tequila4kapp said:
….There are some potential juicy ironies coming (for those on the right) whereby BCC - without their security clearances - will be the negative recipients of a tool they used against others: they won't get access to classified documents to aid their defense.
"When a criminal defendant needs classified documents for their defense, the Classified Information Procedures Act (CIPA) provides a framework for handling the situation. CIPA aims to balance the defendant's constitutional rights with the government's need to protect national security
by allowing for the use of classified information in a way that minimizes public disclosure. Here's how CIPA works in practice:
1. Notice Requirement:
The defendant must notify the prosecution and the court if they intend to disclose or cause the disclosure of classified information.
2. Discovery and Protective Orders:
CIPA allows courts to issue protective orders, limiting the disclosure of classified information to only those with proper security clearances.
3. Substitution and Summaries:
Instead of disclosing the classified information directly, the court may allow the use of summaries or substitutions (e.g., using "Country A" instead of the actual country name) that provide the defendant with the same ability to present their defense.
4. "Silent Witness" Rule:
In some cases, the court may allow classified information to be disclosed only to the judge, jury, counsel, and witnesses without making it public.
5. Admissibility at Trial:
If classified information is deemed admissible, it can be presented to the jury through various methods, such as the "silent witness" approach, where the witness refers to specific parts of the document without revealing it to the public, or by using summaries or substitutions.
6. Balancing Rights:
The court must ensure that any restrictions on the use of classified information do not violate the defendant's constitutional rights, such as the right to a public trial, to confront witnesses, and to the assistance of counsel.
Important Considerations:
Relevance and Admissibility:
The court must determine if the classified information is relevant and admissible as evidence.
Exculpatory Information:
The prosecution must disclose any exculpatory information (information that could prove the defendant's innocence) to the defense, even if it is classified.
National Security Concerns:
The court must balance the defendant's rights with the government's responsibility to protect national security.
CIPA is not a complete bar to using classified information in a criminal trial.
It provides a framework for managing the situation while ensuring the defendant receives a fair trial."
AI Overview
Key question that arises from this discussion:
Do you think the people that were ordered/hired to murder Epstein were murdered themselves as part of the cover up? Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention
“I love Cal deeply. What are the directions to The Portal from Sproul Plaza?”
