RFK jr considering Aaron Rogers as running mate

15,342 Views | 248 Replies | Last: 1 yr ago by Strykur
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bearister said:

bear2034 said:


By bringing in Putin and Trump into this, don't you know you automatically lost?
What did he lose? Your respect and admiration? Well, that right there is what they call a crying shame. He may need counseling.

The same kind of counseling I provide you in OT or the women's basketball forum?
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:


Assuming it is true,
wc22
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I want to focus on the anti-Rogers folks thinking that Trump is anti-vaccines. There is no way a major political candidate who says, arrogantly, "I made the COVID vaccines happen and they are great, the greatest great thing ever!, and I did this, I saved you ALL!", is associated with anti-"Science"? Right? Trump has been dead consistent in his support for the COVID vaccines.

And yet...

There is a very easy contradiction here. People who read the NY Times somehow think one of the loudest voices for the vaccines is anti-vaccine. How does this happen?
wc22
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No, seriously, how is Trump associated with being anti-vaccine when he has only said positive things about the COVID vaccines for three straight years and taken credit for them? That is really weird. How does that happen? How do so many "well informed" people think the Trump has his exact opposite of the views?
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wc22 said:

This is a perfect example of why the public has such low trust in the media.
"Journalist here, 10 years ago Aaron told me something crazy in a private conversation. Thought I would write a story about today of all days."

Where else are they going to receive their indoctrination?
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wc22 said:

No, seriously, how is Trump associated with being anti-vaccine when he has only said positive things about the COVID vaccines for three straight years and taken credit for them? That is really weird. How does that happen? How do so many "well informed" people think the Trump has his exact opposite of the views?


More red herrings. Trump was anti-mask, anti-quarantine (refusing to have a federal policy and even encouraging armed opposition against state policies) and helped fan the flames of the virus that killed 1.2 million Americans, far more deaths than any other country and more than all the Americans killed in every war combined. He did push for fast tracking of the vaccines (Operation Warp Speed) which I give him credit for.

However, the vaccines did not come out until Biden was president so Trump's base turned against the vaccines, invented conspiracies around them and blamed and still blame Biden and Faucci for their imagined issues with the vaccines that actually ended the pandemic. After mentioning vaccines and getting booed by his base, Trump now distanced himself from the vaccines in order to keep throwing red meat to his base. The question to ask is why do so many of Trump's supporters who think the vaccines were horrible not hold him accountable for their imagined horrors?
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

bear2034 said:

calumnus said:

bear2034 said:

sycasey said:

okaydo said:



This seems bad.

When okaydo posts Jake Tapper tweets about private conversations, maybe not.
So at least you agree that it would be really vile to believe and spread Sandy Hook conspiracy theories, right?

Russia, Russia, Putin, Trump, Putin, Russia?


Trump just hosted his and Putin's buddy and fellow dictator at Mar a Lago this week:
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/rcna142774
Orban himself said Trump told him he would cut off all funding to Ukraine.

Orban is not a "dictator", he has decisively won every election in his country since 2010 and has arguably been the most popular leader in Europe.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Hungarian_parliamentary_election

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Hungarian_parliamentary_election
wc22
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

wc22 said:

No, seriously, how is Trump associated with being anti-vaccine when he has only said positive things about the COVID vaccines for three straight years and taken credit for them? That is really weird. How does that happen? How do so many "well informed" people think the Trump has his exact opposite of the views?


More red herrings. Trump was anti-mask, anti-quarantine (refusing to have a federal policy and even encouraging armed opposition against state policies) and helped fan the flames of the virus that killed 1.2 million Americans, far more deaths than any other country and more than all the Americans killed in every war combined. He did push for fast tracking of the vaccines (Operation Warp Speed) which I give him credit for.

