mikecohen;842120629 said:
In relationships, the main honesty thing is to be honest with yourself. As to the other(s) in the relationship: Although it sounds un-ideal, the most honest thing is to live up to the burden of judging what the other(s) is/are capable of receiving in a way that furthers the communication. If the judgment is that expressing what you believe to be the truth will meet with resistance to the truth, the best alternative is to find a way to communicate it that will get past the resistance. Failing the insight to find that, the alternative is to wait until you have that insight. One has to accept the arrogance that comes with the necessity of such judgment; and one has to live with the fact that, in making such judgment (as with everything else), everybody is far from perfect. So, what if one judges that the other(s) can receive the information in a constructive way, but one turns out to be wrong? The better judgments are lessons from such failures. But what's the remedy for mistakenly withholding the truth? The only answer I can think of is that, all things being equal, withholding the truth is not something one can live with for very long; and the more one has to do it, the weaker the relationship(s).
You put a lot of thought into this. I have an ex-girlfriend who I am sure would like to meet you. We used to talk about this stuff for hours. I got exhausted. The flame went out. For me anyway.
Charles McCabe wrote another column once, describing the research work done by some psychologists on couples with successful relationships. They chose the research subjects by interviewing people and asking them which of their married friends seemed to have the happiest successful relationships. They then selected several of those couples for their research.
The psychologists then placed hidden microphones in places where the couple would spend time together, like their home (kitchen, bedroom, living room) and their car. They recorded their conversations, to try and study what happy, successful couples talked about, and what their conversation was like. The single thing they found that all the couples had in common was that they seldom talked to each other, and when they did, they said very little. In the car, for example, they all said little, except to discuss the directions to whatever place they were driving to.
I am fascinated when I see young couples out to dinner or elsewhere in public, and they are not talking with each other. They are both on their i-phone, or their i-pad, or similar device, each communicating with someone else. Do they ever talk to each other?