Off Topic
Sponsored by

The Official Russian Invasion of Ukraine Thread

2,434,091 Views | 14326 Replies | Last: 9 days ago by smh
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ACC Bear said:

bearister said:

This comment isn't directed at you:
Before AI Overview, the usual suspects here would post some provocative MAGA bullsh@it and cite catturd, amuse or some other anonymous hack as the source.
I would spend time researching to find legitimate material to rebut the propaganda and then post it. The original poster would then drop some flippant one liner in response to my post.

Now with AI Overview:
It takes me 10 seconds or less to find a summary of 100+ articles that calls bullsh@t on amuse and catturd. If the original poster wants to spend the time pointing out the AI Overview is wrong, they can have at it like you did.

I can tell you that I won't post an AI Overview that isn't consistent with my understanding from my prior reading on the topic. I also look at the multiple sample sources they cite at the end of the AI Overview to see if they meet my credibility standards.

You call my sources unreliable MSM and I think your sources are often highly biased and outlier. We mostly disagree on things, but you are a gentleman and polite.





Hey, as BI's Chief Critical Thinker, do you have any smug, flippant comments to make about the actions of the man you deny you voted for?

"President Trump is gradually testing, stretching and gutting the independence of America's major institutions, leaving few stones unturned in his pursuit of unchecked power, Axios' Zachary Basu writes.

Why it matters: In Trump's vision of America, authority flows only from his consent.

The firing of Fed governor Lisa Cook, a first in modern history, shows that even the central bank's legendary independence is no longer untouchable.

"I have the right to do anything I want to do. I'm the president of the United States," Trump told reporters yesterday when discussing his threat to send the National Guard into Chicago.

The big picture: In just seven months, Trump has consolidated vast power by following a clear playbook:

Capture what he can, contest what he can't and punish those who resist.

1. Captured institutions: Trump has exerted decisive control over every inch of the executive branch, leaving little pretense of independence anywhere in the federal bureaucracy.

Justice Department: Trump has declared himself, not the attorney general ,as America's "chief law enforcement officer." He's stacked the DOJ with loyalists who are now leading criminal investigations into Democrats, Obama-era intelligence officials and other Trump critics.

Intelligence community: Security clearances have been stripped from alleged leakers, and intelligence staff have been cut dramatically. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth even fired the head of the Defense Intelligence Agency after a preliminary assessment by the DIA suggested Trump's Iran strikes were less successful than he claimed.

Independent agencies: An executive order moved all regulatory bodies under White House control, erasing decades of autonomy and enabling the gutting of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and U.S. Agency for International Development.

Washington, D.C.: Trump has seized control, literally and figuratively, over much of the nation's capital, deploying the National Guard, taking over the Kennedy Center and threatening the Smithsonian over what he deemed "anti-American" content.

2. Contested battlegrounds: These arenas face constant interference, but Trump hasn't yet achieved full capture:

Military: Trump has fired top generals and required new four-star nominees to meet with him.

Congress: The White House has eroded the legislature's core powers on tariffs, spending and war, sidelining lawmakers with emergency declarations or outright defiance.

Academia and law: The Trump administration has extracted over $1 billion in settlements from elite universities and law firms, weaponizing the federal government's enormous funding leverage to browbeat liberal power centers.

3. Remaining resistance: These are the institutions that still act as counterweights, even if Trump is trying to kneecap them:

Courts: Federal judges have frozen dozens of Trump's most aggressive policies and spoken out against intimidation. Still, the White House has escalated attacks on "rogue" judges, testing whether the judiciary can withstand sustained pressure.

Media: Major outlets continue to investigate and expose contradictions in Trump's presidency, even as he curtails access, threatens regulatory action against broadcasters, and promotes loyalist voices in the press corps.

Democratic Party: Despite their unpopularity, Democrats remain a legitimate opposition force, using congressional hearings, lawsuits and state governments to challenge Trump."
Axios



*I really dig that the owner of this site f@ucking hates your guts and stomps on your bullsh@it almost as quickly as you spew it.
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside

“I love Cal deeply, by the way, what are the directions to The Portal from Sproul Plaza?”
ACC Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bearister said:

ACC Bear said:




Hey, as BI's Chief Critical Thinker, do you have any smug, flippant comments to make about the actions of the man you deny you voted for?

I sure do and thanks for asking!







