Maybe I am misreading the linked study. It seems like between vaccinated (without prior infection) and natural immunity, natural immunity was more effective. However, between natural immunity and natural immunity with vaccine, of course having both is more effective. However, this only studies infection rate, which with Delta and with waning immunity from vaccine, the effectiveness of the vaccine will wear out but the ability to fight the symptoms will continue just as strong.DiabloWags said:los altos bear said:
We have long since reached a point where any adult who wants to be vaccinated is now vaccinated.
And if you're vaccinated, you've nothing meaningful to worry about. The chance you'll get the virus from a vaccinated or unvaccinated person are minimal- and the chances you'll be hospitalized are infinitesimal.
Accordingly, and on the other hand, if you choose not to get vaccinated you're only putting yourself, and other unvaccinated people, at any meaningful risk.
There are many reasons to get vaccinated (I am)… and there are also reasons not to get vaccinated (eg you've already had Covid and now have natural immunities, or you're a young/healthy person where the vaccine might do more harm than good, etc)
So, there's no rational reason to care whether anyone else is vaccinated. And so there's no reason for government mandates.
And if you believe that we should mandate vaccines to manage down hospitalizations and health care costs, then you should also be for banning cigarettes, alcohol, ice cream, and a 25mph speed limit on all roads…
It really should be up to each individual to make the decision that is best for them. "My body, my choice" applies more - much more- in this context than in the context it's most used in…
Although I wouldn't have made the same decision, I applaud Rolovich for sticking to his guns. A selfish decision? Hardly. He's forfeited a lot of coin. It's easy to fight a fight when there are no personal costs. Far more difficult when the costs are your livelihood…
It was quite ridiculous that Rolovich was terminated. Best of luck to him and the many others who have been forced out of their jobs by overreaching authoritarians.
Sadly, your claims are terribly false on so many levels that its downright scary where you get your information. The most glaring is your ignorance regarding "breakthrough" infections with moderately to severely immunocompromised people.
And you couldnt be more wrong about Covid giving you natural immunities enough for prevention of re-infection, especially when it comes to variants like Delta; where the vaccine is much more effective. In fact, data has shown that vaccinated individuals have about half the risk of experiencing a "breakthrough" infection as do naturally immune individuals.
Comparing SARS-CoV-2 Natural Immunity to Vaccine-Induced Immunity: Reinfections versus Breakthrough Infections | NCRC (jhsph.edu)
The main reason I recommend vaccine for people who may already have had Covid is that the the strength of the natural immunity depends on how strong the symptoms were. And if the symptoms were strong enough, you probably have long Covid and you may want further immunity to avoid reinfection when you are already suffering. And if you did not have severe symptoms, you may not have great immunity. The vaccine is more controlled and therefore provides more certainty of adequate level of protection.
If we want to convince folks, we need to make sure we are really applying science and not overselling elements of the vaccine. The facts are good enough to support everyone getting a vaccine without diluting credibility.