Story Poster
Photo by X / Cal Football
Cal Football

The Football Roster Post Spring - The Quarterbacks (FREE)

May 21, 2025
6,374

It’s often called the single most important position in all of sports - Quarterback.   Even without any hyperbole, it’s certainly the single most important variable outside of the head coach in predicting the success of a college football team.   QBs set the tone in the locker room, they can lift or deflate an entire teams belief in itself and they can both overcome deficiencies on offense to raise a team up as well creating a fixed lower ceiling to an otherwise talented offensive unit.

Cal lost RS Sophomore Fernando Mendoza in what can only be described as a soap opera style parting of the ways.  Mendoza went from unheralded recruit to a very solid college quarterback in a few short years.   He was a gamer, who was tough and unafraid, gifted with a plus arm and good accuracy.  He was also limited by a lack of pocket mobility, a tendency to hold the ball too long and more than a few mental gaffes (the sliding on a sure TD vs Wake Forest may still go down as the single most “interesting” decision of the 2025 season).

To replace him comes one of the nation’s top recruits in the 2022 class, a player who battled for the starting role at Ohio State the past two seasons only to find himself as the backup to two very productive players.   Joining him is Jaron Keawe Sagapolutele‍, one of the most heralded QB recruits in this most recent, 2025 class.   Returning to the Bears is EJ Caminong‍, fresh off a RS Freshman bowl game disaster.  The final piece is JC transfer Dominic Ingrassia‍, a 2024 recruit who won a JC State Championship at the College of San Mateo last Fall.   

All four played this Spring, giving the staff and fans a head start on evaluating this room.

Departures: 

Fernando Mendoza

Chandler Rogers

CJ Harris

Returners

EJ Caminong:  6’2, 210, RS Sophomore (6 of 19 for 57 yards in 2025)

Newcomers via Transfer

Devin Brown:  6’3, 215, RS Junior (27 of 48 for 331 yards, 3 TDs and no interceptions at Ohio State over two seasons)

Dominic Ingrassia:  6’4, 200, Sophomore (CSM JC 3 Star Recruit)

Newcomers via High School*

Jaron Keawe Sagapolutele:  6’2, 210 (5 star by On3, Elite 11 Finalist)

*JKS was technically a portal transfer from Oregon after committing their in the December signing period

Projected Depth Chart entering Fall Camp

Brown

JKS

Caminong 

Ingrassia

Observations

This Spring showed that this battle will be more interesting than may have been obvious given Brown’s pedigree both as a recruit and as key backup for the National Champion Ohio State Buckeyes.   Brown has good size, a plus arm, is a very capable runner and displayed the leadership and football acumen of a potential high level starter.   However, he struggled at times in 11v11 this Spring with his consistency and accuracy and he will need to take a meaningful step forward early in Fall Camp to make himself the outright QB1.

JKS was as advertised in terms of his arm talent.  His mechanics are messy, he had a steep learning curve adjusting to the pre and post snap reads needed in Bryan Harsin’s offense and his decision making at times was very much in line with a player that should have been attending HS classes in Hawaii.   Yet, he can make throws both on and off platform that were startling in their velocity and accuracy.  He made more big plays than the other QBs in the room combined and he has a natural charisma and low key style that resonated with his teammates.  He  got better as the Spring progressed but there’s a lot of work to do before he has a true command of this offense.

Ej Caminong looked like a completely different player from the overwhelmed Freshman playing in the LA Bowl.   He’s taken to Harsin’s offense like a duck to water, making quick and correct reads, getting the ball out on time and showing off decent athleticism when its his turn to tuck it and run.   His raw arm talent is clearly below that of JKS and Brown and he’s not a dynamic athlete so the question will be around his ceiling but if Spring was a real indicator of progress, he’s got a very solid floor and appears to be immediately capable of coming off the bench and having success.

Ingrassia got very few snaps in live drills given the three players ahead of him.  You can see his natural accuracy and good poise and his arm is good enough.   Hope to see more of him in Fall Camp.

Harsin really likes JKS and if he continues to progress and Brown doesn’t find enough consistency, don’t be surprised to see Cal play both early in the season.  

Others in this series:

The Tight Ends

The Offensive Line

The Wide Receivers

The Running Backs

Discussion from...

