WSU off season

3,171 Views | 30 Replies | Last: 2 yr ago by Big C
HoopDreams
How long do you want to ignore this user?
different teams' offseasons impact their teams differently!

https://www.espn.com/mens-college-basketball/story/_/id/34052635/washington-state-mouhamed-gueye-withdraws-name-basketball-transfer-portal
KoreAmBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yah they are on the brink of the NCAAs, while we are merely on the brink.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoopDreams said:

different teams' offseasons impact their teams differently!

https://www.espn.com/mens-college-basketball/story/_/id/34052635/washington-state-mouhamed-gueye-withdraws-name-basketball-transfer-portal


WSU is a tough location, but I have been very impressed with Kyle Smith since he took Columbia from perennial doormat to contender.
joe amos yaks
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Pullman is somewhat remote, but the Palouse is beautiful and a great place for a serious student . . . and they serve excellent ice cream.
"Those who say don't know, and those who know don't say." - LT
stu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
During the winter isn't everything there some form of ice?
Econ141
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That WSU can do this shows that we are going out of our way to be this bad.

Carol H. Christ - please do something one of these days.
calbear80
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Isn't WSU coach the guy Knowlton passed over?

Chancellor Christ needs to fix the real problem.

Go Bears!
calbear80
How long do you want to ignore this user?
joe amos yaks said:

Pullman is somewhat remote, but the Palouse is beautiful and a great place for a serious student . . . and they serve excellent ice cream.

I have been to Pullman, WA and Moscow, ID (about 10 miles away) half a dozen times. I would not use the word beautiful in the same paragraph as Pullman or Moscow, even in the "good weather" part of the year. Any coach who can make things happen in Pullman, must have something going for him/her.

Go Bears!
concordtom
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calbear80 said:

joe amos yaks said:

Pullman is somewhat remote, but the Palouse is beautiful and a great place for a serious student . . . and they serve excellent ice cream.

I have been to Pullman, WA and Moscow, ID (about 10 miles away) half a dozen times. I would not use the word beautiful in the same paragraph as Pullman or Moscow, even in the "good weather" part of the year. Any coach who can make things happen in Pullman, must have something going for him/her.

Go Bears!

Tony Bennett won a National championship!!
calbear80
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Somehow the ADs at WSU hire winning FB and MBB coaches and our last two ADs hire …. Maybe, it is time for Chancellor Christ to find out what is WSU's secret (hint, a good AD is a good start).

Go Bears!
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calbear80 said:

Isn't WSU coach the guy Knowlton passed over?

Chancellor Christ needs to fix the real problem.

Go Bears!

No, it was reported here that Smith has family connections in the greater, greater Pullman area and actually wanted to be there, WSU hired him even before Cal had an opening. Knowlton passed over Travis Decuire to hire Fox.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Big C said:

calbear80 said:

Isn't WSU coach the guy Knowlton passed over?

Chancellor Christ needs to fix the real problem.

Go Bears!

No, it was reported here that Smith has family connections in the greater, greater Pullman area and actually wanted to be there, WSU hired him even before Cal had an opening. Knowlton passed over Travis Decuire to hire Fox.


My brother knows him through Randy Bennett and a bunch of other UCSD basketball alums. Smith had been interested in the Cal job since he lived in the East Bay as an assistant at St. Mary's and then had success in turning around an academic school like Columbia making him think he could do so at Cal too.

WSU's and Cal's seasons ended at the same time. Initially Knowlton indicated Wyking would be back and WSU came after Smith hard and had him signed before Knowlton changed gears, fired Jones, hired a search firm and hired Fox all in 5 days.

It is true that Kyle Smith's wife is from the area making it more attractive to him than it would otherwise be, but anyone who thinks he would not have entertained the additional salary Cal pays in a better recruiting location, a better school and more storied history with no need to move his family is just making excuses for Knowlton.
calbear80
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

Big C said:

calbear80 said:

Isn't WSU coach the guy Knowlton passed over?

Chancellor Christ needs to fix the real problem.

Go Bears!

No, it was reported here that Smith has family connections in the greater, greater Pullman area and actually wanted to be there, WSU hired him even before Cal had an opening. Knowlton passed over Travis Decuire to hire Fox.


My brother knows him through Randy Bennett and a bunch of other UCSD basketball alums. Smith had been interested in the Cal job since he lived in the East Bay as an assistant at St. Mary's and then had success in turning around an academic school like Columbia making him think he could do so at Cal too.

