So, How's Sonny doing at SMU?

8,577 Views | 58 Replies | Last: 5 yr ago by oskidunker
25To20
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
SFCALBear72
How long do you want to ignore this user?
And they play their alphabet rival, TCU, tomorrow night at home. It's looking like 0-2. The game is on ESPN2.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SFCALBear72 said:

And they play their alphabet rival, TCU, tomorrow night at home. It's looking like 0-2. The game is on ESPN2.
Who wants to wager when we'll see Sonny blow up on the sidelines?
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.

He is getting worse. If memory serves, opposing teams averaged only 44 points against the Dykes led Bears.
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside
FloriDreaming
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Tedford was the good one we took for granted. The one whose parents said was too good for you, and they were right. Every time you complained, your friends warned you that you'd be sorry if you left, but you were convinced you could do better because you already had a spouse out of your league, so things could only go up from there. Should've listened to your friends.

Dykes was the rebound relationship that never should have happened. Ends up in prison after draining your bank account. Friends tried to warn you, then bailed on you out of self-preservation. But at least your kids are getting good grades in school because you stopped being cheap and hired a tutor instead of "sink or swim" parenting. Kids openly mock you.

Wilcox is what happens after that when you decide you're hopelessly damaged goods and just settle for someone boring, unattractive and predictable for companionship. You stock up on Viagra to avoid facing the truth of your unhappiness. Take up golf and convince yourself you actually enjoy it. Try not to notice that "The One That Got Away" has moved on just fine without your sorry arse while you're paying a 30-year mortgage in Loserville. Your kids barely talk to you.

Cal is the living embodiment of the "Dirty Golden Bear" parody.

RighteousGoldenBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SMU fans don't appear to be too thrilled with Sonny.....

http://www.ponyfans.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=86222

Looks like Yenser joined Dykes at SMU.....I really feel for those fans.
Strykur
How long do you want to ignore this user?
4 yards rushing is impressively bad, especially against North Texas.
59bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
socaliganbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The only thing I want to know about Sonny is how much SMU is paying him.
Another Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm interested in SMU's final season stats for defense. It must be some kind of record to have 5 straight seasons of FBS bottom feeding crap defense (one at LAT and four at Cal). Wonder if Sonny can produce another season of defensive suckitude.

The thing is, just hire a decent DC. Is it really that difficult? Harbaugh found a few DC's online. This level of incompetence is mind boggling.
82gradDLSdad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Another Bear said:

I'm interested in SMU's final season stats for defense. It must be some kind of record to have 5 straight seasons of FBS bottom feeding crap defense (one at LAT and four at Cal). Wonder if Sonny can produce another season of defensive suckitude.

The thing is, just hire a decent DC. Is it really that difficult? Harbaugh found a few DC's online. This level of incompetence is mind boggling.


No DC wants to coach Sonny ball.
BearEatsTacos
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Uthaithani said:

Tedford was the good one we took for granted. The one whose parents said was too good for you, and they were right. Every time you complained, your friends warned you that you'd be sorry if you left, but you were convinced you could do better because you already had a spouse out of your league, so things could only go up from there. Should've listened to your friends.

Dykes was the rebound relationship that never should have happened. Ends up in prison after draining your bank account. Friends tried to warn you, then bailed on you out of self-preservation. But at least your kids are getting good grades in school because you stopped being cheap and hired a tutor instead of "sink or swim" parenting. Kids openly mock you.

Wilcox is what happens after that when you decide you're hopelessly damaged goods and just settle for someone boring, unattractive and predictable for companionship. You stock up on Viagra to avoid facing the truth of your unhappiness. Take up golf and convince yourself you actually enjoy it. Try not to notice that "The One That Got Away" has moved on just fine without your sorry arse while you're paying a 30-year mortgage in Loserville. Your kids barely talk to you.

Cal is the living embodiment of the "Dirty Golden Bear" parody.


