Rodney Brown decommits from Cal

14,010 Views | 106 Replies | Last: 2 yr ago by calumnus
socaltownie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SFCityBear said:

BC Calfan said:

It's easy to just blame it on NIL. If so, why did Brown commit in the first place and what transpired in such a short period that made him change his mind?

Maybe another school made a bigger $ offer? OK, then he should have committed to that particular school.

We can speculate all we want but the fact is that it's another horrible look for Fox. We are all just looking for a shred of hope with this moribund program. A sign that things might be turning around. We finally got it and it only lasted 3 weeks.
I don't buy this. Maybe it does not look good for Coach Fox, but when the commitment was made, there were three adults and one young person, likely a minor, in the room. Two of the adults were parents whose advice, and whose word apparently meant little. The young person is not yet mature. likely impressionable, and not yet aware of the fact that in life, a man is only as good as his word. He should have been advised that if he is not sure, then he should wait and let the process play out. The only man in the room who demonstrated some character was coach Fox. He kept his word on the offer of a scholarship. I think it is hard enough to find and evaluate a player, and then try to sell the program and the school to the player, but to try be a mind-reader and evaluate a player, his parents, and maybe his agent as to the value of their word is quite a stretch, IMO.
LOL. This is like 30 years behind the time. Simply put the NIL offer came in better. We are in an entirely new world.
Take care of your Chicken
socaltownie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Shocky1 said:


cal's current basketball staff with a combined age of 200 years on planet earth is the oldest 4 person staff in d1 college basketball, this may not bother mark fox or jim knowlton (they both gonna get paid regardless of results or if haas is a cold empty palace again) but in today's fiercely competitive recruiting environment that necessitates daily contact/communications (something that almost all old white men are incapable of fulfilling) in building relationships this is fatal

jaylen brown told me he tried to explain to jim knowlton the importance of a black trusted father figure/life mentor like coach martin but that he didn't think jim understood what the **** he was talking about

if u want more details, the shockster is posting on the rivals site





cal's monster worser class (don't be a dumb azz)#

YES!!! He emerges. Lets hope 2023 issues in

A new AD
A new BB coach
A return to the Monster Class Thread.

Take care of your Chicken
Bobodeluxe
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Magenta home uniforms.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
stu said:

Bobodeluxe said:

stu said:

Again, waiting till the end of this season is the right thing to do. I wouldn't want any coach fired mid-season except for a serious scandal.
… or an five star player revolt.
Well, we don't have one five-star player and we don't have five players who I'd describe as stars.

Actually I think one of Fox's strengths is retaining the players he has recruited. He has trouble getting recruits to come to Cal but those who do have stayed (I'm not counting all the players recruited by former coaches).


"Everybody" who comes to play for Fox comes because Cal is their only P5 offer, they know they have no chance at the NBA and they know getting a Cal degree is worth putting up with this. Those with some talent grad transfer after getting the degree. Some medically retire and focus on academics. Walk-ons too.
eastcoastcal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Do you think Knowlton can limit Fox to 1-2 players? Would be really terrible if Fox fills a class with low level players and handicaps the next hire
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

Do you think Knowlton can limit Fox to 1-2 players? Would be really terrible if Fox fills a class with low level players and handicaps the next hire


Knowlton would never do that, he is not engaged enough or take charge enough. He pretty much outsourced the hiring in the first place. Treated it like something he wanted to get over with. Plus, he shouldn't. You either fire the guy or you let him do what he thinks is best for the program.

This was the problem with extending him "for COVID" and not cuttting losses and firing him.

What we can hope is that Fox relies HEAVILY on the transfer portal. That will limit the long term roster damage. It also is a strategy Fox might tealize gives the best chance of short term improvement.
BC Calfan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Big visit this weekend. I consider it a victory for our staff when we get a 4-star to even sniff our program.

