-first blueprint tailored to the ACC's grind. His Oregon unit ranks top-4 nationally, and at 44, he's got decades to build sustainably amid Cal's constraints. Rivera, with NFL ties, can help navigate the buyout and assemble a staff (pair him with an offensive mind like Ryan Grubb from Alabama for balance).

This hire signals commitment: Retain Sagapolutele, boost NIL to $5M+, and aim for 8+ wins by 2027. If Lupoi balks, pivot to Mora for stability. The carousel is spinning fastCal needs to move quickly to avoid portal chaos. What do you think Lupoi or someone else?

Me: Cal struggled with a defensive coach in Wilcox. Don't you think Cal fans are ready for a change with an offensive minded coach?

Grok AI My Revised Take: Go All-In on Ryan Grubb

If Cal wants to flip the script and win back the Memorial faithful, Ryan Grubb is the slam-dunk hire. His offenses don't just score they sustain (Alabama's top-3 in red-zone efficiency this year), which is gold for a program that's hemorrhaged talent via portal. Pair him with a defensive coordinator like Lupoi (if he stays available) for balance, and you've got Tedford 2.0 without the health issues. It's a bold swing, but with Rivera's NFL Rolodex, they can afford the buyout and staff it right. Lewis is a close second for that instant California cool factor.

Fans are buzzing for this shift posts are flooding with "No more D-first!" vibes. What about you: Grubb's polish or Lewis's fire? Or is there a dark horse I'm missing?
PAC-10-BEAR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Me: Aren't other schools with deeper pockets going after Ryan Grubb?

Grok AI: You're right to flag thatRyan Grubb's stock is undeniably rising, and his West Coast roots plus proven play-calling (Alabama's sitting at 42.1 PPG this season, top-10 in efficiency despite a shaky O-line) make him a hot commodity in this carousel. But based on the latest buzz as of today (November 24), the competition isn't as cutthroat as it could be for a coordinator of his caliber. Deeper-pocketed programs like Penn State (potentially opening up after James Franklin's rumored exit) or even a rebound at Washington (where he thrived under DeBoer) have been floated in speculation, but nothing concrete has materialized yet. ESPN's Adam Rittenberg and Bruce Feldman peg him squarely as a top early target for Cal specifically, with no aggressive pursuits reported from blue-bloods. His $5M+ buyout from Bama is a hurdle, but Ron Rivera's NFL Rolodex could help Cal sweeten the pot with NIL commitments for Sagapolutele.

That said, if a Power 4 giant like UCLA (another ACC vacancy with SoCal cash) pivots hard, yeah, Cal could get priced out. For now, though, Grubb's name is louder in Berkeley circles than anywhere else. Fans and insiders see it as a natural "homecoming" fit after his Huskies title run. Alabama's staff churn (e.g., DC Kane Wommack to Arkansas rumors) might even push DeBoer to let him walk without much fight.

Bottom line: Cal's got a window to strike while Grubb's radar is tuned Westhis NFL detour (fired after one Seahawks season) might make him wary of jumping to a pressure cooker like Penn State anyway. If Rivera can lock in a 7-8 win vision with staff autonomy, Grubb stays viable. But you're spot-on; monitor UCLA closelythey could crash the party with that SoCal shine. Thoughtsworth the risk, or hedge with Sean Lewis as Plan B?
BearGreg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
CalBarn said:

Why so many current DC's? We have a terrific young QB.
Get somebody who can continue to develop JKS and
recruit better offensive talent around him.

This is a great question which we are discussing on the BI premium board
BearGreg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
PAC-10-BEAR said:

Me: Aren't other schools with deeper pockets going after Ryan Grubb?

Grok AI: You're right to flag thatRyan Grubb's stock is undeniably rising, and his West Coast roots plus proven play-calling (Alabama's sitting at 42.1 PPG this season, top-10 in efficiency despite a shaky O-line) make him a hot commodity in this carousel. But based on the latest buzz as of today (November 24), the competition isn't as cutthroat as it could be for a coordinator of his caliber. Deeper-pocketed programs like Penn State (potentially opening up after James Franklin's rumored exit) or even a rebound at Washington (where he thrived under DeBoer) have been floated in speculation, but nothing concrete has materialized yet. ESPN's Adam Rittenberg and Bruce Feldman peg him squarely as a top early target for Cal specifically, with no aggressive pursuits reported from blue-bloods. His $5M+ buyout from Bama is a hurdle, but Ron Rivera's NFL Rolodex could help Cal sweeten the pot with NIL commitments for Sagapolutele.

That said, if a Power 4 giant like UCLA (another ACC vacancy with SoCal cash) pivots hard, yeah, Cal could get priced out. For now, though, Grubb's name is louder in Berkeley circles than anywhere else. Fans and insiders see it as a natural "homecoming" fit after his Huskies title run. Alabama's staff churn (e.g., DC Kane Wommack to Arkansas rumors) might even push DeBoer to let him walk without much fight.

