I've ripped KNBR in numerous posts over the past year. In short, they may have the largest wattage for a sports station in the country, however their personality lineup is horrible. Considering the bay area has 3 sports stations to choose from, the lineups are pretty grim.
680am
Murph & Mac-D Two d-bags, one who understand some sports but, as been pointed out, takes full liberties to backhand Cal. Mac does not belong on a sports show. Only saving grace is the regular shows with Krukow & Kuiper.
Gary Radnich-F Can there be a greater blowhard on the air? Who was the top sports personality in the bay area is now a windbag who's increasingly irrelevant. I was hoping Bruno could steer the conversation back to sports in the beginning...no chance now.
Fitz & Brooks-C They do talk sports..even college football, Fitz is full of himself and Brooks on occasion will spark some interesting commentary; for who they are and their content, they fit for the mid-day slot.
Barbieri & Tolbert-F Considering they are billed as the top sports show and get double airing on 1050, they fail miserably. Tolbert adds humor and lightness, as well as perspective. Barbieri unfortunately is an insufferable, pompous ass who's inability to separate his political/social leanings from sports discussions is one of his many failings. Like Radnich, he talks over his guests, he's not very well informed on the broad scope of the bay area sports scene and can easily be swayed into off-topic tangents. Ohh, and they know very little about college sports, let alone college football.
FP Santangelo- incomplete. Looks to capture the twenty something sports fan. Brings a former ballplayer's perspective, doesn't take himself too seriously.
1050am
Mike & Mike in the Morning-A Currently the leading radio sports personality & syndication in the country.
Colin Cowherd-C National Syndication. He can be grating with his self adulation however, he talks sports and has an opinion, which is more than what most of the bay area show hosts can say.
Jim Rome- B National syndicated personality who constantly has an impressive lineup of guests. Style and format is modern encouraging self-serving callers who "have a take" rather than the common Q&A.
Damon Bruce-B Ousted from KNBR due to his strong opinion of the Giants but, due to his high ratings was moved downstairs and into a new time slot rather than the "Larry Krueger treatment". One of the few bay area sports personalities that discusses sports all the time, keeps it humorous and is willing to take various teams to task.
Tony Bruno- C Taking a page from Radnich, Bruno brings his show late night with much of the discussions centering on sports & popular entertainment. Competes with Santangelo for the single-twenty something male audience.
Dan Patrick- C Recorded. National sports syndication of former ESPN personality. Unique format with multiple co-hosts.
860am
Tim Brando- C Polarizing sports host and commentator. Brings sports talk from the South; reminds me of Radnich without the severe tangents.
Rick Tittle- B Only Bay Area sports hosts who can honestly talk about all bay area sports with a decent level of knowledge. Not a charismatic voice, however, he talks sports and should be heard by more.
JJ & the Mouth- D JJ Stokes and Geoff Sheen bring a somewhat amateur hour nationally syndicated sports talk show. They do talk sports, however, Stokes is an idiot and Sheen reminds me of Money from Petros & Money show in SoCal.
Sporting News Radio- Haven't listened.
Ron Barr- B Long time sports personality who's show is interview format only. In depth discussions with guests.
JT the Brick- F One of the most difficult sports personalities to listen too. In your face personality, lots of screaming and ranting. Self appointed mouth piece for the "true Raider-fan and the Black Hole".