However, the vaccines did not come out until Biden was president so Trump's base turned against the vaccines, invented conspiracies around them and blamed and still blame Biden and Faucci for their imagined issues with the vaccines that actually ended the pandemic. After mentioning vaccines and getting booed by his base, Trump now distanced himself from the vaccines in order to keep throwing red meat to his base. The question to ask is why do so many of Trump's supporters who think the vaccines were horrible not hold him accountable for their imagined horrors?
No, you really are living in a false reality: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=trump+on+covid+vaccines
okaydo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
blungld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wc22 said:

blungld said:

wc22 said:

Tainted his reputation with whom?
With sensible people.
I like this shift. "Sensible people" replacing "Moral people" is a good start. You are neither.
I see. And you know this how?
westcoastdude
How long do you want to ignore this user?
A very good Twitter (X) thread from one of the Sandy Hook lawyers on the crazy stuff Qarron spews.

philly1121
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Before you go full tin foil red hat brigade, we should remember Operation Warp Speed. Yes, Trump was president when that happened. He should get credit for it. The vaccine didn't actually come out until December 2020. The Pfizer and Moderna vaccines anyway. But since then, Trump has rarely spoken about it. When he used to mention the vaccine at his rally's - the crowd would boo.

I recall he was asked about this on Fox News Bret Baer's show as to why he doesn't tout it more. He said he doesn't because its not popular. Its not popular with his base. He was booed on stage when he revealed he got a covid booster shot. Since Biden's election, Republicans have been decidedly anti-vax - simply because Dems support vaccinations.

So, yes, one can say that Trump is pro-vax. But he doesn't even mention the one thing (in my opinion) his administration did right with Op Warp Speed. But his supporters are overwhelmingly anti-vax; they're anti-public health and their paranoia has spawned multiple conspiracy theories about the vaccine that have zero merit. So who do you blame for that? Trump or his supporters?
okaydo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rodgers told reporters he was "immunized."




Anarchistbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The last thing the American people care about in 2024 is Covid or vaccines. Trump and Biden are the two most unpopular candidates in US history. Running against them with vaccines as a major issue buys you nothing but the usual cranks. Let's hope Cornel West is smarter
blungld
How long do you want to ignore this user?
westcoastdude said:

A very good Twitter (X) thread from one of the Sandy Hook lawyers on the crazy stuff Qarron spews.


Living 15 minutes from Sandy Hook when it happened and knowing the parents and kids there, including some who lost their child, any of the pro-gun or crisis actor Sandy Hook conspiracy is horrifying and disgusting and insight to a media stream that has lost touch with reality and attaches itself malignantly to the cancer of the American system.

I can only assume that we as a nation have become so callous to violence and know deep down that we are all responsible through our lack of gun legislation and our tossing to the side of community and mental health care, that the shame and guilt bubbles up in denialism that takes the form as conspiracy theory to look the other way from our dark truth.
wc22
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The people who thought Immunized meant vaccinated were dumb. It was obviously a code word for some woo woo stuff.

I think most people who claim "Aaron is a liar! He lied about being vaccinated!" know he didn't. It is performative.
wc22
How long do you want to ignore this user?
philly1121 said:

Before you go full tin foil red hat brigade, we should remember Operation Warp Speed. Yes, Trump was president when that happened. He should get credit for it. The vaccine didn't actually come out until December 2020. The Pfizer and Moderna vaccines anyway. But since then, Trump has rarely spoken about it. When he used to mention the vaccine at his rally's - the crowd would boo.

I recall he was asked about this on Fox News Bret Baer's show as to why he doesn't tout it more. He said he doesn't because its not popular. Its not popular with his base. He was booed on stage when he revealed he got a covid booster shot. Since Biden's election, Republicans have been decidedly anti-vax - simply because Dems support vaccinations.

