Quote:
You realize that the immigrants coming to the border are ALSO poor and working-class people, for the most part, right? There is nothing inconsistent about a liberal arguing in their favor as well. Do you actually pay attention to liberal arguments on things?
What's wrong with you? The immigrants coming to the border aren't American citizens; the legal immigrants in the country are. This point of yours makes no sense. It is nowhere in the intellectual history of liberalism to be shills for the foreign poor at the expense of the American working class.
Quote:
And which "reform" should liberals support? The time when he tried to prevent everyone from Muslim-majority countries from entering the United States, even those with green cards and other legal documentation? The time when his administration started taking children away from their parents at the border, with no promise of ever returning them? An expensive "wall" that most experts say would not actually help curb illegal immigration?
Would you support a "wall" ? This would actually uncover whether someone is saving face by attacking the "cost".
Quote:
Immigration is a side show. It's not one of the top issues facing our country and every minute spent discussing it is a distraction from our real problems. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that we should ignore it entirely, but we are entirely ignoring real issues because Trump thinks it's a "winning" issue for him. Just because it's a pet issue for him doesn't mean we have to pretend like it should be a top priority. I'm much more concerned about healthcare, wasteful military spending and climate change/environmental issues.
Millions of menial laborers using up both public and private resources is not considerable issue? You say we shouldn't ignore it, so do you acknowledge it's a problem?
It certainly is a winning issue for Trump, I doubt he principally cares about it. But a lot of Americans do. Immigration, especially from 3rd world countries, has considerable social, cultural, and economic impacts on a country and its citizens. More so when the courts guarantee considerable public resources (education, health care) to those immigrants. According to Pew, 40% of Americans support a "wall" (20% of Democrats). Doesn't mean it's a bad or good idea, it just suggests its not a fringe issue. I think there's a lot of anxiety about how to carry it out. The optics of any one immigration reform are strong. There is political and social blowback to doing anything drastic on immigration.
We know what importing low wages does to the existing laboring class. Why do you think it's an issue that isn't big but considerable enough to not be ignored?