The Non-Yogi Israel-Palestine war thread

427,859 Views | 3287 Replies | Last: 8 hrs ago by Cal88
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BearGoggles said:

tequila4kapp said:

IDF captured 3 members of Hamas' Beit Hanoun battalion in northern Gaza. The IDF posted this picture of the capture Sunday. Do they look like they are starving?




Hamas started this war and is responsible for all of the suffering. Full stop. They are counting on Palestinian suffering to influence the squishy left and Europeans. And many people on this board are up for it.




Right, you have to understand, that when Israeli snipers shoot toddlers in the head, it is because of HAMAS.



And if the fact that dozens of Gaza children have been shot in the head or chest by Israeli snipers bothers you, then you must be from "the squishy left", or even worse, a European.


Quote:

And for those of you who claim that Israel is responsible for the potential (not yet actual) famine, please tell me what other country is expected to feed the country they are at war with? Did the US feed ISIS or Syrians? Or Iraqis in Mosul? There are current war caused famines in Yemen and Sudan, yet silence here and no calls for a cease fire. The focus on only Israel is unprecedented and truly bizarre.



Israel has destroyed Gaza crops and plowed over all their fields, greenhouses, the same way they have gone out of their way to bomb nearly every hospital, school, clinic, campus building, water infrastructure and so forth. Israeli soldiers and boats shoot and sink any small fishing vessel that dares try to fish. Israeli fanatics hold up and destroy trucks of food destined to Gaza.

Almost all the food aid for Gaza being held up by Israel is from non-Israeli sources, hundreds of trucks and hundreds of tons of food aid is being held up at the Egyptian border by Israel. Your gaslighting here is not just dishonest, it is pathetic.
BearNIt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2034 said:



I'll refer you to the above post.
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BearGoggles
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Israeli snipers would not (allegedly) be shooting if not for Hamas. Full stop. The war would end if Hamas released the hostages and/or agreed to the cease fire terms supported by Egypt, Qatar, and the USA and accepted by the Israelis. Hamas is responsible for starting and now continuing this war.

The link you posted says this: "the IDF said the details of Layan and Mira's cases had been recorded and "will be examined by the competent authorities". It added: "Intentional harm to civilians, especially children, is strictly prohibited."

Has Hamas ever stated that "Intentional harm to civilians, especially children, is strictly prohibited"? We know they don't act that way, hiding behind civilians. And that is the difference - Israel's goal is not to kill civilians whereas that is Hamas' primary strategy (both as to Israeli and Palestinian citizens). Mistakes/accidents will happen in all wars. And in all armies there will always be bad actors who commit war crimes.
BearGoggles
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Not that it would dissuade you - because you don't care about the veracity of the ish you post. But this claim is highly disputed and the provenance/accuracy of the picture is unknown.

sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Israel has full military control of Gaza at this point. Hamas still exists as an entity, but that's the thing, they basically always will. They are a political party and a nebulous terrorist organization that can constantly churn through new leaders and membership. This isn't like getting Hitler or Hirohito to officially sign off on a surrender and then it's all over. If the goal is to fully stamp out Hamas, then it will go about as well as the Bush Administration's attempt to end terrorism.

Another direction is needed. If Israel wants to maintain control of the land, then they also have a responsibility to the people who live there. Just saying it's all on Hamas to feed them isn't a good enough answer.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Isn't that the stomach cancer guy who was being treated at an Israeli Hospital?
Anarchistbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
"States and cities that boycott Israeli companies will be denied grants from the Federal Emergency Management Agency, according to grant notices posted by the agency in recent days.

The new eligibility criteria could restrict access to at least $1.9 billion earmarked for search-and-rescue equipment, emergency manager salaries and backup power systems used during blackouts, Reuters reported.

To be eligible for federal funds, the grant notices say that states and cities must follow the "terms and conditions" set forth by the Department of Homeland Security, the parent agency of FEMA. Since April, D.H.S. has prohibited grantees from "limiting commercial relations specifically with Israeli companies."