So, yes, one can say that Trump is pro-vax. But he doesn't even mention the one thing (in my opinion) his administration did right with Op Warp Speed. But his supporters are overwhelmingly anti-vax; they're anti-public health and their paranoia has spawned multiple conspiracy theories about the vaccine that have zero merit. So who do you blame for that? Trump or his supporters?
Kinda missing the point. Trump is pro-vax. Part of his base is not. And RFK Jr. appeals to that part of his base. We don't know if RFK Jr. is going to take more votes from Biden or Trump. Also, there are plenty of Democrats that are anti-COVID Mandates and even outright anti-Vax. You simplify things in such a way that I don't think you even care about the issues as much as hating on "typical Republican voters", or some other inaccurate category of people you have in your head.
Unit2Sucks
How long do you want to ignore this user?
People who believe in some conspiracy theories tend to believe in others. It's been pretty well studied and the results won't surprise anyone. Needless to say, we should expect this behavior to continue. As I mentioned in the positivity thread yesterday, at least AR hasn't gone full Kanye ... yet. But no one should be surprised when he starts getting to really outlandish stuff (holocaust denialism, etc.). These things don't tend to self-moderate. I think the best we can hope for is that he just shuts up and starts to keep his opinions to himself.

Here's a few articles if anyone is interested (1, 2)

Quote:

Even though many conspiracy theories seem to provide clarity or a supposed secret truth about confusing events, a need for closure or a sense of control were not the strongest motivators to endorse conspiracy theories. Instead, the researchers found some evidence that people were more likely to believe specific conspiracy theories when they were motivated by social relationships. For instance, participants who perceived social threats were more likely to believe in events-based conspiracy theories, such as the theory that the U.S. government planned the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, rather than an abstract theory that, in general, governments plan to harm their citizens to retain power.

"These results largely map onto a recent theoretical framework advancing that social identity motives may give rise to being drawn to the content of a conspiracy theory, whereas people who are motivated by a desire to feel unique are more likely to believe in general conspiracy theories about how the world works," according to Bowes.

The researchers also found that people with certain personality traits, such as a sense of antagonism toward others and high levels of paranoia, were more prone to believe conspiracy theories. Those who strongly believed in conspiracy theories were also more likely to be insecure, paranoid, emotionally volatile, impulsive, suspicious, withdrawn, manipulative, egocentric and eccentric.

Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
okaydo said:

Rodgers told reporters he was "immunized."




If he already has had covid, he would have indeed been immunized. The immunization from prior infection is more complete, effective and longer-lasting than that from the mRNA vaccine.

In any case, for his age group and fitness level, the mRNA vaccine does not present a very favorable risk-benefit profile. In that sense, his decision was rational and well-informed.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Anarchistbear said:

The last thing the American people care about in 2024 is Covid or vaccines. Trump and Biden are the two most unpopular candidates in US history. Running against them with vaccines as a major issue buys you nothing but the usual cranks. Let's hope Cornel West is smarter

Covid, vaccines, public health, and government overreach are still hot topics on people's minds. The Covid thread in the OT forum is still going strong. As far as candidate popularity goes, Biden received the most "votes" in history, 11 million more than his former boss, Obama. And Trump is so popular that 51 former intel agents went out of their way to lie and claim that Hunter Biden's laptop bore all the hallmarks of Russian disinformation.
philly1121
How long do you want to ignore this user?
No, it is exactly the point. You can't separate Trump from his followers. And we're not talking about mandates, we are talking about the vaccine. And on that issue, Politico did a poll in September 2023 with nearly 2,000 respondents who were registered voters. Dems overwhelmingly responded that the covid vaccine was safe (91%). Yet Repubs were split. 48% responded that they were not safe. So, yes, there is a very distinct disparity in Republicans as to whether they thought the vaccine was safe.

In 2021 studies showed that Republicans constituted 60% of unvaccinated population and that political leanings were strong indicators as to whether one would get the vaccine. I believe Brookings did another study that showed party affiliation as one main factor when it came to vaccination status. Especially for individuals under 50 years old.