Bottom line: Cal's got a window to strike while Grubb's radar is tuned Westhis NFL detour (fired after one Seahawks season) might make him wary of jumping to a pressure cooker like Penn State anyway. If Rivera can lock in a 7-8 win vision with staff autonomy, Grubb stays viable. But you're spot-on; monitor UCLA closelythey could crash the party with that SoCal shine. Thoughtsworth the risk, or hedge with Sean Lewis as Plan B?

Grubb is another candidate being discussed on the Premium board
ducktilldeath
How long do you want to ignore this user?
PAC-10-BEAR said:

Me: Aren't other schools with deeper pockets going after Ryan Grubb?

Grok AI: You're right to flag thatRyan Grubb's stock is undeniably rising, and his West Coast roots plus proven play-calling (Alabama's sitting at 42.1 PPG this season, top-10 in efficiency despite a shaky O-line) make him a hot commodity in this carousel. But based on the latest buzz as of today (November 24), the competition isn't as cutthroat as it could be for a coordinator of his caliber. Deeper-pocketed programs like Penn State (potentially opening up after James Franklin's rumored exit) or even a rebound at Washington (where he thrived under DeBoer) have been floated in speculation, but nothing concrete has materialized yet. ESPN's Adam Rittenberg and Bruce Feldman peg him squarely as a top early target for Cal specifically, with no aggressive pursuits reported from blue-bloods. His $5M+ buyout from Bama is a hurdle, but Ron Rivera's NFL Rolodex could help Cal sweeten the pot with NIL commitments for Sagapolutele.

That said, if a Power 4 giant like UCLA (another ACC vacancy with SoCal cash) pivots hard, yeah, Cal could get priced out. For now, though, Grubb's name is louder in Berkeley circles than anywhere else. Fans and insiders see it as a natural "homecoming" fit after his Huskies title run. Alabama's staff churn (e.g., DC Kane Wommack to Arkansas rumors) might even push DeBoer to let him walk without much fight.

Bottom line: Cal's got a window to strike while Grubb's radar is tuned Westhis NFL detour (fired after one Seahawks season) might make him wary of jumping to a pressure cooker like Penn State anyway. If Rivera can lock in a 7-8 win vision with staff autonomy, Grubb stays viable. But you're spot-on; monitor UCLA closelythey could crash the party with that SoCal shine. Thoughtsworth the risk, or hedge with Sean Lewis as Plan B?

A rebound at UW whose coach is going nowhere? AI garbage. Do better.
ManBearLion123
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ducktilldeath said:

PAC-10-BEAR said:

Me: Aren't other schools with deeper pockets going after Ryan Grubb?

Grok AI: You're right to flag thatRyan Grubb's stock is undeniably rising, and his West Coast roots plus proven play-calling (Alabama's sitting at 42.1 PPG this season, top-10 in efficiency despite a shaky O-line) make him a hot commodity in this carousel. But based on the latest buzz as of today (November 24), the competition isn't as cutthroat as it could be for a coordinator of his caliber. Deeper-pocketed programs like Penn State (potentially opening up after James Franklin's rumored exit) or even a rebound at Washington (where he thrived under DeBoer) have been floated in speculation, but nothing concrete has materialized yet. ESPN's Adam Rittenberg and Bruce Feldman peg him squarely as a top early target for Cal specifically, with no aggressive pursuits reported from blue-bloods. His $5M+ buyout from Bama is a hurdle, but Ron Rivera's NFL Rolodex could help Cal sweeten the pot with NIL commitments for Sagapolutele.

That said, if a Power 4 giant like UCLA (another ACC vacancy with SoCal cash) pivots hard, yeah, Cal could get priced out. For now, though, Grubb's name is louder in Berkeley circles than anywhere else. Fans and insiders see it as a natural "homecoming" fit after his Huskies title run. Alabama's staff churn (e.g., DC Kane Wommack to Arkansas rumors) might even push DeBoer to let him walk without much fight.

Bottom line: Cal's got a window to strike while Grubb's radar is tuned Westhis NFL detour (fired after one Seahawks season) might make him wary of jumping to a pressure cooker like Penn State anyway. If Rivera can lock in a 7-8 win vision with staff autonomy, Grubb stays viable. But you're spot-on; monitor UCLA closelythey could crash the party with that SoCal shine. Thoughtsworth the risk, or hedge with Sean Lewis as Plan B?

A rebound at UW whose coach is going nowhere? AI garbage. Do better.

AI is garbage, no argument here...but I do think there's a chance Fisch leaves for Florida or UCLA. If that happens, I'd be worried about UW's interest in Tosh.
PAC-10-BEAR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ducktilldeath said:

A rebound at UW whose coach is going nowhere? AI garbage. Do better.

How about Lane Kiffin, duck? This came via the unofficial president of the Rich Lyons fan club.

Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Why isn't Will Stein a leading candidate? He is the one coordinator we should be targeting at Oregon.
PAC-10-BEAR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ducktilldeath
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ManBearLion123 said:

ducktilldeath said:

PAC-10-BEAR said:

Me: Aren't other schools with deeper pockets going after Ryan Grubb?

Grok AI: You're right to flag thatRyan Grubb's stock is undeniably rising, and his West Coast roots plus proven play-calling (Alabama's sitting at 42.1 PPG this season, top-10 in efficiency despite a shaky O-line) make him a hot commodity in this carousel. But based on the latest buzz as of today (November 24), the competition isn't as cutthroat as it could be for a coordinator of his caliber. Deeper-pocketed programs like Penn State (potentially opening up after James Franklin's rumored exit) or even a rebound at Washington (where he thrived under DeBoer) have been floated in speculation, but nothing concrete has materialized yet. ESPN's Adam Rittenberg and Bruce Feldman peg him squarely as a top early target for Cal specifically, with no aggressive pursuits reported from blue-bloods. His $5M+ buyout from Bama is a hurdle, but Ron Rivera's NFL Rolodex could help Cal sweeten the pot with NIL commitments for Sagapolutele.

That said, if a Power 4 giant like UCLA (another ACC vacancy with SoCal cash) pivots hard, yeah, Cal could get priced out. For now, though, Grubb's name is louder in Berkeley circles than anywhere else. Fans and insiders see it as a natural "homecoming" fit after his Huskies title run. Alabama's staff churn (e.g., DC Kane Wommack to Arkansas rumors) might even push DeBoer to let him walk without much fight.

Bottom line: Cal's got a window to strike while Grubb's radar is tuned Westhis NFL detour (fired after one Seahawks season) might make him wary of jumping to a pressure cooker like Penn State anyway. If Rivera can lock in a 7-8 win vision with staff autonomy, Grubb stays viable. But you're spot-on; monitor UCLA closelythey could crash the party with that SoCal shine. Thoughtsworth the risk, or hedge with Sean Lewis as Plan B?

A rebound at UW whose coach is going nowhere? AI garbage. Do better.

AI is garbage, no argument here...but I do think there's a chance Fisch leaves for Florida or UCLA. If that happens, I'd be worried about UW's interest in Tosh.

lol no. What has he done? UF is a MASSIVE job.
ManBearLion123
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ducktilldeath said:

ManBearLion123 said:

ducktilldeath said:

PAC-10-BEAR said:

Me: Aren't other schools with deeper pockets going after Ryan Grubb?

Grok AI: You're right to flag thatRyan Grubb's stock is undeniably rising, and his West Coast roots plus proven play-calling (Alabama's sitting at 42.1 PPG this season, top-10 in efficiency despite a shaky O-line) make him a hot commodity in this carousel. But based on the latest buzz as of today (November 24), the competition isn't as cutthroat as it could be for a coordinator of his caliber. Deeper-pocketed programs like Penn State (potentially opening up after James Franklin's rumored exit) or even a rebound at Washington (where he thrived under DeBoer) have been floated in speculation, but nothing concrete has materialized yet. ESPN's Adam Rittenberg and Bruce Feldman peg him squarely as a top early target for Cal specifically, with no aggressive pursuits reported from blue-bloods. His $5M+ buyout from Bama is a hurdle, but Ron Rivera's NFL Rolodex could help Cal sweeten the pot with NIL commitments for Sagapolutele.

That said, if a Power 4 giant like UCLA (another ACC vacancy with SoCal cash) pivots hard, yeah, Cal could get priced out. For now, though, Grubb's name is louder in Berkeley circles than anywhere else. Fans and insiders see it as a natural "homecoming" fit after his Huskies title run. Alabama's staff churn (e.g., DC Kane Wommack to Arkansas rumors) might even push DeBoer to let him walk without much fight.

Bottom line: Cal's got a window to strike while Grubb's radar is tuned Westhis NFL detour (fired after one Seahawks season) might make him wary of jumping to a pressure cooker like Penn State anyway. If Rivera can lock in a 7-8 win vision with staff autonomy, Grubb stays viable. But you're spot-on; monitor UCLA closelythey could crash the party with that SoCal shine. Thoughtsworth the risk, or hedge with Sean Lewis as Plan B?

A rebound at UW whose coach is going nowhere? AI garbage. Do better.

AI is garbage, no argument here...but I do think there's a chance Fisch leaves for Florida or UCLA. If that happens, I'd be worried about UW's interest in Tosh.

lol no. What has he done? UF is a MASSIVE job.

Fisch did turn around UA and has done a fairly good job at UW. I don't disagree that he would be a disappointing hire for a program like Florida, but right now he's the betting favorite for the position.
ducktilldeath
How long do you want to ignore this user?
https://www.flightaware.com/live/flight/EJA551/history/20251126/0200Z/KEUG/KOAK
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.