DiabloWags said:sycasey said:DiabloWags said:sycasey said:She won one event.Cal88 said:
Of course that article from "Science" magazine will quote activist academics who will claim that Lia Thomas has had no physiological advantages of being a biological male in crushing the NCAAW field...
Yup.
Never mind that it may have been a "down" year in the Women's 500 Free.
It was. They didn't come close to setting any new records.
And look, I can see how someone who went through male puberty and transitioned to being a woman (doing all the medical steps too) might have an unfair advantage in this sport. But the way people exaggerate how well Lia Thomas did is ridiculous. Her times are not wildly out of line with what cis women have done. It's obviously part of a broader political agenda, not borne out of legitimate concern for women's sports.
You are correct.
You can tell the people here that actually "know" something about the Sport that is being discussed... as opposed to the political "hacks" here.
Thank you for your informed input.
I'm not even an expert in women's swimming! I just went out and did a bit of research once this became a big story and found that almost everything about it had been wildly exaggerated. Just like it always is now whenever a trans person is involved.