The Football Roster Post Spring - The Quarterbacks (FREE)

4,024 Views | 19 Replies | Last: 2 days ago by bluehenbear
BearoutEast67
How long do you want to ignore this user?
This is a notably step-up at QB. Just need our OL to be solid.
Donate to Cal's NIL at https://calegends.com/donation/
AXLBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What about rb room?
BearGreg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Staff
AXLBear said:

What about rb room?
There's a link above - though it's premium

Bearly Clad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Not super excited about the possibility of another QB competition heading into the season and for the first several games while we figure **** out. The overall QB talent is higher but the carousel has cost us in the last few years. Hopefully one guy pulls away in fall, wins the job outright, and never looks back. If JKS keeps improving and gets at least a solid grasp on the mental side I think it'll be his to lose but Brown has that veteran presence that is very valuable and that our coaching staff especially loves.

I just hope that someone makes it a no-brainer and can't be denied
Shocky1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
terrific FREE summary of the qb1 battle!!
GivemTheAxe
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BearoutEast67 said:

This is a notably step-up at QB. Just need our OL to be solid.


Same old story: "we just need our OL to be solid"
"So you're saying we have a chance"
6956bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bearly Clad said:

Not super excited about the possibility of another QB competition heading into the season and for the first several games while we figure **** out. The overall QB talent is higher but the carousel has cost us in the last few years. Hopefully one guy pulls away in fall, wins the job outright, and never looks back. If JKS keeps improving and gets at least a solid grasp on the mental side I think it'll be his to lose but Brown has that veteran presence that is very valuable and that our coaching staff especially loves.

I just hope that someone makes it a no-brainer and can't be denied
It is difficult to prepare 1 Qb in a new system with as many new teammates as this team will feature. Much less get 2 ready. IMO they need to pick a QB early in camp and then use the balance of the camp to get that player the reps with the 1's. It will be interesting to see when the team closes practices to the public. They closed the last half of Spring. It would not surprise me if they close Fall camp after about 7 days.

JMO but I think they start Brown. But if JKS is close IMO they need to go all in on him early. No idea how Harsin views experience even as limited as Brown's over raw talent.
Rushinbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
6956bear said:

Bearly Clad said:

Not super excited about the possibility of another QB competition heading into the season and for the first several games while we figure **** out. The overall QB talent is higher but the carousel has cost us in the last few years. Hopefully one guy pulls away in fall, wins the job outright, and never looks back. If JKS keeps improving and gets at least a solid grasp on the mental side I think it'll be his to lose but Brown has that veteran presence that is very valuable and that our coaching staff especially loves.

I just hope that someone makes it a no-brainer and can't be denied
It is difficult to prepare 1 Qb in a new system with as many new teammates as this team will feature. Much less get 2 ready. IMO they need to pick a QB early in camp and then use the balance of the camp to get that player the reps with the 1's. It will be interesting to see when the team closes practices to the public. They closed the last half of Spring. It would not surprise me if they close Fall camp after about 7 days.

JMO but I think they start Brown. But if JKS is close IMO they need to go all in on him early. No idea how Harsin views experience even as limited as Brown's over raw talent.
making quick decisions correctly and with accuracy will tell the tale.
Grrrrah76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
still looks like a long season ahead.......losing a 1 1/2 year starting qb, the entire backfield, top tight end, and most of the starting receivers. Add a new starter at qb and offensive coaching staff. And really only fall camp to get all the new pieces to jell.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Grrrrah76 said:

still looks like a long season ahead.......losing a 1 1/2 year starting qb, the entire backfield, top tight end, and most of the starting receivers. Add a new starter at qb and offensive coaching staff. And really only fall camp to get all the new pieces to jell.

We lost a lot of guys on defense to graduation too.
All the new pieces is one reason OSU is slightly favored in our opener.
MinotStateBeav
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If they can make the ground and pound work, it would help the defense. Do I have a lot of confidence in that? not really.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MinotStateBeav said:

If they can make the ground and pound work, it would help the defense. Do I have a lot of confidence in that? not really.


Even the B1G schools have gone away from that style, I don't know why it would be a good strategy for Cal? It is a strategy that requires a decisive personnel advantage on the offensive line, both in size and strength. We may very well be improved on OL, but expecting our OL to be dominant seems very unrealistic.

Moreover, choosing an offense in order to help your defense seems like a good way to try to keep your losses close, but not a very good way to win. And it is definitely not a good way to generate excitement, fill Memorial Stadium and build a fan base.
MinotStateBeav
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

MinotStateBeav said:

If they can make the ground and pound work, it would help the defense. Do I have a lot of confidence in that? not really.


