Ok, still planning to write a review of the Tue/Wed games involving USMNT players and prospects, but been a little distracted with this little nationwide thing that happened yesterday, and now with the USMNT senior roster dropping for the November competitive window. Home-and-away CONCACAF Nations' League quarterfinals with Haiti, though the "away" is in Miami with its large Haitian population, since Haiti's civil war (or war between armed criminal factions) makes it impossible to have a soccer game in Port-au-Prince. Haiti is not a terrible team - they did make the World Cup, gave Scotland all they could handle, and did score 2 goals against Morocco. Overall, I like this roster a lot, though I have a few issues with it.
So the USMNT 25-man Nov. roster is organized as goalies/defenders/midfielders/forwards, but I'm going to organize it differently below for my comment, more along the lines of Pochettino's usual 4-2-3-1:
(Noting players' age, whether they are age eligible for the U-23 2028 Olympics, club and open dual-nat status)
Goalkeepers:
Matt Freese (28yo, NYCFC - MLS)
Diego Kochen (20yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Lyngby - Danish League) - Peru/Venezuela Triple-Nat but seems all US.
Brian Schwake (25yo, Nashville - MLS)
My comments: this is mostly fine with this as long as Kochen gets at least one start, and either he or Schwake start the other match. I think Schwake may be the better goal defender right now, but Kochen's quality with the ball at his feet makes him the 11th man when breaking a press, and after Mexico/Canada/Belgium's recent success with the press against the US, I see all opponents trying it until we prove we can punish them.
I would have slightly preferred not to see Freese on the list. I would have been good with sluggo's suggestion of Roman Celentano (26yo, Cincinnati - MLS) instead. Some folks are suggesting it should have been Matt Turner who is having a good season for New England in the MLS, but I'll pass.
Center Backs:
George Campbell (25yo, West Brom - EFL Championship/2nd League)
Neil Pierre (19yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Philadelphia Union - MLS), Haiti Dual-Nat
Chris Richards (26yo, Crystal Palace - EFL Premier League)
Auston Trusty (28yo, Celtic - Scottish Premier League)
No big surprise here. Richards and Trusty probably start at RCB and LCB with Richards being, not great but decent and the most proven, and Trusty being left-footed and with the next most USMNT senior team experience. Campbell has often played LCB for West Brom in a 4-2-3-1 despite being right footed, so it might work out nicely.
EXCEPT - Campbell just got injured and was subbed out at halftime of West Brom's midweek match. If Campbell can't go, and with Justin Che (22yo, Red Bull NY - MLS) also injured, the options I could see to replace him on the Nov. roster may be: Mark McKenzie (27yo, Toulouse - French Ligue 1) or Josh Wynder (21yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, New England - MLS), with Wynder being a consideration because he, like Campbell, plays at LCB quite a bit and is comfortable with his left foot. Please, please please no more Miles Robinson!!! (Actually, I think Miles Robinson is also injured).
By the way, I hope Neil Pierre gets minutes for multiple reasons, including cap-tying him against Haiti, which seems a little ironic but would work for me.
Outside Backs/Fullbacks/Wingbacks:
Reed Baker-Whiting (21yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Nashville - MLS) - first ever call-up
Alex Freeman (22yo, Villarreal - Spanish La Liga)
Bryan Reynolds (25yo, Rennes - French Ligue 1)
Antonee "Jedi" Robinson (29yo, Fulham - EFL Premier League)
(Technically Sergino Dest is listed here too and can play right wingback, but I am listing him at right wing).
Ok some eye-opening choices by Pochettino here. ARob and Freeman are no-brainers to start at left and right fullback, so no comment there. Baker-Whiting is a choice almost no one saw coming. A steady fullback who can play both sides and plays left back for Nashville who has been the best team in MLS. But is his ceiling high enough to warrant a USMNT call-up? I could see a bit more justification for Reynolds, as Rennes is a mid-table Ligue 1 team and Reynolds has shown a bit more than Baker-Whiting, but then he's also no longer close to being a prospect.
I would have gone with Tim Weah (26yo, Marseille - French Ligue 1) instead of Reynolds at backup right back. He plays in the same league as Reynolds for a comparable team, but has a better body of work and like Reynolds, has been in form. Not that I am super excited about Weah, but he seems better than Reynolds in pretty much every way, except perhaps his lack of left foot and propensity to pick up red cards...
But you know what? I can live with Reynolds as Freeman's backup. The real head-scratcher is Baker-Whiting as ARob's backup on the left. Huh? Peyton Miller (will be 19yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, New England - MLS) is younger and has a much higher upside. Sure Baker-Whiting is a better defender than Miller right now, but if that's your main concern, then have Joe Scally (23yo, Monchengladbach - German Bundesliga) back up ARob instead. Scally is actually having a good club season, albeit for a bad Bundesliga team.
Holding Midfield (defensive "6" and box-to-box "8"):
Tyler Adams (27yo, Bournemouth - EFL Premier League) - defensive "6"
Sebastian Berhalter (25yo, Middlesbrough - EFL Championship/2nd League) - box-to-box "8" (sort of)
Santiago Castaneda (will be 22yo, Paderborn - German Bundesliga) - defensive "6", Colombia Dual-Nat, first ever call-up
Adri Mehmeti (17yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Red Bull NY - MLS) - defensive "6", Albania Dual-Nat
Malik Tillman (24yo, Bayer Leverkusen for now - German Bundesliga) - box-to-box "8"
Lots to talk about here. Adams has been in form for Bournemouth and starts at the "6" despite sluggo's feelings towards him. Tillman can play attacking midfield too, but starts at the "8" despite seeming to have developed a toxic relationship with his club and their fans. He needs a transfer, but he has played well for the US when called up this year. Berhalter is more of a specialist/ball-striker/set-piece guy, so I could see McKennie or Reyna sliding back from offensive midfield to fill in at the "8" as well.