Because not being loyal to Israel is un American and denies you aid from your own country .
And people still believe anti- semitism is real.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Anarchistbear said:

"States and cities that boycott Israeli companies will be denied grants from the Federal Emergency Management Agency, according to grant notices posted by the agency in recent days.

The new eligibility criteria could restrict access to at least $1.9 billion earmarked for search-and-rescue equipment, emergency manager salaries and backup power systems used during blackouts, Reuters reported.

To be eligible for federal funds, the grant notices say that states and cities must follow the "terms and conditions" set forth by the Department of Homeland Security, the parent agency of FEMA. Since April, D.H.S. has prohibited grantees from "limiting commercial relations specifically with Israeli companies."

Because not being loyal to Israel is un American and denies you aid from your own country .
And people still believe anti- semitism is real.

This is insane. Why should fealty to a foreign country be a requirement to get funds from your own government?

Serious question: what even do we get out of the Israel "alliance" anymore?
Anarchistbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tequila4kapp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:

Israel has full military control of Gaza at this point. Hamas still exists as an entity, but that's the thing, they basically always will. They are a political party and a nebulous terrorist organization that can constantly churn through new leaders and membership. This isn't like getting Hitler or Hirohito to officially sign off on a surrender and then it's all over. If the goal is to fully stamp out Hamas, then it will go about as well as the Bush Administration's attempt to end terrorism.

Another direction is needed. If Israel wants to maintain control of the land, then they also have a responsibility to the people who live there. Just saying it's all on Hamas to feed them isn't a good enough answer.

And that's probably the justification for very late breaking reports that Israel is going to fully occupy Gaza. The let the Palestinians self govern experiment in Gaza was an abject failure. I wish for a 2 state solution but this is Israel's best option for minimizing violence against it from Gaza after the war.
tequila4kapp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2034 said:

Isn't that the stomach cancer guy who was being treated at an Israeli Hospital?

Probably. Probably just as real as the "starving kids" with underlying medical conditions. Meanwhile, Hamas fighters are fit and fine because they steal the aide and allow others in Gaza starve.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tequila4kapp said:

bear2034 said:

Isn't that the stomach cancer guy who was being treated at an Israeli Hospital?

Probably. Probably just as real as the "starving kids" with underlying medical conditions. Meanwhile, Hamas fighters are fit and fine because they steal the aide and allow others in Gaza starve.

Hamas lost control of the food supply as Palestinians can get access to food aid directly from Israel rather than getting ripped off by Hamas.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bearister said:

UN says "worst-case scenario" now unfolding in Gaza....

Is this the same UN that meets together in NYC or is this the UN in Gaza that's run by Hamas and is indistinguishable from Hamas?
CaliforniaEternal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gaza had twenty years to prove it could function as an independent state and failed miserably. No amount of pandering by European counties will ever convince the Palestinians in Gaza to recognize Israel and live in peace within their own border or turn them into a functioning democracy. Ireland, Spain, France, and the UK can establish states of Palestine within their own borders with Islamists are in power and see how that works out for them. Israel is not going to sacrifice its security so loser politicians in Europe can stay in power by scapegoating Israel for all their problems.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tequila4kapp said:

sycasey said:

Israel has full military control of Gaza at this point. Hamas still exists as an entity, but that's the thing, they basically always will. They are a political party and a nebulous terrorist organization that can constantly churn through new leaders and membership. This isn't like getting Hitler or Hirohito to officially sign off on a surrender and then it's all over. If the goal is to fully stamp out Hamas, then it will go about as well as the Bush Administration's attempt to end terrorism.

Another direction is needed. If Israel wants to maintain control of the land, then they also have a responsibility to the people who live there. Just saying it's all on Hamas to feed them isn't a good enough answer.

And that's probably the justification for very late breaking reports that Israel is going to fully occupy Gaza. The let the Palestinians self govern experiment in Gaza was an abject failure. I wish for a 2 state solution but this is Israel's best option for minimizing violence against it from Gaza after the war.