WSU's and Cal's seasons ended at the same time. Initially Knowlton indicated Wyking would be back and WSU came after Smith hard and had him signed before Knowlton changed gears, fired Jones, hired a search firm and hired Fox all in 5 days.

It is true that Kyle Smith's wife is from the area making it more attractive to him than it would otherwise be, but anyone who thinks he would not have entertained the additional salary Cal pays in a better recruiting location and more storied history with no need to move his family is just making excuses for Knowlton.

+100

There are three kinds of people: those who make it happen, those who know what happened and those who wonder what happened. Knowlton falls in the third category when it comes to hiring MBB and WBB coaches.

Go Bears!
joe amos yaks
How long do you want to ignore this user?
stu said:

During the winter isn't everything there some form of ice?
Yes, winter is winter, it ain't no San Diego, but that's the northwest. The Palouse is grand and beautiful country.
"Those who say don't know, and those who know don't say." - LT
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
joe amos yaks said:

stu said:

During the winter isn't everything there some form of ice?
Yes, winter is winter, it ain't no San Diego, but that's the northwest. The Palouse is grand and beautiful country.


But there is a reason why many more people live in the Bay Area (or even Seattle) and home prices are higher. Most 18 year old basketball players are not looking to spend 4 years in "grand and beautiful country" when, if they go to Cal they can just visit once a year.
bearmanpg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

joe amos yaks said:

stu said:

During the winter isn't everything there some form of ice?
Yes, winter is winter, it ain't no San Diego, but that's the northwest. The Palouse is grand and beautiful country.


But there is a reason why many more people live in the Bay Area (or even Seattle) and home prices are higher. Most 18 year old basketball players are not looking to spend 4 years in "grand and beautiful country" when, if they go to Cal they can just visit once a year.
Rignt now, I would take their roster over ours so obviously SOME 18 year old basketball players ARE looking to spend A FEW years in "grand and beautiful country"......I totally understand where your coming from though....
HoopDreams
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Never been to Pullman, but went to our ncaa game in zag town

Is Zags town much better

I was not impressed

But seems like it impresses 12-15 basketball players

bearmanpg said:

calumnus said:

joe amos yaks said:

stu said:

During the winter isn't everything there some form of ice?
Yes, winter is winter, it ain't no San Diego, but that's the northwest. The Palouse is grand and beautiful country.


But there is a reason why many more people live in the Bay Area (or even Seattle) and home prices are higher. Most 18 year old basketball players are not looking to spend 4 years in "grand and beautiful country" when, if they go to Cal they can just visit once a year.
Rignt now, I would take their roster over ours so obviously SOME 18 year old basketball players ARE looking to spend A FEW years in "grand and beautiful country"......I totally understand where your coming from though....

PtownBear1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bearmanpg said:

calumnus said:

joe amos yaks said:

stu said:

During the winter isn't everything there some form of ice?
Yes, winter is winter, it ain't no San Diego, but that's the northwest. The Palouse is grand and beautiful country.


But there is a reason why many more people live in the Bay Area (or even Seattle) and home prices are higher. Most 18 year old basketball players are not looking to spend 4 years in "grand and beautiful country" when, if they go to Cal they can just visit once a year.
Rignt now, I would take their roster over ours so obviously SOME 18 year old basketball players ARE looking to spend A FEW years in "grand and beautiful country"......I totally understand where your coming from though....



If we had a remotely desirable coach, I have no doubt we could easily get any of their players.
Civil Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
PtownBear1 said:

bearmanpg said:

calumnus said:

joe amos yaks said:

stu said:

During the winter isn't everything there some form of ice?
Yes, winter is winter, it ain't no San Diego, but that's the northwest. The Palouse is grand and beautiful country.


But there is a reason why many more people live in the Bay Area (or even Seattle) and home prices are higher. Most 18 year old basketball players are not looking to spend 4 years in "grand and beautiful country" when, if they go to Cal they can just visit once a year.
Rignt now, I would take their roster over ours so obviously SOME 18 year old basketball players ARE looking to spend A FEW years in "grand and beautiful country"......I totally understand where your coming from though....