Quinn don't you have a game to prepare for this weekend?
Cal8285
How long do you want to ignore this user?
59bear said:

25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
Certain posters pick on Mike Williams way too much, but I have trouble looking at the Sonny dismissal as something that MW did right. Screwing up less than he could have is not the same as doing something right.

MW signed Sonny to an extension that MW never should have agreed to, and then a year later, hoped Sonny would leave on his own or provide good cause for termination instead of just firing him right away, in the (futile) hope that Cal wouldn't be stuck with the payout that was a result of the stupid extension. As a result, the termination happened at least a month later than it should have, making life more difficult for JW in terms of both hiring staff and salvaging what he could of the recruiting year.

Sonny is no longer our problem, and Mike Williams is no longer our problem. Outside of our general propensity to think about both the good and the bad of the past, we don't need to think about either one (good grief, in thinking about the past I still think about Bob Bockrath, who makes Mike Williams look like a dream by comparison). But while I'm glad Sonny is gone, MW screwed up getting rid of Sonny almost as badly as he could have, so I have a little trouble saying that Sonny being gone is proof Williams did one thing right. Sure, it would have been even worse if Sonny had been HC in 2017, but just because MW could have screwed it up even worse doesn't mean he didn't screw it up.
going4roses
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Well he did try to get aranda and Akina? But...
Nasal Mucus Goldenbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SFCALBear72 said:

And they play their alphabet rival, TCU, tomorrow night at home. It's looking like 0-2. The game is on ESPN2.

That one could be historically ugly, as in record-breaking Big Game 2013 "603 yards + 63 points allowed, & 50-point deficit" ugly.

http://www.espn.com/college-football/matchup?gameId=333270024
tequila4kapp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Another Bear said:

The thing is, just hire a decent DC. Is it really that difficult? Harbaugh found a few DC's online. This level of incompetence is mind boggling.
I think it's a lot more than that. He just doesn't care or prioritize defense.
Nasal Mucus Goldenbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
25To20 said:

The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters.

Not only that, apparently until late into the 3rd quarter they managed only 1 1st down.
Another Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
82gradDLSdad said:




No DC wants to coach Sonny ball.
Good point...with the bigger point, he didn't develop ties to get one. Still I think he could find a hot shot FCS/D2 DC who would love the opp.

Anywho...he's gone. But man, after read some of the stats on this thread, imagine what Cal FB would be like if Dykes didn't have Goff.
socaliganbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
*knocks on wood*
TheSouseFamily
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RighteousGoldenBear said:



Looks like Yenser joined Dykes at SMU.....I really feel for those fans.


Pretty sure Yenser is currently coaching at the high school level these days. Seemed like a nice guy but WAY in over his head coaching at the P5 level.
Fyght4Cal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal8285 said:

59bear said:

25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
Certain posters pick on Mike Williams way too much, but I have trouble looking at the Sonny dismissal as something that MW did right. Screwing up less than he could have is not the same as doing something right.

MW signed Sonny to an extension that MW never should have agreed to, and then a year later, hoped Sonny would leave on his own or provide good cause for termination instead of just firing him right away, in the (futile) hope that Cal wouldn't be stuck with the payout that was a result of the stupid extension. As a result, the termination happened at least a month later than it should have, making life more difficult for JW in terms of both hiring staff and salvaging what he could of the recruiting year.

Sonny is no longer our problem, and Mike Williams is no longer our problem. Outside of our general propensity to think about both the good and the bad of the past, we don't need to think about either one (good grief, in thinking about the past I still think about Bob Bockrath, who makes Mike Williams look like a dream by comparison). But while I'm glad Sonny is gone, MW screwed up getting rid of Sonny almost as badly as he could have, so I have a little trouble saying that Sonny being gone is proof Williams did one thing right. Sure, it would have been even worse if Sonny had been HC in 2017, but just because MW could have screwed it up even worse doesn't mean he didn't screw it up.
Looking back, at what point should Williams have fired Dykes?
Patience is a virtue, but I’m not into virtue signaling these days.
XXXBEAR
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Uthaithani said:

BTedford was the good one we took for granted. The one whose parents said was too good for you, and they were right. Every time you complained, your friends warned you that you'd be sorry if you left, but you were convinced you could do better because you already had a spouse out of your league, so things could only go up from there. Should've listened to your friends.

