MisterNoodle;842538542 said:
I don't read any boards but this one, so I have no basis for gauging whether it is unusual for a mod to criticize the coaches or players. Is it? His criticism at least seems reasoned.
I appreciate the comment about my criticism being reasoned.
As for it being unusual or not for a Mod to criticize coaches or players, it really depends on the board and the philosophy of the Mod staff there. On The Mesa we view ourselves as regular members who have the responsibility to keep things as civil and on topic as possible. We are big fans, long time fans (Aztec William first attended SDSU in 1960, and I went to my first Aztec game in 1970 at the age of 2 1/2) with strong opinions, and that never changed when we became the Mod staff.
On some boards the Mod staff chooses to refrain from much in the way of posting opinions or criticism. It really is different from board to board. Personally, I'd have a real problem with a Moderator who doesn't appear to care much about the topic or team. I prefer a Mod to be an open, opinionated fan of the team (or topic, depending on what the board is about). But that's just me.
And, yeah, I did go a little overboard Saturday night and Sunday morning, but the offensive showing was so bad that people in the stands were complaining about how boring the game was. It was a big game in that it was the SkyShow night (a local Classic Rock radio station hosts the event and has a HUGE fireworks display after the game, bringing in a lot of people that wouldn't otherwise come to an Aztec game), so it was important that the team look good and that the game was entertaining. When our offense had the ball the game was boring, not entertaining. They did a poor job of selling those casual fans on the team - and SDSU desperately needs a boost in attendance. Especially playing in a 70,000 seat NFL stadium. Even when we get a crowd of 40,000 the place still seems somewhat empty. And the program has been in financial deficit mode for the last 20+ years. That's a problem, too. So given all of that I vented my frustration. I attempted to do so in a reasoned, rational way, but I also did so very aggressively - which, for a Mod, can be a little unusual.
So there you go. The reason behind this thread even existing. I guess it has provided some entertainment value to someone...