If we had a remotely desirable coach, I have no doubt we could easily get any of their players.
Assuming they qualify.
89Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Serious question:
If a poll were taken with a group of recruits and they were to rank the factors in their school decision-making, where would location in the country rank?
I see:
-Playing time
-Connection to coaches
-Playing style
-NBA path
-NIL(for a select few)
-Teammates
-Facilities
-Hype factor of school(Crowds, media coverage...)
(Not saying I agree with these priorities.)
Location, for many of these recruits, is low down the list in my opinion.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
89Bear said:

Serious question:
If a poll were taken with a group of recruits and they were to rank the factors in their school decision-making, where would location in the country rank?
I see:
-Playing time
-Connection to coaches
-Playing style
-NBA path
-NIL(for a select few)
-Teammates
-Facilities
-Hype factor of school(Crowds, media coverage...)
(Not saying I agree with these priorities.)
Location, for many of these recruits, is low down the list in my opinion.

Good question!

It is significant that "academics" isn't on your list, though I think it's a factor with certain recruits (not too many).

In fact, in ranking your factors above, different recruits (and different "types/levels" of recruit) will rank differently (of course).
BeachedBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
89Bear said:

Serious question:
If a poll were taken with a group of recruits and they were to rank the factors in their school decision-making, where would location in the country rank?
I see:
-Playing time
-Connection to coaches
-Playing style
-NBA path
-NIL(for a select few)
-Teammates
-Facilities
-Hype factor of school(Crowds, media coverage...)
(Not saying I agree with these priorities.)
Location, for many of these recruits, is low down the list in my opinion.
Agreed. Location is in "All other things being equal category". More importantly, there is little the coaching staff or AD can do (other than take advantage) to change it. Most things on your list CAN be affected or at least influenced. I would add Academic reputation to your list, near the bottom, just above location and below culinary environment and far below coed friendliness.

The other part of the poll probably needs to include parents rankings as well.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BeachedBear said:

89Bear said:

Serious question:
If a poll were taken with a group of recruits and they were to rank the factors in their school decision-making, where would location in the country rank?
I see:
-Playing time
-Connection to coaches
-Playing style
-NBA path
-NIL(for a select few)
-Teammates
-Facilities
-Hype factor of school(Crowds, media coverage...)
(Not saying I agree with these priorities.)
Location, for many of these recruits, is low down the list in my opinion.
Agreed. Location is in "All other things being equal category". More importantly, there is little the coaching staff or AD can do (other than take advantage) to change it. Most things on your list CAN be affected or at least influenced. I would add Academic reputation to your list, near the bottom, just above location and below culinary environment and far below coed friendliness.

The other part of the poll probably needs to include parents rankings as well.


I think you have to add tradition/name and chances of making the NCAA Tournament.

Location and campus matter. Think about when you applied for school, it was probably: 1. Academics 2. Location and campus 3. Cost. For top athletes it is just that their sport is #1 replacing academics and cost is not an issue.

Cal has a much better basketball history, name and location than WSU. We have had far more top recruits in our history than they have, for a reason.
wifeisafurd
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The weather certainly helps WSU basketball players stay focused indoors to practice and study.
4thGenCal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

BeachedBear said:

89Bear said:

Serious question:
If a poll were taken with a group of recruits and they were to rank the factors in their school decision-making, where would location in the country rank?
I see:
-Playing time
-Connection to coaches
-Playing style
-NBA path
-NIL(for a select few)
-Teammates
-Facilities
-Hype factor of school(Crowds, media coverage...)
(Not saying I agree with these priorities.)
Location, for many of these recruits, is low down the list in my opinion.
Agreed. Location is in "All other things being equal category". More importantly, there is little the coaching staff or AD can do (other than take advantage) to change it. Most things on your list CAN be affected or at least influenced. I would add Academic reputation to your list, near the bottom, just above location and below culinary environment and far below coed friendliness.

The other part of the poll probably needs to include parents rankings as well.


I think you have to add tradition/name and chances of making the NCAA Tournament.

Location and campus matter. Think about when you applied for school, it was probably: 1. Academics 2. Location and campus 3. Cost. For top athletes it is just that their sport is #1 replacing academics and cost is not an issue.

