HearstMining said:
Thanks for sharing this. While it's a demonstration, I still see several differences with today's game:
- McHale makes an actual jump-stop when setting the pick which pretty much eliminates the chance of the ref calling a moving screen. Today's players shuffle which makes it less clear when/if they actually stop.
- Why do today's players shuffle? I think it's because the ball-handler starts trying to use the screen before it's set and he doesn't take a good angle or cut close enough to the screener so the screener keeps resetting his feet so his screen is effective.
- Today's screener sometimes rolls to the hoop too soon, before the ball-handler has run the defender into him, reducing the effectiveness of the screen.
- McHale sets the screen about a foot away from the defender. In today's game, I've seen that called a foul numerous times. Referees seem to expect that the screen is set no closer than 2-3 feet from the defender providing more space for the defender to go over or under the screen.
Times change, and so has basketball.
It has become a game with basically no rules. The rules, or lack of them, or lack of their enforcement, which have tilted the scales in favor of the offense. More scoring, and especially exciting to the eye scoring sells tickets, seats and viewers. In the pros, it is greedy owners, coaches and players, and today in the colleges, it is greedy administrations, athletic directors, coaches, and many players. Money, or the idea of it, has ruined our game for the moment.
As to the pick and roll, it is one of several time-honored basketball plays, along with the give-and-go, the back door, etc. Pete Newell said that the two man play was the foundation of basketball. His practices usually consisted of various drills on individual fundamentals, like footwork, positioning, but there was also considerable time working on the two man play. The players would split up into groups of two men, working on say, a pick and roll, first alone by themselves and then later with two defenders. First, they would walk through the play a few times, and then run through it at game speed, and then at game speed with defenders, until they could work it to perfection. They practiced most days of the week, and on the last day, as the final event of a practice session, there would be a scrimmage. Newell usually left the gym for the scrimmage, which was run by his assistant coaches. I was often in the gallery for the practice, and as someone who aspired to make the team, I focused on watching the individual footwork drills, and the two-man plays. I didn't pay much attention to the scrimmage part of practice. I figured that if Newell wasn't interested in seeing it, then I wouldn't be either. And it gave me an extra 45 minutes to study for classes. The plays were the thing. The only play I remember where more players were involved was the weave, where 3-5 players were involved. It was all great fun to watch and play, especially the precision and timing that the Cal players achieved. Plays like these were one reason why the Cal players could easily execute a play resulting in an open high percentage shot, like a layup, in 10 seconds or less.