dajo9 said:
LudwigsFountain said:
I'll add one more. Medicare has a $50 to $60 trillion unfunded liability. That's trillion with a T. The debt/tax implications of that number are beyond frightening.
Two things:
1 - The U.S. has the most inefficient healthcare in the advanced world and it is bankrupting the nation
2- Talk of "unfunded liabilities" is just meaningless alarmism. What is the comparable national GDP over the same time period?
I don't understand why you think my concern for Medicare's unfunded liability is meaningless alarmism. Instead of looking at this figure in comparison to GDP, I was interested in what it meant for taxes and deficits.. The vast majority of this calculation relates to Medicare Parts B and D. These programs are funded by a combination of general taxation, premiums and deductibles and co pays. (Medicare payroll taxes are dedicated exclusively to Part A). Premiums are set every year so that general taxes cover 75% of the cost. That number is currently over $500 billion, so it's the single biggest contributor to our annual deficit $500 billion a year doesn't get you to a $50-60 trillion present value revenue shortfall; you get there because the use of general taxes for Medicare is projected to reach $4 trillion a year. I asked Google to express all this as a percent of GDP. it said the current figure is 1.9% and is expected to grow to 3.9%. So considering that federal tax receipts have averaged around 18% of GDP, we'd have to raise taxes by 40% to completely eliminate Medicare's contribution to our debt, I knew the number was going to big but I didn't know it would be that big. That's why I found it alarming. Of course, knowing us nothing will be done until there's an absolute crisis. I won't be around, but I worry for my kids and grandkids.