Cal has a much better basketball history, name and location than WSU. We have had far more top recruits in our history than they have, for a reason.
Agree - Tradition, chances of making NCAA Tournament, connection to staff,Facilities,Location, playing style,NIL opportunities, housing (parents weigh in often on this) - at the top and then - yes " coed quality" ( its a common complaint amongst the bball and football guys - not sure where that factor ranks though). Academics a lower factor - I usually get the response that it weighed in less than the above criteria. .
Jalen still on crutches and had a pretty heavy setback with the ACL and meniscus tear and a stretch to the MCL - likely not able to be back to normal until Feb/March. Marsalis Roberson recently had some minor scar tissue removal and thus knee surgery and will be fine in a month. Hyder feeling really good and hopefully now that he is healthy, will be much improved. Joel Brown - healthy/recovered from past month minor knee surgery and will be improved. All on campus except the 6' 9" incoming freshman, due to visa issues that should be resolved over the next couple of weeks. Team will be quicker and more athletic - not sure if they can protect the rim, shoot from outside consistently and limit offensive rebounding of the opposing team. Losing Kelly is a big loss - others that graduated/out of eligibility, not so much. At some point would be interesting to have our annual W/L prediction /conf finish forecasting. For me too early to peg a finish, but gut says double digit finish in conf.
oskidunker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Is the transfer going to be eligible?
Go Bears!
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
4thGenCal said:

calumnus said:

BeachedBear said:

89Bear said:

Serious question:
If a poll were taken with a group of recruits and they were to rank the factors in their school decision-making, where would location in the country rank?
I see:
-Playing time
-Connection to coaches
-Playing style
-NBA path
-NIL(for a select few)
-Teammates
-Facilities
-Hype factor of school(Crowds, media coverage...)
(Not saying I agree with these priorities.)
Location, for many of these recruits, is low down the list in my opinion.
Agreed. Location is in "All other things being equal category". More importantly, there is little the coaching staff or AD can do (other than take advantage) to change it. Most things on your list CAN be affected or at least influenced. I would add Academic reputation to your list, near the bottom, just above location and below culinary environment and far below coed friendliness.

The other part of the poll probably needs to include parents rankings as well.


I think you have to add tradition/name and chances of making the NCAA Tournament.

Location and campus matter. Think about when you applied for school, it was probably: 1. Academics 2. Location and campus 3. Cost. For top athletes it is just that their sport is #1 replacing academics and cost is not an issue.

Cal has a much better basketball history, name and location than WSU. We have had far more top recruits in our history than they have, for a reason.
Agree - Tradition, chances of making NCAA Tournament, connection to staff,Facilities,Location, playing style,NIL opportunities, housing (parents weigh in often on this) - at the top and then - yes " coed quality" ( its a common complaint amongst the bball and football guys - not sure where that factor ranks though). Academics a lower factor - I usually get the response that it weighed in less than the above criteria. .
Jalen still on crutches and had a pretty heavy setback with the ACL and meniscus tear and a stretch to the MCL - likely not able to be back to normal until Feb/March. Marsalis Roberson recently had some minor scar tissue removal and thus knee surgery and will be fine in a month. Hyder feeling really good and hopefully now that he is healthy, will be much improved. Joel Brown - healthy/recovered from past month minor knee surgery and will be improved. All on campus except the 6' 9" incoming freshman, due to visa issues that should be resolved over the next couple of weeks. Team will be quicker and more athletic - not sure if they can protect the rim, shoot from outside consistently and limit offensive rebounding of the opposing team. Losing Kelly is a big loss - others that graduated/out of eligibility, not so much. At some point would be interesting to have our annual W/L prediction /conf finish forecasting. For me too early to peg a finish, but gut says double digit finish in conf.


What is your current guess at who will be the starting 5?
eastcoastcal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What do y'all think is the reasonable floor for grounds to fire Fox? What is the worst place Fox can finish and be retained?
stu
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

What do y'all think is the reasonable floor for grounds to fire Fox? What is the worst place Fox can finish and be retained?
Reasonable: 6th
Actual: 12th
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

What do y'all think is the reasonable floor for grounds to fire Fox? What is the worst place Fox can finish and be retained?


Is this a prediction or wish?

We already know that we can finish 12th and Fox can get an extension.

I think we should plan on moving on because we can do better, and the sooner the better.

Relating to the OP, Fox and Smith took over programs at the bottom of the conference. Last year WSU went 22-15 (11-9). Id be willing to change my mind if Fox can come close to replicating that.

But do I trust Knowlton to make the right decision and follow up with the right hire?
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

What do y'all think is the reasonable floor for grounds to fire Fox? What is the worst place Fox can finish and be retained?

Any situation like this needs to be looked at holistically.

W/L and conference W/L is right there at the top, obviously. But then there's...

- were most of the losses at least competitive.... "eye test", how does the team project for the next season?
- recruiting outlook
- player satisfaction or lack thereof
- attendance and opinion of fan base, especially major donors and poster "Big C" on Bear Insider


If the team isn't improved -- and most everybody feels it won't be -- hard to imagine Fox surviving past March 2023
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.