I don't need to simplify things. They are right in front of us. We are talking about who is pro vax and who isn't. And on that metric, Republicans are decidedly anti-vax. Even if Trump is pro vax. Mandates is another issue for which there is broader support against mandates. Nevertheless, we aren't talking about that.
Unit2Sucks
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wc22 said:

The people who thought Immunized meant vaccinated were dumb. It was obviously a code word for some woo woo stuff.

I think most people who claim "Aaron is a liar! He lied about being vaccinated!" know he didn't. It is performative.
Everyone knowing he was lying doesn't mean he wasn't lying. It became clear after he came down with COVID in 2021 that it was his first infection and that his "immunization" was like a visit to a homeopathic doctor or something. You still see disingenuous people defending him by inventing facts like that his "immunization" was from prior infection when that is known not to be the case.

It's okay to call a lie a lie.

Quote:

In November 2021, Rodgers tested positive for COVID. It became obvious at that point, based on the protocols that applied to him after testing positive, that he had not been vaccinated. That prompted many to revisit his comments from earlier in the year, when he was asked by reporters if he's been vaccinated.
"Yeah, I've been immunized," Rodgers said.

He later admitted that he deliberately misled reporters, waiting for one of them to ask whether "yeah, I've been immunized" means "yes, I've been vaccinated" or something else. When they didn't, he never bothered to say he hadn't been vaccinated.

Fast forward to Tuesday, when McAfee made in clear jest a reference to the argument that Rodgers lied when he said he was "immunized." McAfee was having some fun. Rodgers couldn't let it go.
"Do they still not understand why I said 'immunized'"? Rodgers said. "Do they know that I was in an appeal process? Not to mention, like, I don't know what you would call it if you go to a homeopathic doctor and you get taken to an immunization process, what do you say you are?"

Again, that's not the point. He was asked if he was vaccinated. He said, "Yeah, I've been immunized." He didn't say, "No, I've been immunized."

bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
westcoastdude said:

A very good Twitter (X) thread from one of the Sandy Hook lawyers on the crazy stuff Qarron spews.

The same people who read QAnon are the same people who hate Aaron Rodgers. They also subscribe to Blue Anon. It's funny how that works.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
okaydo said:

Rodgers told reporters he was "immunized."
And the vaccine nazis lost their minds.
Unit2Sucks
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wc22 said:

No, seriously, how is Trump associated with being anti-vaccine when he has only said positive things about the COVID vaccines for three straight years and taken credit for them? That is really weird. How does that happen? How do so many "well informed" people think the Trump has his exact opposite of the views?
I think you're confused. Trump is pro-Trump and often that means holding wildly inconsistent beliefs.

Because he thinks he deserves credit for the COVID vaccines, he is pro COVID vaccines (specifically operation warp speed). But he is still an "old school" anti-vaxxer who thinks vaccines cause autism. He's said it publicly numerous times and has never come back to say that he was wrong. I can confidently say that because he has never said he was wrong about anything, regardless of how counter-factual it is.

Quote:

2007:
"When I was growing up, autism wasn't really a factor," he told the South Florida Sun-Sentinel in a 2007 interview. "And now all of a sudden, it's an epidemic. Everybody has their theory. My theory, and I study it because I have young children, my theory is the shots. We're giving these massive injections at one time, and I really think it does something to the children."

At a press briefing about the fund-raiser, Mr. Trump talked about vaccinating his son, Barron, then almost 2: "What we've done with Barron, we've taken him on a very slow process. He gets one shot at a time then we wait a few months and give him another shot, the old-fashioned way."

2009:
"I think the vaccines can be very dangerous. And, obviously, you know, a lot of people are talking about vaccines with children with respect to autism."

Later in the interview Mr. Trump said that if his children got sick, he would keep them at home from school:
"But I don't think I would inject them with all sorts of vaccines that, really, nobody even right now knows if it works with respect to what they're what they're looking at right now, Neil."