And if they are going to occupy, then they have to do it humanely. Any trust the local population will have in Israel is pretty much crushed at this point, so you will probably have to overdeliver on aid.

Do I think Netanyahu can deliver on that? Not holding my breath, but here's hoping.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Since Hamas starves their own population by stealing food and aid, it should be no surprise that they starve Israeli hostages.
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
"In a first for an Israeli government, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's administration voted today to fire its attorney general, who is currently prosecuting Netanyahu for corruption, Axios' Barak Ravid reports."
Axios

Trump and Bibi are so corrupt that there is actually a level of entertainment to it.
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention

“I love Cal deeply. What are the directions to The Portal from Sproul Plaza?”
MinotStateBeav
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I want the USA to have no part of this war...this is a Palestine/Israel war as far as I'm concerned, Iran should not be supplying them either but I saw this today and it confirmed what I had always thought, never seen this before though. The reporting coming out of there is just not independent and the numbers and casualty stories are simply put out to propagate a narrative, much like Israel does.

tequila4kapp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Another example.
---
Report: Anti-Israel Photographer Stages Photographs of Hunger in Gaza

Joel B. Pollak
5 Aug 20253,125
2:45
A photographer whose work is routinely picked up by international agencies reportedly stages photographs of hunger in Gaza, emphasizing women and children and avoiding showing Palestinians receiving food, German Bild says.
The investigative article (translated via Google) reported (emphasis removed):
Quote:

The hunger is (almost always) real but the images are often not quite so. A recently widely circulated photo showed desperate people on a truck in front of a food distribution point. Opposite them: photographer Anas Zayed Fteiha, a freelance "journalist" commissioned by the Turkish news agency Anadolu.

Potential problem: The scene, captured by other photographers as well, shows mostly adult men waiting for food and getting it.

Because "journalist" Fteiha apparently has a mission: "Free Palestine." This is what it says on a bombastic painting he presents on his Instagram accountin combat gear with the proud inscription "Presse." The "artist" who created the image for Fteiha is an avowed Jew-hater.

In the Gaza Strip, almost exclusively Palestinian photographers are now taking photographs quite a few with Hamas connections. Historian and photography expert Gerhard Paul told the Sddeutsche Zeitung: "In southern Gaza, Hamas controls 100 percent of image production." The goal: to generate sympathy in the West and stir up anger against Israel.

The Israeli foreign ministry shared the article, noting that Hamas uses staged photographs, transmitted by anti-Israel freelancers and news agencies, "to manipulate global opinion."
Journalist Avi Mayer noted that while photos of "starving" Palestinian children who turned out to have other maladies were published on front pages throughout the world, only four newspapers, aside from the New York Post, initially did the same with photos of Israeli hostages being starved deliberately by Hamas and they were all Israeli outlets.

https://www.breitbart.com/middle-east/2025/08/05/report-anti-israel-photographer-stages-photographs-of-hunger-in-gaza/
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?

This almost reads like a Babylon Bee headline.
tequila4kapp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2034 said:


This almost reads like a Babylon Bee headline.

" He can no longer play football. Hezbollah is helping him find a new job. Sheri realizes it's impossible now to find a role alongside Hezbollah fighters."

The AP must be proud of this reporting.
bear2034
How long do you want to ignore this user?

More propaganda from Gaza-wood.
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MinotStateBeav said:

I want the USA to have no part of this war...this is a Palestine/Israel war as far as I'm concerned, Iran should not be supplying them either but I saw this today and it confirmed what I had always thought, never seen this before though. The reporting coming out of there is just not independent and the numbers and casualty stories are simply put out to propagate a narrative, much like Israel does.





FYI this guy, Matti Friedman, is an Israeli citizen and an IDF soldier.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matti_Friedman
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2034 said:


More propaganda from Gaza-wood.



The term you were looking for here is hasbara, or Israeli propaganda. The reason it is so easy to fool some right wingers on anything related to Israel is that this propaganda is prevalent, and dominates your information bubble.



Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?