Darius Carr Visiting Sept 10 Weekend
Intuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Top 150 senior Rodney Brown discusses his de-commitment and reopened recruitment (247sports.com)
Harborview
Intuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Darius Carr, Southern California Academy, Combo Guard (247sports.com)
Harborview
HearstMining
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Intuit said:

Top 150 senior Rodney Brown discusses his de-commitment and reopened recruitment (247sports.com)
So the question is, does Fox have hurt feelings and walk away, or does he do what Wilcox apparently did with Ott; stay in touch, try to understand the recruit's concerns and address them?
BeachedBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
socaltownie said:

SFCityBear said:


....
LOL. This is like 30 years behind the time. Simply put the NIL offer came in better. We are in an entirely new world.
30 years ago, a commitment meant that there was a . . . commitment. Over the last couple decades we have had various levels of commitment and the winnowing of the all powerful LOI. The last year or two (particularly with NIL) - a commitment is more like a tweet with really no basis until they actually enroll at the university AND put on a jersey. Everything else is just eyeball candy.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
^^^ I just looked it up and you are correct ^^^

From the Official 2022 Dictionary of Sports Terms: "commitment" - it's sort of like a tweet
dimitrig
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Intuit said:

Top 150 senior Rodney Brown discusses his de-commitment and reopened recruitment (247sports.com)


"California-Berkley?"

Is that like "Stanfurd?"

KoreAmBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
dimitrig said:

Intuit said:

Top 150 senior Rodney Brown discusses his de-commitment and reopened recruitment (247sports.com)


"California-Berkley?"

Is that like "Stanfurd?"


He "owed it to himself" to go through the process.

Because what he wronged himself by committing so early to Cal? *Smh*

Just say you committed too early, and have second thoughts. No need for the owed an obligation to oneself business. The recruiting process is not some moral/ethical gauntlet.
dimitrig
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KoreAmBear said:

dimitrig said:

Intuit said:

Top 150 senior Rodney Brown discusses his de-commitment and reopened recruitment (247sports.com)


"California-Berkley?"

Is that like "Stanfurd?"


He "owed it to himself" to go through the process.

Because what he wronged himself by committing so early to Cal? *Smh*

Just say you committed too early, and have second thoughts. No need for the owed an obligation to oneself business. The recruiting process is not some moral/ethical gauntlet.


It would be nice if he mentioned something about Cal and where we stand instead of talking about Arizona, which hasn't even expressed interest recently.

Or did I miss where he talked about Cal and Fox?

Bobodeluxe
How long do you want to ignore this user?
dimitrig said:

KoreAmBear said:

dimitrig said:

Intuit said:

Top 150 senior Rodney Brown discusses his de-commitment and reopened recruitment (247sports.com)


"California-Berkley?"

Is that like "Stanfurd?"


He "owed it to himself" to go through the process.

Because what he wronged himself by committing so early to Cal? *Smh*

Just say you committed too early, and have second thoughts. No need for the owed an obligation to oneself business. The recruiting process is not some moral/ethical gauntlet.


It would be nice if he mentioned something about Cal and where we stand instead of talking about Arizona, which hasn't even expressed interest recently.

Or did I miss where he talked about Cal and Fox?


He loved Fox, but the fan sites disturbed him.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bobodeluxe said:

dimitrig said:

KoreAmBear said:

dimitrig said:

Intuit said:

Top 150 senior Rodney Brown discusses his de-commitment and reopened recruitment (247sports.com)


"California-Berkley?"

Is that like "Stanfurd?"


He "owed it to himself" to go through the process.

Because what he wronged himself by committing so early to Cal? *Smh*

Just say you committed too early, and have second thoughts. No need for the owed an obligation to oneself business. The recruiting process is not some moral/ethical gauntlet.


It would be nice if he mentioned something about Cal and where we stand instead of talking about Arizona, which hasn't even expressed interest recently.

Or did I miss where he talked about Cal and Fox?


He loved Fox, but the lack of fan enthusiasm disturbed him.