2012:
On Autism Awareness Day in April, Mr. Trump called in to Fox and Friends. The hosts noted that most physicians disagreed with his theory that vaccines cause autism.

"Well, it's also very controversial to even say, but I couldn't care less. I mean, I've seen people, where they have a perfectly healthy child, and they go for the vaccinations, and a month later the child is no longer healthy."

He continued: "It happened to somebody that worked for me recently. I mean, they had this beautiful child, not a problem in the world, and all of a sudden, they go in, they get this monster shot you ever see the size of it? It's like they're pumping in, you know it's terrible, the amount, and they pump this into this little body, and then all of a sudden the child is different a month later. And I strongly believe that's it."

That same year, Mr. Trump was tweeting those views.

2015:
During a CNN debate among Republican presidential candidates that September, Mr. Trump said he supported vaccinations generally, but again disputed the early childhood schedule and cited a child of someone who worked for him:
"If you take this little beautiful baby, and you pump … I mean, it looks just like it's meant for a horse, not for a child, and we've had so many instances, people that work for me, just the other day, 2 years old, 2 years old, a child, a beautiful child, went to have the vaccine and came back, and a week later got a tremendous fever, got very, very sick, now is autistic."

A month later, Mr. Trump called in to the "Opie With Jim Norton" radio show. He was asked if he got the flu shot every year. Mr. Trump replied:

"I've never had one and that's why I've never had the flu. I don't like the idea of injecting bad stuff into your body, which is basically what they do."

This sound like a pro-vaccine guy to you?

And when is this thread going to be moved to the women's basketball board?
Anarchistbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2034 said:

Anarchistbear said:

The last thing the American people care about in 2024 is Covid or vaccines. Trump and Biden are the two most unpopular candidates in US history. Running against them with vaccines as a major issue buys you nothing but the usual cranks. Let's hope Cornel West is smarter

Covid, vaccines, public health, and government overreach are still hot topics on people's minds. The Covid thread in the OT forum is still going strong. As far as candidate popularity goes, Biden received the most "votes" in history, 11 million more than his former boss, Obama. And Trump is so popular that 51 former intel agents went out of their way to lie and claim that Hunter Biden's laptop bore all the hallmarks of Russian disinformation.


Covid threat going strong in OT. Of course it is being whack job central.

Biden and Trump both have favorability ratings in the low 40's. Most people are indifferent to them because they don't have anything to do with their lives. OT is another exception where they actually think who wins is life or death
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Anarchistbear said:

bear2034 said:

Anarchistbear said:

The last thing the American people care about in 2024 is Covid or vaccines. Trump and Biden are the two most unpopular candidates in US history. Running against them with vaccines as a major issue buys you nothing but the usual cranks. Let's hope Cornel West is smarter

Covid, vaccines, public health, and government overreach are still hot topics on people's minds. The Covid thread in the OT forum is still going strong. As far as candidate popularity goes, Biden received the most "votes" in history, 11 million more than his former boss, Obama. And Trump is so popular that 51 former intel agents went out of their way to lie and claim that Hunter Biden's laptop bore all the hallmarks of Russian disinformation.


Covid threat going strong in OT. Of course it is being whack job central.

Biden and Trump both have favorability ratings in the low 40's. Most people are indifferent to them because they don't have anything to do with their lives. OT is another exception

If OT is whack job central, what is Growls?

Even anarchists were forced to get vaccinated weren't they?
Anarchistbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2034 said:

Anarchistbear said:

bear2034 said:

Anarchistbear said:

The last thing the American people care about in 2024 is Covid or vaccines. Trump and Biden are the two most unpopular candidates in US history. Running against them with vaccines as a major issue buys you nothing but the usual cranks. Let's hope Cornel West is smarter

Covid, vaccines, public health, and government overreach are still hot topics on people's minds. The Covid thread in the OT forum is still going strong. As far as candidate popularity goes, Biden received the most "votes" in history, 11 million more than his former boss, Obama. And Trump is so popular that 51 former intel agents went out of their way to lie and claim that Hunter Biden's laptop bore all the hallmarks of Russian disinformation.