Dykes was the rebound relationship that never should have happened. Ends up in prison after draining your bank account. Friends tried to warn you, then bailed on you out of self-preservation. But at least your kids are getting good grades in school because you stopped being cheap and hired a tutor instead of "sink or swim" parenting. Kids openly mock you.

Wilcox is what happens after that when you decide you're hopelessly damaged goods and just settle for someone boring, unattractive and predictable for companionship. You stock up on Viagra to avoid facing the truth of your unhappiness. Take up golf and convince yourself you actually enjoy it. Try not to notice that "The One That Got Away" has moved on just fine without your sorry arse while you're paying a 30-year mortgage in Loserville. Your kids barely talk to you.

Cal is the living embodiment of the "Dirty Golden Bear" parody.


Feel better now?
ColoradoBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TheSouseFamily said:

RighteousGoldenBear said:



Looks like Yenser joined Dykes at SMU.....I really feel for those fans.


Pretty sure Yenser is currently coaching at the high school level these days. Seemed like a nice guy but WAY in over his head coaching at the P5 level.
Lol he might make more as a HS Head coach, but here he is:

https://smumustangs.com/coaches.aspx?rc=5275&path=football
TheSouseFamily
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Interesting. Much be a new hire because just a few months ago in May, he was hired as the OL coach at Enterprise HS in Alabama.

http://m.southeastsun.com/mobile/sports/article_dce3c5c2-59f5-11e8-9e2c-577659a67784.html

Edit: yup, looks like he made the move on aug 1. Didn't he do a similar switcheroo at the last minute when we hired him?

http://m.southeastsun.com/mobile/sports/article_5a47d6a2-9597-11e8-9504-87c9da2252c0.html
TheSouseFamily
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Current whereabouts of the rest of Sonny's first staff he brought to Cal:

Tony Franklin- OC. Middle Tennessee
Pierre Ingram - AHC Fujitsu (Japan) Frontiers
Rob Likens - OC, Arizona State
Andy Buh - DC. Maryland
Garrett Chacere - OC New Mexico Highlands Univ
Barry Sacks - DL Coach, Montana
Randy Stewart - Safeties Coach, Cal Poly
Mark Tommerdhahl - ST Coach, Purdue (recent- had been at Utah State)
Damon Harrington - Head Strength Coach, Grambling

wifeisafurd
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Fyght4Cal said:

Cal8285 said:

59bear said:

25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
Certain posters pick on Mike Williams way too much, but I have trouble looking at the Sonny dismissal as something that MW did right. Screwing up less than he could have is not the same as doing something right.

MW signed Sonny to an extension that MW never should have agreed to, and then a year later, hoped Sonny would leave on his own or provide good cause for termination instead of just firing him right away, in the (futile) hope that Cal wouldn't be stuck with the payout that was a result of the stupid extension. As a result, the termination happened at least a month later than it should have, making life more difficult for JW in terms of both hiring staff and salvaging what he could of the recruiting year.

Sonny is no longer our problem, and Mike Williams is no longer our problem. Outside of our general propensity to think about both the good and the bad of the past, we don't need to think about either one (good grief, in thinking about the past I still think about Bob Bockrath, who makes Mike Williams look like a dream by comparison). But while I'm glad Sonny is gone, MW screwed up getting rid of Sonny almost as badly as he could have, so I have a little trouble saying that Sonny being gone is proof Williams did one thing right. Sure, it would have been even worse if Sonny had been HC in 2017, but just because MW could have screwed it up even worse doesn't mean he didn't screw it up.
Looking back, at what point should Williams have fired Dykes?
if its 2017, sometime well before the recruiting class deadlines are occurring so the new coach (Wilcox) would have time to recruit. I know what finally caused Williams to act, and Williams could have gone through that process far sooner. In any event, it is just dust in the wind. Only thing that now matters is finding an offense and beating BYU (next team up).
wifeisafurd
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TheSouseFamily said:

Current whereabouts of the rest of Sonny's first staff he brought to Cal:

Tony Franklin- OC. Middle Tennessee
Pierre Ingram - AHC Fujitsu (Japan) Frontiers
Rob Likens - OC, Arizona State
Andy Buh - DC. Maryland
Garrett Chacere - OC New Mexico Highlands Univ
Barry Sacks - DL Coach, Montana
Randy Stewart - Safeties Coach, Cal Poly
Mark Tommerdhahl - ST Coach, Purdue (recent- had been at Utah State)
Damon Harrington - Head Strength Coach, Grambling


Likens was the real deal and was wise enough to bail early. Franklin was just not a fit, but I thought had some success here. Buh is an interesting case. You look at his resume, and wonder if he was the problem or was it Sonny and Sonnyball. Tommerdahl probably wasn't as bad as first thought - just didn't have the athletes, and Ingram had legal problems. Everyone else probably didn't belong at a D1 school coaching, starting with Harrington.
Fyght4Cal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wifeisafurd said:

Fyght4Cal said:

Cal8285 said:

59bear said:

25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
Certain posters pick on Mike Williams way too much, but I have trouble looking at the Sonny dismissal as something that MW did right. Screwing up less than he could have is not the same as doing something right.

MW signed Sonny to an extension that MW never should have agreed to, and then a year later, hoped Sonny would leave on his own or provide good cause for termination instead of just firing him right away, in the (futile) hope that Cal wouldn't be stuck with the payout that was a result of the stupid extension. As a result, the termination happened at least a month later than it should have, making life more difficult for JW in terms of both hiring staff and salvaging what he could of the recruiting year.

Sonny is no longer our problem, and Mike Williams is no longer our problem. Outside of our general propensity to think about both the good and the bad of the past, we don't need to think about either one (good grief, in thinking about the past I still think about Bob Bockrath, who makes Mike Williams look like a dream by comparison). But while I'm glad Sonny is gone, MW screwed up getting rid of Sonny almost as badly as he could have, so I have a little trouble saying that Sonny being gone is proof Williams did one thing right. Sure, it would have been even worse if Sonny had been HC in 2017, but just because MW could have screwed it up even worse doesn't mean he didn't screw it up.
Looking back, at what point should Williams have fired Dykes?
if its 2017, sometime well before the recruiting class deadlines are occurring so the new coach (Wilcox) would have time to recruit. I know what finally caused Williams to act, and Williams could have gone through that process far sooner. In any event, it is just dust in the wind. Only thing that now matters is finding an offense and beatign BYU.
That's when it became clearer to me that he needed to go. However, my friend 8285 may have an earlier time in mind. I've valued his thoughts for about 40 years now, so I'm eager to read his views on the contract extension. Especially considering that w/o the extension Dykes may have appeared to be a dead man walking, to my mind. I'm confident that 8285 can show me the error of my ways.

Go Bears! Beat the Cougars!
going4roses
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Coach burns is at Oregon st
82gradDLSdad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
going4roses said:

Well he did try to get aranda and Akina? But...


And I tried to date Raquel Welch. None of these relationships EVER had a chance of occurring.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wifeisafurd said:

Fyght4Cal said:

Cal8285 said:

59bear said:

25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
Certain posters pick on Mike Williams way too much, but I have trouble looking at the Sonny dismissal as something that MW did right. Screwing up less than he could have is not the same as doing something right.

MW signed Sonny to an extension that MW never should have agreed to, and then a year later, hoped Sonny would leave on his own or provide good cause for termination instead of just firing him right away, in the (futile) hope that Cal wouldn't be stuck with the payout that was a result of the stupid extension. As a result, the termination happened at least a month later than it should have, making life more difficult for JW in terms of both hiring staff and salvaging what he could of the recruiting year.