The destruction of the Democrats is 100% worth four more years of Trump.

https://media.tenor.com/uARaKFpSkaMAAAAC/anger-management-jack-nicholson.gif
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
"The destruction of the Democrats is 100% worth four more years of Trump."

At least you are honest on that point. I hope after 4 years it's over.

1. Are you ok with the Trumpism punishment lasting more than 4 years?
2. If both Trumpism and Democrats become no longer viable, what are you hoping for?
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside

“I love Cal deeply, by the way, what are the directions to The Portal from Sproul Plaza?”
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
NBC: Rheinmetall chief says Europe must catch up with Russia's ammunition output as it opens mega plant

"CEO Armin Papperger on Wednesday told CNBC that Russia had the capacity to put out 4 to 5 million artillery ammunition rounds a year. Comparatively, he said Europe has a yearly output of around 2 million, more than half of which is produced by Rheinmetall....

"...Europe's "biggest need is artillery ammunition and missiles," Papperger said, stressing the new plant in Unterluess will focus on both items. The plant's output is expected to reach 350,000 artillery shells a year by 2027....

"...The NATO chief added that Russia and China were "producing weapons and heavy military equipment at an incredible rate" and with "little transparency." "

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/08/28/rheinmetall-chief-says-europe-must-catch-up-with-russian-ammo-output.html



Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I seriously doubt that Europe's current output is anywhere close to 2 million shells/year.
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
And the new factory, not a game changer, probably won't be at 100% capacity until the war is over.

Politico: Trump admin offers subdued response to Russia's assault on Kyiv, and Europe's outrage

"Allies sought to convince Trump that deadly overnight attacks make clear that Putin's not interested in peace. But they made little headway"

The article notes how EU leaders are trying to sway President Trump w tweets. Weak.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The allies are probably right that Putin is not interested in peace.
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The Russians did offer what looks today like a peace deal with very favorable terms in April 2022 in Istanbul, including withdrawal from all territories except Crimea, at a time when they occupied a lot more Ukrainian territory than they do now.
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Maybe Putin wants the Dniper River + demilitarized zone, maybe he wants Odessa. Russian troops appear to be rolling at twice the pace, while Ukraine scatters.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

The Russians did offer what looks today like a peace deal with very favorable terms in April 2022 in Istanbul, including withdrawal from all territories except Crimea, at a time when they occupied a lot more Ukrainian territory than they do now.

I notice this was from three years ago. That deal still on the table?
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

The Istanbul deal had called for greater autonomy to the Donbas provinces within a federal Ukrainian system similar to those in place in Spain, Belgium, the UK or Canada.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

What peace deal is on offer from Putin now?
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

What peace deal is on offer from Putin now?


The Russians have essentially floated an "Istanbul Plus" deal that retakes the same outlines as the original deal (Ukraine neutral/no NATO, limits on Ukrainian military, equal rights for Russophones, restoration of the Orthodox Church) and adds a recognition of the 4 oblasts they mostly occupy as Russian territory.

Two items would be left for negotiation, the annexation of parts of the oblasts that the Russians don't currently hold (like the city of Kherson or Slovyansk in Donetsk oblast), and allocation of part of the $300 billion fund for Ukrainian reconstruction.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

What peace deal is on offer from Putin now?


The Russians have essentially floated an "Istanbul Plus" deal that retakes the same outlines as the original deal (Ukraine neutral/no NATO, limits on Ukrainian military, equal rights for Russophones, restoration of the Orthodox Church) and adds a recognition of the 4 oblasts they mostly occupy as Russian territory.

Two items would be left for negotiation, the annexation of parts of the oblasts that the Russians don't currently hold (like the city of Kherson or Slovyansk in Donetsk oblast), and allocation of part of the $300 billion fund for Ukrainian reconstruction.

Is there anything in these deals that would prevent Ukraine from being invaded again?
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The application of these provisions would be more than enough. The Russians went into Ukraine reluctantly, Putin was widely criticized at home for not having intervened much earlier in the Ukrainian civil war that started in 2014 with the "ATO". Alternatively the Russians could go for a neutral/UN non-NATO type of peacekeeping force along the Korean lines at the established borders.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

The application of these provisions would be more than enough.

Doesn't seem like Ukraine or most of Europe agrees.

And sure, you could just say, "Screw them, they wanted war" or something, but how do you get a peace agreement without them?
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The Frenchie cheese eaters will hold the line.
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

The application of these provisions would be more than enough.