Even the B1G schools have gone away from that style, I don't know why it would be a good strategy for Cal? It is a strategy that requires a decisive personnel advantage on the offensive line, both in size and strength. We may very well be improved on OL, but expecting our OL to be dominant seems very unrealistic.

Moreover, choosing an offense in order to help your defense seems like a good way to try to keep your losses close, but not a very good way to win. And it is definitely not a good way to generate excitement, fill Memorial Stadium and build a fan base.
In football, you can always gain an advantage with being the team that does something different than everybody else. If you can show success doing it, it can lead to great recruiting etc. Think Mike Leach.
calumnus
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MinotStateBeav said:

calumnus said:

MinotStateBeav said:

If they can make the ground and pound work, it would help the defense. Do I have a lot of confidence in that? not really.


Even the B1G schools have gone away from that style, I don't know why it would be a good strategy for Cal? It is a strategy that requires a decisive personnel advantage on the offensive line, both in size and strength. We may very well be improved on OL, but expecting our OL to be dominant seems very unrealistic.

Moreover, choosing an offense in order to help your defense seems like a good way to try to keep your losses close, but not a very good way to win. And it is definitely not a good way to generate excitement, fill Memorial Stadium and build a fan base.
In football, you can always gain an advantage with being the team that does something different than everybody else. If you can show success doing it, it can lead to great recruiting etc. Think Mike Leach.

"Ground and pound" is the opposite of Mike Leach, the opposite of innovative. Moreover, I highly doubt we will be any better at it this year than we have been in the past.
HearstMining
How long do you want to ignore this user?
calumnus said:

MinotStateBeav said:

calumnus said:

MinotStateBeav said:

If they can make the ground and pound work, it would help the defense. Do I have a lot of confidence in that? not really.


Even the B1G schools have gone away from that style, I don't know why it would be a good strategy for Cal? It is a strategy that requires a decisive personnel advantage on the offensive line, both in size and strength. We may very well be improved on OL, but expecting our OL to be dominant seems very unrealistic.

Moreover, choosing an offense in order to help your defense seems like a good way to try to keep your losses close, but not a very good way to win. And it is definitely not a good way to generate excitement, fill Memorial Stadium and build a fan base.
In football, you can always gain an advantage with being the team that does something different than everybody else. If you can show success doing it, it can lead to great recruiting etc. Think Mike Leach.

"Ground and pound" is the opposite of Mike Leach, the opposite of innovative. Moreover, I highly doubt we will be any better at it this year than we have been in the past.
Sometimes being a contrarian is as effective as being innovative. Remember Harbaugh was successful at Stanford partially by NOT going to the spread offense when everybody else was. The spread gurus didn't use tight ends, so he attracted the top tight ends in the country, OL who were good run blockers, and power runners ala Toby Gerhardt. I think Harbaugh is a sanctimonious d!ck, but in that case, it certainly worked.
KoreAmBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bearly Clad said:

Not super excited about the possibility of another QB competition heading into the season and for the first several games while we figure **** out. The overall QB talent is higher but the carousel has cost us in the last few years. Hopefully one guy pulls away in fall, wins the job outright, and never looks back. If JKS keeps improving and gets at least a solid grasp on the mental side I think it'll be his to lose but Brown has that veteran presence that is very valuable and that our coaching staff especially loves.

I just hope that someone makes it a no-brainer and can't be denied
I would be super bummed about another in-season QB comp with JW overseeing it, but for some reason, I tend to think JW will let Harsin and Rolo figure this one out. I mean this is his last chance to really change the trajectory of his thoroughly mediocre tenure. If not, if there continues to be more start and stops and uncertainty, we are in for more Jackson/Ben Finley/Fernando, Bowers/Garbers/McIlvaine, and basically another 5-7 to 7-5 season.
Bobodeluxe
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If this team goes 7-5, Wilcox will be in the running for national coach of the year.
Big C
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bobodeluxe said:

If this team goes 7-5, Wilcox will be in the running for national coach of the year.

And anything less than that, he will be in the running for a top defensive coordinator job!
bluehenbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Starting JKS will delay the people whispering in his ear until late October when it appears we'll go 6-6 again. Starting Brown will start the people whispering in his ear in late August. Cal is not allowed to have two highly rated QBs at the same time.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.