Bearly Clad said:
Am I the only one who thinks Caleb Williams is a weird pick given that he never won the PAC-12 and only played in the conference for two years in very weak conference years (especially in the south division)?
I will probably be made to look a fool, but there are a handful of college QBs that the moment I saw them play, I thought they would be solid to star QBs in the NFL: Aikman (was not sold on Peete), Rodgers, Mariota, Goff, Luck, Brees, and Jim Everett (okay that one is sorta shaky). I am sure there were others but those are the college QBs I had strong reactions to.
Caleb Williams wowed me on several plays, but for some reason I am not sold on his leadership. As I said, I am sure I will look the fool here, but I don't think he is going to be the savior everyone thinks he will be. I don't think he will be a total bust, but if I was forced to bet I don't think he will ever be the top gun in the NFL. In fact, I was more impressed by Penix.