Doesn't seem like Ukraine or most of Europe agrees.

And sure, you could just say, "Screw them, they wanted war" or something, but how do you get a peace agreement without them?



You can't, Trump can put some pressure on them but he won't pull the plug, because Ukraine would collapse militarily without US support and he would be blamed for that. It's a lack of courage on his part, or perhaps his advisors talked him out of it. As it is, Ukraine's military will eventually crumble later next year, they can't sustain the ongoing attrition rates that much longer, continued military support for Ukraine amounts to kicking the can down the road, and adding several hundred thousands more deaths to the tally. in a battle whose outcome is not in doubt.
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Supposedly some key areas Ukraine now holds were constructed w strong defensive positions. If they lose / fall back, there will be a lot of defenseless area Russia can advance through.
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Slovyansk-Kramatorsk in the Donetsk region, the last remaining heavily fortified Ukrainian position in the Donbas. It's not too far from Bakhmut, but the Russians don't want to repeat the Bakhmut scenario where they lost 25k KIA to take that fortress, they will go around, bomb heavily the bunkers with glide bombs and gnaw at the supply lines instead. It's a battle that will play out next year if the war goes on.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

The application of these provisions would be more than enough.

Doesn't seem like Ukraine or most of Europe agrees.

And sure, you could just say, "Screw them, they wanted war" or something, but how do you get a peace agreement without them?



You can't, Trump can put some pressure on them but he won't pull the plug, because Ukraine would collapse militarily without US support and he would be blamed for that. It's a lack of courage on his part, or perhaps his advisors talked him out of it. As it is, Ukraine's military will eventually crumble later next year, they can't sustain the ongoing attrition rates that much longer, continued military support for Ukraine amounts to kicking the can down the road, and adding several hundred thousands more deaths to the tally. in a battle whose outcome is not in doubt.

And if this is truly the case, why would Putin agree to a peace now? He figures he's going to win anyway.
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

The application of these provisions would be more than enough.

Doesn't seem like Ukraine or most of Europe agrees.

And sure, you could just say, "Screw them, they wanted war" or something, but how do you get a peace agreement without them?



You can't, Trump can put some pressure on them but he won't pull the plug, because Ukraine would collapse militarily without US support and he would be blamed for that. It's a lack of courage on his part, or perhaps his advisors talked him out of it. As it is, Ukraine's military will eventually crumble later next year, they can't sustain the ongoing attrition rates that much longer, continued military support for Ukraine amounts to kicking the can down the road, and adding several hundred thousands more deaths to the tally. in a battle whose outcome is not in doubt.

And if this is truly the case, why would Putin agree to a peace now? He figures he's going to win anyway.



Bigger picture - he wants a new security paradigm and normalization with the US and EU, sees an opportunity with Trump, would rather avoid further losses and knows that the further west he goes into Ukraine, the more hostile the population will be, especially past the russophone majority eastern third of that country.

You're right though, his BATNA is fairly good at this point, it's Istanbul Plus or the war keeps going.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

The application of these provisions would be more than enough.

Doesn't seem like Ukraine or most of Europe agrees.

And sure, you could just say, "Screw them, they wanted war" or something, but how do you get a peace agreement without them?



You can't, Trump can put some pressure on them but he won't pull the plug, because Ukraine would collapse militarily without US support and he would be blamed for that. It's a lack of courage on his part, or perhaps his advisors talked him out of it. As it is, Ukraine's military will eventually crumble later next year, they can't sustain the ongoing attrition rates that much longer, continued military support for Ukraine amounts to kicking the can down the road, and adding several hundred thousands more deaths to the tally. in a battle whose outcome is not in doubt.

And if this is truly the case, why would Putin agree to a peace now? He figures he's going to win anyway.



Bigger picture - he wants a new security paradigm and normalization with the US and EU, sees an opportunity with Trump, would rather avoid further losses and knows that the further west he goes into Ukraine, the more hostile the population will be, especially past the russophone majority eastern third of that country.

You're right though, his BATNA is fairly good at this point, it's Istanbul Plus or the war keeps going.

If he knows this, why did he try to capture Kiev in the first place?
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
He sent what, 10k-15k troops to capture a city of 3 million?? If he wanted to capture and hold Kieve, he would have needed a lot more troops, given that the city was the main military garrison with 100,000 militants and Azov types from western Ukraine.