Covid threat going strong in OT. Of course it is being whack job central.

Biden and Trump both have favorability ratings in the low 40's. Most people are indifferent to them because they don't have anything to do with their lives. OT is another exception

If OT is whack job central, what is Growls?

Even anarchists were forced to get vaccinated weren't they?


Growls is the bar that closes on Saturday night
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wc22 said:

The people who thought Immunized meant vaccinated were dumb. It was obviously a code word for some woo woo stuff.
If someone asks you "Have you been vaccinated?" and you respond with "Yeah, I've been immunized," how do you think they're going to take it?
kal kommie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If Rodgers believes the things he reportedly said on the Eddie Bravo podcast then he's got a really warped world view and I wouldn't be surprised if he subscribed to some Sandy Hook conspiracy theory. I noted the wording Rodgers used in his disclaimer tweet can be construed in a way that is technically truthful if Rodgers believes, as he is reported to have said, that Sandy Hook was a government orchestrated massacre rather than a fabrication with crisis actors as others suggest.

But I find this reporting by CNN's Pamela Brown interesting for reasons other than Rodgers' personal character. Brown claims she was on the job for CNN at the Kentucky Derby in 2013 and Aaron Rodgers, one of the most famous athletes in America, told her Sandy Hook was a government inside job and she chose not to report this very newsworthy item at the intersection of sports and politics?

It only occurs to Brown to report this outrageous statement Rodgers made to her a decade later when Rodgers becomes associated with a third party political candidacy. And the only corroboration Tapper and Brown can offer is another hearsay episode from that most plastic of sources, one they keep anonymous because the supposed source wishes to condemn Rodgers while shielding themselves from any kind of accountability for their allegation.

I'm not saying Rodgers didn't make the statements to Pamela Brown in 2013 that she reported. At this point it's believable that he would hold such an extreme view just based on other extreme views he has expressed. But I think this reporting is bad journalism of an unfortunately common variety.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Anarchistbear said:

bear2034 said:

Anarchistbear said:

bear2034 said:

Anarchistbear said:

The last thing the American people care about in 2024 is Covid or vaccines. Trump and Biden are the two most unpopular candidates in US history. Running against them with vaccines as a major issue buys you nothing but the usual cranks. Let's hope Cornel West is smarter

Covid, vaccines, public health, and government overreach are still hot topics on people's minds. The Covid thread in the OT forum is still going strong. As far as candidate popularity goes, Biden received the most "votes" in history, 11 million more than his former boss, Obama. And Trump is so popular that 51 former intel agents went out of their way to lie and claim that Hunter Biden's laptop bore all the hallmarks of Russian disinformation.


Covid threat going strong in OT. Of course it is being whack job central.

Biden and Trump both have favorability ratings in the low 40's. Most people are indifferent to them because they don't have anything to do with their lives. OT is another exception

If OT is whack job central, what is Growls?

Even anarchists were forced to get vaccinated weren't they?


Growls is the bar that closes on Saturday night

Kind of a low bar, but I vote for the above as the best-line-of-the-thread so far.
bluehenbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
https://www.theonion.com/backpedaling-aaron-rodgers-meets-with-sandy-hook-parent-1851336032
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:

wc22 said:

The people who thought Immunized meant vaccinated were dumb. It was obviously a code word for some woo woo stuff.
If someone asks you "Have you been vaccinated?" and you respond with "Yeah, I've been immunized," how do you think they're going to take it?