FIFY
smh
How long do you want to ignore this user?
> He loved Fox, but the fan sites disturbed him.

funny (not)
muting more than 300 handles, turnaround is fair play
SFCityBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
smh said:

> He loved Fox, but the fan sites disturbed him.

funny (not)

I often wonder whether potential recruits, their families, or friends ever read comments on this forum during the recruiting process to see what a school's fans have to say about the Cal basketball program. What a recruit sees on this board is a small, but vocal, group of Cal fans, and not necessarily typical of all Cal fans. Still, with a high percentage of the fans here disparaging the Cal program, the Cal coach, and the AD, I wonder if it would have a negative effect on our recruiting. And a few of these vocal posters now seem to be predicting a firing during this season or immediately following. If I was a recruit, looking at which school I'd like to play for, would I want to go with a school who was likely to fire its coach very soon, or go to a school whose coach will likely be gone shortly, and I'll end up playing for a new coach I don't know, or transferring to another school. Any transfer I make after the first one, I'll have to sit out a year, so I lose that advantage from the new rule. I think frankly I'd decide to play for a coach who is not under the threat of being fired, rather than play for a coach who is has a good chance to be fired.
SFCityBear
SFCityBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
socaltownie said:

SFCityBear said:

BC Calfan said:

It's easy to just blame it on NIL. If so, why did Brown commit in the first place and what transpired in such a short period that made him change his mind?

Maybe another school made a bigger $ offer? OK, then he should have committed to that particular school.

We can speculate all we want but the fact is that it's another horrible look for Fox. We are all just looking for a shred of hope with this moribund program. A sign that things might be turning around. We finally got it and it only lasted 3 weeks.
I don't buy this. Maybe it does not look good for Coach Fox, but when the commitment was made, there were three adults and one young person, likely a minor, in the room. Two of the adults were parents whose advice, and whose word apparently meant little. The young person is not yet mature. likely impressionable, and not yet aware of the fact that in life, a man is only as good as his word. He should have been advised that if he is not sure, then he should wait and let the process play out. The only man in the room who demonstrated some character was coach Fox. He kept his word on the offer of a scholarship. I think it is hard enough to find and evaluate a player, and then try to sell the program and the school to the player, but to try be a mind-reader and evaluate a player, his parents, and maybe his agent as to the value of their word is quite a stretch, IMO.
LOL. This is like 30 years behind the time. Simply put the NIL offer came in better. We are in an entirely new world.
Do you think there will already be high $ NIL offers for a 3-star player?
SFCityBear
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SFCityBear said:

socaltownie said:

SFCityBear said:

BC Calfan said:

It's easy to just blame it on NIL. If so, why did Brown commit in the first place and what transpired in such a short period that made him change his mind?

Maybe another school made a bigger $ offer? OK, then he should have committed to that particular school.

We can speculate all we want but the fact is that it's another horrible look for Fox. We are all just looking for a shred of hope with this moribund program. A sign that things might be turning around. We finally got it and it only lasted 3 weeks.
I don't buy this. Maybe it does not look good for Coach Fox, but when the commitment was made, there were three adults and one young person, likely a minor, in the room. Two of the adults were parents whose advice, and whose word apparently meant little. The young person is not yet mature. likely impressionable, and not yet aware of the fact that in life, a man is only as good as his word. He should have been advised that if he is not sure, then he should wait and let the process play out. The only man in the room who demonstrated some character was coach Fox. He kept his word on the offer of a scholarship. I think it is hard enough to find and evaluate a player, and then try to sell the program and the school to the player, but to try be a mind-reader and evaluate a player, his parents, and maybe his agent as to the value of their word is quite a stretch, IMO.
LOL. This is like 30 years behind the time. Simply put the NIL offer came in better. We are in an entirely new world.
Do you think there will already be high $ NIL offers for a 3-star player?


He is reopening his recruitment to see what is available. He is just inside the Top 150, so a high 3 star. He is trying to get Arizona interested. Maybe he is trying to get an offer from California Legends before he recommits?
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

SFCityBear said:

socaltownie said:

SFCityBear said:

BC Calfan said:

It's easy to just blame it on NIL. If so, why did Brown commit in the first place and what transpired in such a short period that made him change his mind?

Maybe another school made a bigger $ offer? OK, then he should have committed to that particular school.

