tequila4kapp said:The first guy led demonstrations that denied Jews access to education, distributed pro-Hamas materials, Jews were threatened at protests. That's not exactly plotting the next 9/11, but fine. Affirmative actions were taken that denied other's rights and advocated for a terrorist hroip. Fine / good, get rid of him.MinotStateBeav said:I understand the question, but I'm not falling to appeals of emotion. The law is pretty clear here. If Democrats had a way to deport conservatives they would 100% do it. but they don't.sycasey said:I don't think you understood the question.MinotStateBeav said:American born citizens are not the same as GUESTS to the USA. They literally can not do that.Cal88 said:MinotStateBeav said:Yes, speech is the link. Why do you think green card and visa holders can say anything they want? They cannot. If they would have told the government they were pro-hamas before entering they would have been denied entry. Green card holders are not naturalized citizens. Their entrance into the United States comes with responsibility. We do not want to be importing people into the USA that cause social disruption, that would be catastrophic.sycasey said:This fits with the same pattern as the Columbia student who got arrested. The government still has not presented any evidence of actual material support for terrorism from him either . . . again, it's all just speech. This all sets a very, very bad precedent.tequila4kapp said:
A UW fellow and Georgetown PHD candidate have been detained for deportation. Based on what I'm seeing so far they have 'supported' Hezbellah (with words) and associated with Hamas (the PHD candidates' father in law was an advisor to a Hamas leader). Unless there are additional facts indicating something more than thoughts/words/family members...this is a step too far, wrong and un-American.
Would you feel the same if the shoe was on the other foot, and permanent residents were getting deported by a Democrat administration for protesting against say, covid mandates, or other activities deemed "socially disruptive" by the administration in office?
Not fine/good. There's no evidence thus far that he "led" the protests, only that he served as a negotiator for the student group. The government has openly admitted that they are not charging him with a crime. It would be unprecedented to deport a green card holder for this.