Sonny is no longer our problem, and Mike Williams is no longer our problem. Outside of our general propensity to think about both the good and the bad of the past, we don't need to think about either one (good grief, in thinking about the past I still think about Bob Bockrath, who makes Mike Williams look like a dream by comparison). But while I'm glad Sonny is gone, MW screwed up getting rid of Sonny almost as badly as he could have, so I have a little trouble saying that Sonny being gone is proof Williams did one thing right. Sure, it would have been even worse if Sonny had been HC in 2017, but just because MW could have screwed it up even worse doesn't mean he didn't screw it up.
Looking back, at what point should Williams have fired Dykes?
if its 2017, sometime well before the recruiting class deadlines are occurring so the new coach (Wilcox) would have time to recruit. I know what finally caused Williams to act, and Williams could have gone through that process far sooner. In any event, it is just dust in the wind. Only thing that now matters is finding an offense and beating BYU (next team up).
Okay, wife, you brought it up, so now you gotta tell us (or at least give us a hint or a direction). I'm pretty sure this is a board etiquette guideline. What finally caused Williams to act?

Some folks say I'm morbid or need to stop dwelling on the past, but I've always been fascinated by the inside facts about Cal coaches' hirings and firings. In this case, was it financial? Sonny's job searching? Lack of ability to hire a top DC? Personal? Something else?
82gradDLSdad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TheSouseFamily said:

RighteousGoldenBear said:



Looks like Yenser joined Dykes at SMU.....I really feel for those fans.


Pretty sure Yenser is currently coaching at the high school level these days. Seemed like a nice guy but WAY in over his head coaching at the P5 level.


My favorite Yenser tidbit: while I'm watching our OL start every play in a two point stance Yenser is up on the Memorial minitron exclaiming to his troops during a filmed practice, "Low man wins!!". I was flabbergasted.
Bear19
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Uthaithani said:

Wilcox is what happens after that when you decide you're hopelessly damaged goods and just settle for someone boring, unattractive and predictable for companionship. You stock up on Viagra to avoid facing the truth of your unhappiness. Take up golf and convince yourself you actually enjoy it. Try not to notice that "The One That Got Away" has moved on just fine without your sorry arse while you're paying a 30-year mortgage in Loserville. Your kids barely talk to you.

Cal is the living embodiment of the "Dirty Golden Bear" parody.
Uth is working on some good imagery for how much he dislikes Wilcox. Not bad for the first game of the season, not mid-season form either. Keep working on it, Uth. You've got several months to reach "All-Conference Insulter" status.
wifeisafurd
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Fyght4Cal said:

wifeisafurd said:

Fyght4Cal said:

Cal8285 said:

59bear said:

25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
Certain posters pick on Mike Williams way too much, but I have trouble looking at the Sonny dismissal as something that MW did right. Screwing up less than he could have is not the same as doing something right.

MW signed Sonny to an extension that MW never should have agreed to, and then a year later, hoped Sonny would leave on his own or provide good cause for termination instead of just firing him right away, in the (futile) hope that Cal wouldn't be stuck with the payout that was a result of the stupid extension. As a result, the termination happened at least a month later than it should have, making life more difficult for JW in terms of both hiring staff and salvaging what he could of the recruiting year.