We can speculate all we want but the fact is that it's another horrible look for Fox. We are all just looking for a shred of hope with this moribund program. A sign that things might be turning around. We finally got it and it only lasted 3 weeks.
I don't buy this. Maybe it does not look good for Coach Fox, but when the commitment was made, there were three adults and one young person, likely a minor, in the room. Two of the adults were parents whose advice, and whose word apparently meant little. The young person is not yet mature. likely impressionable, and not yet aware of the fact that in life, a man is only as good as his word. He should have been advised that if he is not sure, then he should wait and let the process play out. The only man in the room who demonstrated some character was coach Fox. He kept his word on the offer of a scholarship. I think it is hard enough to find and evaluate a player, and then try to sell the program and the school to the player, but to try be a mind-reader and evaluate a player, his parents, and maybe his agent as to the value of their word is quite a stretch, IMO.
LOL. This is like 30 years behind the time. Simply put the NIL offer came in better. We are in an entirely new world.
Do you think there will already be high $ NIL offers for a 3-star player?


He is reopening his recruitment to see what is available. He is just inside the Top 150, so a high 3 star. He is trying to get Arizona interested. Maybe he is trying to get an offer from California Legends before he recommits?

1. These kids' entourages are always telling them how good they are and, if not, well they surely will be.

2. Honestly, in this new NIL era, they can't be blamed for getting what they can, when they can. It's what we do!
rfmason44
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Fox and Knowlton stealing money
sluggo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

SFCityBear said:

socaltownie said:

SFCityBear said:

BC Calfan said:

It's easy to just blame it on NIL. If so, why did Brown commit in the first place and what transpired in such a short period that made him change his mind?

Maybe another school made a bigger $ offer? OK, then he should have committed to that particular school.

We can speculate all we want but the fact is that it's another horrible look for Fox. We are all just looking for a shred of hope with this moribund program. A sign that things might be turning around. We finally got it and it only lasted 3 weeks.
I don't buy this. Maybe it does not look good for Coach Fox, but when the commitment was made, there were three adults and one young person, likely a minor, in the room. Two of the adults were parents whose advice, and whose word apparently meant little. The young person is not yet mature. likely impressionable, and not yet aware of the fact that in life, a man is only as good as his word. He should have been advised that if he is not sure, then he should wait and let the process play out. The only man in the room who demonstrated some character was coach Fox. He kept his word on the offer of a scholarship. I think it is hard enough to find and evaluate a player, and then try to sell the program and the school to the player, but to try be a mind-reader and evaluate a player, his parents, and maybe his agent as to the value of their word is quite a stretch, IMO.
LOL. This is like 30 years behind the time. Simply put the NIL offer came in better. We are in an entirely new world.
Do you think there will already be high $ NIL offers for a 3-star player?


He is reopening his recruitment to see what is available. He is just inside the Top 150, so a high 3 star. He is trying to get Arizona interested. Maybe he is trying to get an offer from California Legends before he recommits?
I think he is severely under-ranked and can get a much better offer if he waits. I hope in the end he comes to Cal.
eastcoastcal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
How many scholarship spots do we have open for this class?
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
eastcoastcal said:

How many scholarship spots do we have open for this class?

That really depends on who plans on staying through their full eligibility (and if we want them to stay).
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sluggo said:

calumnus said:

SFCityBear said:

socaltownie said:

SFCityBear said:

BC Calfan said:

It's easy to just blame it on NIL. If so, why did Brown commit in the first place and what transpired in such a short period that made him change his mind?

Maybe another school made a bigger $ offer? OK, then he should have committed to that particular school.

