MinotStateBeav;841966588 said:
I don't get the Isi hate by some of you. Is he as fast as bigelow? no. But he's not a bad tailback. He's a solid back...definitely a solid 2 and an adequate 1. You may disagree with JT playing him #1...but imho he (Isi) should not be dogged on..thats not his decision.
I have been a big fan of Sofele since he arrived. I was his biggest defender against his detractors last year before the season started saying that, other than WR, he was the last thing I was worried about.
As for the complaints he goes down easy--that applies in 2 situations: 1) First down and short yardage runs into the wall and 2) draw plays where the defender gets a hand on him before he can start running.
Once he gets going he is very difficult to bring down in space. So I disagree with those trashing Isi calling for Bigelow. Yet I still want Bigelow. Why?
Sofele is very good, but Bigelow can be great.
The same was true with Forsett and Best, Echemandu and Arrington and even Arrington and Lynch or at QB with Robertson and Rodgers. The first guy doesn't need to suck to warrant playing the guy with game breaking star potential. People are too black and white, good as bad in their thinking. Sometimes there is good and better (sometimes there is not so good is the best we have).
The problem is that sometimes calls for a back up in game sound like disrespect to the guy playing his heart out. that would suck. I wish Tedford would just do the obvious so the fans wouldn't feel like they need to start chants.