If he didn't lead with "yeah" in answering the question it would be disingenuous, but it wouldn't be outright lying.
Vandalus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
kal kommie said:

If Rodgers believes the things he reportedly said on the Eddie Bravo podcast then he's got a really warped world view and I wouldn't be surprised if he subscribed to some Sandy Hook conspiracy theory. I noted the wording Rodgers used in his disclaimer tweet can be construed in a way that is technically truthful if Rodgers believes, as he is reported to have said, that Sandy Hook was a government orchestrated massacre rather than a fabrication with crisis actors as others suggest.

But I find this reporting by CNN's Pamela Brown interesting for reasons other than Rodgers' personal character. Brown claims she was on the job for CNN at the Kentucky Derby in 2013 and Aaron Rodgers, one of the most famous athletes in America, told her Sandy Hook was a government inside job and she chose not to report this very newsworthy item at the intersection of sports and politics?

It only occurs to Brown to report this outrageous statement Rodgers made to her a decade later when Rodgers becomes associated with a third party political candidacy. And the only corroboration Tapper and Brown can offer is another hearsay episode from that most plastic of sources, one they keep anonymous because the supposed source wishes to condemn Rodgers while shielding themselves from any kind of accountability for their allegation.

I'm not saying Rodgers didn't make the statements to Pamela Brown in 2013 that she reported. At this point it's believable that he would hold such an extreme view just based on other extreme views he has expressed. But I think this reporting is bad journalism of an unfortunately common variety.


Put another way; though I have always been a huge Arod football fan, his views on other subjects concerning "conspiracy theories," in addition to his prior comments and subterfuge re being "immunized" make his current reported beliefs on Sandy Hook to be much more plausible, vis a vis my belief that a reporter would have this conversation but then never write an article about it until his newfound potential foray into politics.

Maybe if ARod took an oath under penalty of perjury, and he was asked direct probing questions under direct and cross examination, and if perhaps maybe Ms. Brown and the unnamed corroborating source were also called into to testify, and if perhaps Ms. Brown recalls that she told some other family, personal or professional acquaintance of this conversation contemporaneously, or if more people came out to say - yes, I have heard ARod make comments such as these, then maybe we can make a more informed decision.

You say it's bad journalism. I am not sure what makes is bad. That you think it was newsworthy for her to have reported it then, and that because she did not until now (when its more newsworthy) makes it bad journalism is crying for a revisionist history of the facts. The fact is, she did not report it until now, along with an anonymous source. We have her statement - with a lot of detail and quotes - and a corroborating account from a different time period that is similar; and we have Aaron saying, I have never had those beliefs or said those things. We can agree to disagree, but on the whole, and judging by a "more likely than not" standard, I am in the camp that I believe that he said those things to Ms. Brown. She has no reason to lie. Why would she randomly create a story from an interaction however many years ago? She knows coming forward with this will subject her to critique; what is her motivation to lie about the alleged conversation? And what is Aaron's motivation to lie, obfuscate or deny that he has said and espoused those views?

Seems pretty easy for me to decide if I were sitting in a jurors box, and we haven't even had either of them raise their right hand yet.

-- edit -- side note, and this is admittedly a pet peeve of mine: the anonymous quotes, or those from Brown, are not hearsay. If we ever get into a court or tribunal where the rules of evidence apply, then we can start talking about hearsay and whether any of the statements have an applicable exception to allow them to be admissible or not. Right now they are statements that are attributed to one person, and we can assess them for what they are without relying upon a legal and evidentiary principle that most non-lawyers have almost zero concept of, why we call these statements hearsay, nor why there are so many exceptions to them.
~Spectemur agendo~
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2034 said:

okaydo said:

Rodgers told reporters he was "immunized."
And the vaccine nazis lost their minds.


Your use of that term is vile, but you probably know that. God have mercy on your soul.

1.2 million Americans died from the virus. More than in any other country, more than all the American deaths from all the wars in history combined. The vaccines ended the pandemic.

John Kelly has recently recounted how much your hero Trump admires Hitler. Yes, Trump pushed for the vaccines, but that is not why he and so many of his followers are Nazis.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.