It was an operation meant to force Kiev to sign and comply with a Minsk Plus agreement. Note that the Istanbul Agreement written by Russia stipulated Russian withdrawal from the ~30% of Ukraine that they held in April 23 in exchange for neutrality and disarmament, the Russians did not want to hold on to any Ukrainian territory in early 23, not even the Donbas (Crimea excepted).
ACC Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bearister said:

"The destruction of the Democrats is 100% worth four more years of Trump."

At least you are honest on that point. I hope after 4 years it's over.

1. Are you ok with the Trumpism punishment lasting more than 4 years?
2. If both Trumpism and Democrats become no longer viable, what are you hoping for?

Not that you deserve it at all because the appropriate death for you would be while you are in the middle of posting your latest tragically unfunny meme, but Trumpism is going to slowly die after 2028. What will replace it remains to be seen. Vance will almost certainly be the Republican nominee in 2028 because there are no compelling Republicans to challenge him and if Democrats put up another dullard like Kamala, he will trounce the **** out of that person because Vance, whatever his flaws, is battle tested by doing tons of adversarial interviews and knows how to handle himself in that situation while Democrats hide in their safe spaces and come off inevitably as thoroughly inauthentic.

Gavin won't even get to the nomination. Middle America will reject him instantly for being the fake that he is.



sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

He sent what, 10k-15k troops to capture a city of 3 million?? If he wanted to capture and hold Kieve, he would have needed a lot more troops, given that the city was the main military garrison with 100,000 militants and Azov types from western Ukraine.

It was an operation meant to force Kiev to sign and comply with a Minsk Plus agreement. Note that the Istanbul Agreement written by Russia stipulated Russian withdrawal from the ~30% of Ukraine that they held in April 23 in exchange for neutrality and disarmament, the Russians did not want to hold on to any Ukrainian territory in early 23, not even the Donbas (Crimea excepted).

And that part is exactly why the Ukrainians and their European allies won't accept any agreement that doesn't come with security guarantees that will prevent Russia from pulling that stunt again. The Ukrainians don't want a government that is compliant with Putin and probably would never accept that kind of arrangement.
ACC Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

What peace deal is on offer from Putin now?


The Russians have essentially floated an "Istanbul Plus" deal that retakes the same outlines as the original deal (Ukraine neutral/no NATO, limits on Ukrainian military, equal rights for Russophones, restoration of the Orthodox Church) and adds a recognition of the 4 oblasts they mostly occupy as Russian territory.

Two items would be left for negotiation, the annexation of parts of the oblasts that the Russians don't currently hold (like the city of Kherson or Slovyansk in Donetsk oblast), and allocation of part of the $300 billion fund for Ukrainian reconstruction.

Is there anything in these deals that would prevent Ukraine from being invaded again?

Was there anything in the deals Russia made with the United States that prevented NATO from moving eastward?

All of the stupid questions that you ask about this war have been answered a million times more than satisfactorily, but because you refuse to admit that NATO did everything they could to force Russia into a military response, you pretend that somehow you're right even though you have been far and away the most wrong person on this war from the very start.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ACC Bear said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

What peace deal is on offer from Putin now?


The Russians have essentially floated an "Istanbul Plus" deal that retakes the same outlines as the original deal (Ukraine neutral/no NATO, limits on Ukrainian military, equal rights for Russophones, restoration of the Orthodox Church) and adds a recognition of the 4 oblasts they mostly occupy as Russian territory.

Two items would be left for negotiation, the annexation of parts of the oblasts that the Russians don't currently hold (like the city of Kherson or Slovyansk in Donetsk oblast), and allocation of part of the $300 billion fund for Ukrainian reconstruction.

Is there anything in these deals that would prevent Ukraine from being invaded again?

Was there anything in the deals Russia made with the United States that prevented NATO from moving eastward?

All of the stupid questions that you ask about this war have been answered a million times more than satisfactorily, but because you refuse to admit that NATO did everything they could to force Russia into a military response, you pretend that somehow you're right even though you have been far and away the most wrong person on this war from the very start.

No, I still think I'm quite right about Putin wanting to conquer and not really being interested in peace. Just trying to understand why people seem to stubbornly believe otherwise.

Also, no one has been more wrong about this war than the people who stridently claimed that it wouldn't happen at all, because Putin was too rational to invade. Sure he was.
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Vance / Gabbard?