U.S. Senator Chris Van Hollen strongly denied claims that Hamas is systematically stealing aid in Gaza, calling it "a big lie."

He emphasized that multiple international organizations, including USAID, have rejected these accusations.

Van Hollen accused the Israeli and U.S. governments of spreading this false narrative to justify using food as a weapon of war.
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I wonder why the aid hasn't been getting to Gaza?

tequila4kapp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
sycasey said:



So basically just like the US did with Japan following WW2. Except Gaza is contiguous to Israel, so it makes even more sense.
bearister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
"Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu confirmed on Thursday that Israel will proceed with its plan to occupy the entire Gaza Strip."
Axios
Cancel my subscription to the Resurrection
Send my credentials to the House of Detention

“I love Cal deeply. What are the directions to The Portal from Sproul Plaza?”
Cal88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
tequila4kapp said:

sycasey said:



So basically just like the US did with Japan following WW2. Except Gaza is contiguous to Israel, so it makes even more sense.


The plan is to colonize and ethnically cleanse Gaza, not quite post-WW2 Japan. That was the plan all along.





Quote:



Reporting on Israeli TV with actual and credible quotes from cabinet meetings on March 1, 2025, shows beyond any doubt that Israel intentionally broke the ceasefire rather than get the hostages back and end the genocide. At the time, there was a comprehensive deal on the table, which Israel did not want. Netanyahu chose to let the hostages rot.

The heads of the Israeli security services believed a deal was attainable and preferable. Ronen Bar, head of the Shin Bet said "reaching phase B is my preferred option. We can easily restart the war."

IDF negotiator Nitzan Allon said: "Our assumption that Sinwar wanted to blow up negotiations for Phase 1 was incorrect. We should learn from that."

A confidential IDF intelligence source said, "Hamas is willing to move forward if we pursue phase 2. Otherwise, they are ready to restart the fighting."

Ron Dermer said: "We are not ready to end the war while Hamas are in power. We thought the talks would explode once we entered them and that didn't happen."

Netanyahu said, "you are misleading the public that we can stop the fighting and then return to it because Trump will let us. That is ignorance!"

Mossad head Barnea disagreed and said, "for 30 days we will negotiate the second phase. At the end of that, the US will not stop us from renewing. We will get the hostages back and withdraw from Gaza."

Dermer replied: "I am not willing to see Hamas in power even for a minute. I can't live with that."

This discussion shows two things clearly. First, that Israel could have ended the war and gotten the hostages back by now. Second, that even if the hostages were returned, it would renew the fighting. This has never been about the hostages and Israel has never wanted a ceasefire. This is incontrovertible proof.





smh
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bearister said:

"Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu confirmed on Thursday that Israel will proceed with its plan to occupy the entire Gaza Strip."
Axios

..(the silent part) after killing any/all non-jewish persons already there
sycasey
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:

tequila4kapp said:

sycasey said:



So basically just like the US did with Japan following WW2. Except Gaza is contiguous to Israel, so it makes even more sense.


The plan is to colonize and ethnically cleanse Gaza, not quite post-WW2 Japan. That was the plan all along.

If Netanyahu's government takes the opportunity to set up a new economy and democratic self-governance structure for the Palestinians, I will be pleasantly surprised.

Their behavior in the West Bank does not suggest that this is the plan, though.
tequila4kapp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Cal88 said:



The plan is to colonize and ethnically cleanse Gaza, not quite post-WW2 Japan. That was the plan all along.


Again, if Israel wanted to ethnically cleanse and colonize Gaza it would have been accomplished long ago. And Israel wouldn't have 20% Palestinian population. And Israel would not have removed Israeli settlements to give Palestinians Gaza some 20 years ago.

Like all of your posts this one relies heavily on social media from entirely biased people instead of mainstream sources. The first post from X includes comments indicating the speaker - who claims to have received 2 written offers from Hamas - is not a negotiator for Israel and hasn't been for about 15-20 years. There is also commentary indicating Hamas supposed offer of "surrender" did not include disarming or leaving Gaza.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.