Sonny is no longer our problem, and Mike Williams is no longer our problem. Outside of our general propensity to think about both the good and the bad of the past, we don't need to think about either one (good grief, in thinking about the past I still think about Bob Bockrath, who makes Mike Williams look like a dream by comparison). But while I'm glad Sonny is gone, MW screwed up getting rid of Sonny almost as badly as he could have, so I have a little trouble saying that Sonny being gone is proof Williams did one thing right. Sure, it would have been even worse if Sonny had been HC in 2017, but just because MW could have screwed it up even worse doesn't mean he didn't screw it up.
Looking back, at what point should Williams have fired Dykes?
if its 2017, sometime well before the recruiting class deadlines are occurring so the new coach (Wilcox) would have time to recruit. I know what finally caused Williams to act, and Williams could have gone through that process far sooner. In any event, it is just dust in the wind. Only thing that now matters is finding an offense and beatign BYU.
That's when it became clearer to me that he needed to go. However, my friend 8285 may have an earlier time in mind. I've valued his thoughts for about 40 years now, so I'm eager to read his views on the contract extension. Especially considering that w/o the extension Dykes may have appeared to be a dead man walking, to my mind. I'm confident that 8285 can show me the error of my ways.

Go Bears! Beat the Cougars!
The comment was aimed more at other posts than at your request about timing in firing Dykes.. Personally, I would have sat Sonny down the year before when he was so publicly looking at other jobs and said, your either committed here or your gone. And I think Knowlton would have done the same thing - he seems like a no BS kind of guy. Williams had a more conciliatory style which worked at Cal at the time (we now have a diplomatic, but no BS kind of Chancellor). My two cents in any event.
wifeisafurd
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Big C said:

wifeisafurd said:

Fyght4Cal said:

Cal8285 said:

59bear said:

25To20 said:

I'm glad you asked. SMU lost to that college football juggernaut, North Texas in Sonny's debut, 46 - 23. The Mustangs were shutout through 3 quarters. Looks like Sonny's got that same defensive mindset he had at Cal, and is perhaps a little less excited about offense than he was here.
Meh! The man is no longer our problem, proof that Mike Williams did at least one thing right. Go Bears!
Certain posters pick on Mike Williams way too much, but I have trouble looking at the Sonny dismissal as something that MW did right. Screwing up less than he could have is not the same as doing something right.

MW signed Sonny to an extension that MW never should have agreed to, and then a year later, hoped Sonny would leave on his own or provide good cause for termination instead of just firing him right away, in the (futile) hope that Cal wouldn't be stuck with the payout that was a result of the stupid extension. As a result, the termination happened at least a month later than it should have, making life more difficult for JW in terms of both hiring staff and salvaging what he could of the recruiting year.

Sonny is no longer our problem, and Mike Williams is no longer our problem. Outside of our general propensity to think about both the good and the bad of the past, we don't need to think about either one (good grief, in thinking about the past I still think about Bob Bockrath, who makes Mike Williams look like a dream by comparison). But while I'm glad Sonny is gone, MW screwed up getting rid of Sonny almost as badly as he could have, so I have a little trouble saying that Sonny being gone is proof Williams did one thing right. Sure, it would have been even worse if Sonny had been HC in 2017, but just because MW could have screwed it up even worse doesn't mean he didn't screw it up.
Looking back, at what point should Williams have fired Dykes?
if its 2017, sometime well before the recruiting class deadlines are occurring so the new coach (Wilcox) would have time to recruit. I know what finally caused Williams to act, and Williams could have gone through that process far sooner. In any event, it is just dust in the wind. Only thing that now matters is finding an offense and beating BYU (next team up).
Okay, wife, you brought it up, so now you gotta tell us (or at least give us a hint or a direction). I'm pretty sure this is a board etiquette guideline. What finally caused Williams to act?

Some folks say I'm morbid or need to stop dwelling on the past, but I've always been fascinated by the inside facts about Cal coaches' hirings and firings. In this case, was it financial? Sonny's job searching? Lack of ability to hire a top DC? Personal? Something else?
Exit interviews with graduating players were awful, and that was the last straw (sorry about the half-metaphor). Recall Williams making the point that participating in Cal athletics s/b a good experience when hiring Wilcox. I think Sonny was great with alum outreach and some other areas, but he was aloof with players, and morale was low. Wilcox has yet to prove himself on winning games, but he has turned around the player experience from everything I have heard. Williams ultimately made the correct decision, but he set the program back by taking too long to pull the trigger.
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.