Vance / Trump?

Gabbard / ???
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:

ACC Bear said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

What peace deal is on offer from Putin now?


The Russians have essentially floated an "Istanbul Plus" deal that retakes the same outlines as the original deal (Ukraine neutral/no NATO, limits on Ukrainian military, equal rights for Russophones, restoration of the Orthodox Church) and adds a recognition of the 4 oblasts they mostly occupy as Russian territory.

Two items would be left for negotiation, the annexation of parts of the oblasts that the Russians don't currently hold (like the city of Kherson or Slovyansk in Donetsk oblast), and allocation of part of the $300 billion fund for Ukrainian reconstruction.

Is there anything in these deals that would prevent Ukraine from being invaded again?

Was there anything in the deals Russia made with the United States that prevented NATO from moving eastward?

All of the stupid questions that you ask about this war have been answered a million times more than satisfactorily, but because you refuse to admit that NATO did everything they could to force Russia into a military response, you pretend that somehow you're right even though you have been far and away the most wrong person on this war from the very start.


No, I still think I'm quite right about Putin wanting to conquer and not really being interested in peace. Just trying to understand why people seem to stubbornly believe otherwise.

Answer: you ignore common-sense, basic facts.

#1: Because western Ukraine isn't pro Russia, and doesn't have 50% to 70% ethically Russian citizens.

#2: Eastern Ukraine has the most valuable resources and industrial base.

#3: Russia already has massive land holdings and at least $75 Trillion in natural resources (assets).



Also, no one has been more wrong about this war than the people who stridently claimed that it wouldn't happen at all, because Putin was too rational to invade. Sure he was.


I haven't read anyone posit that. Some complained about NATO / West repeatedly breaking agreements.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
movielover said:

sycasey said:

ACC Bear said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

sycasey said:

Cal88 said:

Russia has already annexed the Donbas and the land bridge to Crimea, they won't go back on that, and the Donbas population would strongly oppose that.

What peace deal is on offer from Putin now?


The Russians have essentially floated an "Istanbul Plus" deal that retakes the same outlines as the original deal (Ukraine neutral/no NATO, limits on Ukrainian military, equal rights for Russophones, restoration of the Orthodox Church) and adds a recognition of the 4 oblasts they mostly occupy as Russian territory.

Two items would be left for negotiation, the annexation of parts of the oblasts that the Russians don't currently hold (like the city of Kherson or Slovyansk in Donetsk oblast), and allocation of part of the $300 billion fund for Ukrainian reconstruction.

Is there anything in these deals that would prevent Ukraine from being invaded again?

Was there anything in the deals Russia made with the United States that prevented NATO from moving eastward?

All of the stupid questions that you ask about this war have been answered a million times more than satisfactorily, but because you refuse to admit that NATO did everything they could to force Russia into a military response, you pretend that somehow you're right even though you have been far and away the most wrong person on this war from the very start.


No, I still think I'm quite right about Putin wanting to conquer and not really being interested in peace. Just trying to understand why people seem to stubbornly believe otherwise.

Answer: you ignore common-sense, basic facts.

#1: Because western Ukraine isn't pro Russia, and doesn't have 50% to 70% ethically Russian citizens.

#2: Eastern Ukraine has the most valuable resources and industrial base.

#3: Russia already has massive land holdings and at least $75 Trillion in natural resources (assets).



Also, no one has been more wrong about this war than the people who stridently claimed that it wouldn't happen at all, because Putin was too rational to invade. Sure he was.


I haven't read anyone posit that. Some complained about NATO / West repeatedly breaking agreements.

Oh, "Putin won't invade" was a major claim on this board in the days leading up to the war. Now memory-holed, of course, because it doesn't fit the new narrative.

The reason I think Putin wants Ukraine as part of Russia again is because he basically says so.
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
To put the popularity of this thread in proper perspective:

The Official Russian Invasion of Ukraine Thread
1,556,523 Views

Shocky's thread:

cal's monster offensive line
3,188,865 View
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
I got some friends inside

“I love Cal deeply, by the way, what are the directions to The Portal from Sproul Plaza?”
movielover
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Deep analysis.



oski003
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Who assassinated former speaker of the Ukrainian parliament Andriy Parubiy, the man who coordinated Maidan's self-defense, and why?
First Page Last Page
Page 353 of 410 ▼
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.