We can speculate all we want but the fact is that it's another horrible look for Fox. We are all just looking for a shred of hope with this moribund program. A sign that things might be turning around. We finally got it and it only lasted 3 weeks.
I don't buy this. Maybe it does not look good for Coach Fox, but when the commitment was made, there were three adults and one young person, likely a minor, in the room. Two of the adults were parents whose advice, and whose word apparently meant little. The young person is not yet mature. likely impressionable, and not yet aware of the fact that in life, a man is only as good as his word. He should have been advised that if he is not sure, then he should wait and let the process play out. The only man in the room who demonstrated some character was coach Fox. He kept his word on the offer of a scholarship. I think it is hard enough to find and evaluate a player, and then try to sell the program and the school to the player, but to try be a mind-reader and evaluate a player, his parents, and maybe his agent as to the value of their word is quite a stretch, IMO.
LOL. This is like 30 years behind the time. Simply put the NIL offer came in better. We are in an entirely new world.
Do you think there will already be high $ NIL offers for a 3-star player?


He is reopening his recruitment to see what is available. He is just inside the Top 150, so a high 3 star. He is trying to get Arizona interested. Maybe he is trying to get an offer from California Legends before he recommits?
I think he is severely under-ranked and can get a much better offer if he waits. I hope in the end he comes to Cal.


Agreed on both counts. When he decommited he only said he had "commited too soon." He knows he likes Cal, but that Cal has a multiple scholies to give and will save one for him.

I hope he signs with Cal. I hope the California legends gets him some NIL money.
HearstMining
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Maybe Fox should find out how Cal's football staff responded to Jaydn Ott's decommitment because whatever they did worked, didn't it?
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?

...or ask Ben Braun how he handled Patrick Christopher.

I think what you do is, take a deep breath and then tell the kid you'll always be there for him (her), keep in touch and hope for the best.
concordtom
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Big C said:


...or ask Ben Braun how he handled Patrick Christopher.

I think what you do is, take a deep breath and then tell the kid you'll always be there for him (her), keep in touch and hope for the best.

Patrick Christopher?
Is there some kind of story there?
concordtom
How long do you want to ignore this user?
socaltownie said:

Shocky1 said:


cal's current basketball staff with a combined age of 200 years on planet earth is the oldest 4 person staff in d1 college basketball, this may not bother mark fox or jim knowlton (they both gonna get paid regardless of results or if haas is a cold empty palace again) but in today's fiercely competitive recruiting environment that necessitates daily contact/communications (something that almost all old white men are incapable of fulfilling) in building relationships this is fatal

jaylen brown told me he tried to explain to jim knowlton the importance of a black trusted father figure/life mentor like coach martin but that he didn't think jim understood what the **** he was talking about

if u want more details, the shockster is posting on the rivals site





cal's monster worser class (don't be a dumb azz)#

YES!!! He emerges. Lets hope 2023 issues in

A new AD
A new BB coach
A return to the Monster Class Thread.



Oh, you've got to be kidding me!
Dude comes here, again, after repeatedly being bumped off, and rips on Cal folks, then touts his own posts on another website - as if we care to go there to read his blather?

Talk about being 200 years old?!!
So is his act that he has some sort of inside information.
socaltownie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
While Bill has many warts the bottom line is that interest on this board was never higher than when the master thread was a must read. The number of daily new posts on this page are well under 20 and the interest in the program has never been lower
Take care of your Chicken
bearchamp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I don't recall that Shocky1 was ever a "must read". My recollection was the only reason to read was to see the next embarrassment being submitted.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?

(oops, responded to my own post, when i meant to respond to concordtom's... deleted)
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
concordtom said:

Big C said:


...or ask Ben Braun how he handled Patrick Christopher.

I think what you do is, take a deep breath and then tell the kid you'll always be there for him (her), keep in touch and hope for the best.

Patrick Christopher?
Is there some kind of story there?


Patrick Christopher -- rather highly regarded as a recruit -- committed early to Ben Braun, then decommitted and reflected on things for a fair amount of time, then recommitted. The story had a happy ending. Braun did the right thing, apparently, and stuck with him, supportively. Which is an even better strategy now with the portal.

LOL, I remember one Joe Kapp story where he had a recruit committed, or at least leaning, then the young man changed his mind and committed to UW. Kapp went ballistic on him, supposedly. He couldn't fathom how anybody wouldn't want to come to Cal, especially after hearing his sales pitch.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.