Johnny Cardoso (25yo, Atletico Madrid - Spanish La Liga) is injured AGAIN and not on the roster as Adams' backup at "6" (or could play "8" alongside Adams in a defensive lineup). So instead we get Mehmeti and Castaneda. Mehmeti has great upside with his calm ball control and incisive passing. Weirdly, it's his athleticism that needs to develop, which it still might given how young he is. Castaneda will be interesting to see - his club Paderborn is mid-table in the Bundesliga and Castaneda has been man of the match on a couple occasions for them. Folks that have watched him (not me) have not been overly impressed, but we'll see. Both Mehmeti and Castaneda would be cap-tied to the US if they play.
Pochettino seems to be pointedly passing over other holding mids such as Aidan Morris (24yo, Middlesbrough - EFL Championship/2nd league) and Tanner Tessmann (25yo, Lyons - French Ligue 1). Also Brooklyn Raines (21yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, New England - MLS) who was on the Sept/Oct friendly roster but looked lost in the buildout against Canada's press and frankly belongs down with the U-23s. But most significantly, Poch passed over another guy who was on the Sept/Oct friendly roster and has been in form for his European club: Yunus Musah (23yo, AC Milan - Italian Serie A). I might have called up Musah instead of either Berhalter, Castaneda or Mehmeti (though Mehmeti deserves a call-up at some point regardless). But I'm not super upset about this either - Musah did not play well in the Sept/Oct camp.
Offensive Midfielders ("10"s):
Weston Mckennie (28yo, Juventus - Italian Serie A)
Gio Reyna (will be 24yo, Strasbourg - French Ligue 1)
Not too much to say here - these are no-brainers when healthy. Reyna may have been the best player in the Sept/Oct friendly camp. Both he and Mckennie can play back at the "8" or out wider as a tucked-in winger, but Mckennie did suffer a knock in Juventus' last match. We'll see how serious it is and whether Poch has to replace him. Not sure with who. Others can also play the "10" like Ellis, Tillman and maybe even Sullivan so maybe replace him with a winger if needed.
Wingers:
Mathis Albert (17yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Dortmund - German Bundesliga for now, needs a loan) - left wing, France/Germany Triple-Nat though seems all US.
Sergino Dest (26yo, PSV - Dutch Eredivisie) - usually right wing
Christian Pulisic (28yo, AC Milan - Italian Serie A) - usually left wing
Cavan Sullivan (17yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Philadelphia Union - MLS) - usually right wing, Germany/Bangladesh Triple-Nat though seems all US.
There's all this drama being built in social media between Pochettino and Pulisic, but whatever. Pulisic is in form and the US needs him in form - he's one of our best players and our starting left wing. I guess Albert is his backup, though in truth, Tillman or Ellis could slide out there.
I think Sullivan should be the starting right wing with Dest as backup (or Tillman or Ellis or Mckennie sliding out). Should be fun to see Pulisic and Sullivan as bookends with Reyna in the middle of the attacking midfield.
No Zavier Gozo (19yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Crystal Palace - EFL Premier League for now, too high a level for him and he's not playing) or Cole Campbell (20yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Elversberg - German Bundesliga), which is the right call, in my opinion. Both belong down with the U-23s right now.
Strikers ("9"):
Folarin Balogun (25yo, Monaco - French Ligue 1 for now)
Justin Ellis (19yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Orlando - MLS) - Uruguay Dual-Nat
Julian Hall (18yo, Olympic U-23 eligible, Red Bull NY - MLS) - Poland Dual-Nat
Balogun is the starter. Ellis and Hall are very different players, with Hall being more of a poacher like the missing Ricardo Pepi (23yo, PSV - Dutch Eredivisie) who is playing for his club but just returned from injury. So maybe that's why he was skipped? I'm not too mad because I want to see more of both Ellis and Hall. Ellis can also play offensive midfield/winger with his great ball control and passing. Hall can too, but is really best as a poaching, goal-hungry "9".
And of course Balogun is the best US striker. He's in a weird situation with his club, Monaco, after rejecting a transfer to Everton, which I am bummed he did. Balogun would have been good with Everton, I think, but I'm sure he had his reasons. Regardless, he needs a transfer in January - maybe to join Mckennie at Juventus, who need a good striker!
Olympic U-23 Camp:
There is a simultaneous Olympic U-23 camp going on in Spain, so here are some players who should be on that roster, some of whom are mentioned above:
Goalkeepers: Honestly no clue... Diego Kochen is eligible and would be the obvious choice but we need him on the senior USMNT team. So maybe Julian Eyestone (20yo, Rotherham - EFL League 2/4th League), Duran Ferree (20yo, 3rd string for San Diego - MLS) or Andrew Rick (20yo, 3rd string for Philadelphia Union - MLS)?Really scraping the bottom of the barrel. US is in deep, deep trouble at goalkeeper if Kochen does not pan out.
Center Backs: With Neil Pierre on the senior USMNT, I'll go with the New England Revs duo Josh Wynder (21yo, New England - MLS) and Ethan Kohler (21yo, New England - MLS). Or maybe Stuart Hawkins (20yo, Seattle - MLS). Like with goalie, scraping the bottom of the barrel. US also in trouble at center back if Pierre does not pan out. I guess Justin Che is another young center back too, though a little too old to be Olympic eligible and is currently injured for Red Bull NY.
Outside Backs/Fullbacks/Wingbacks: Peyton Miller (will be 19yo, New England - MLS) maybe should have been with the senior team but is a no-brainer at left back for the Olympic U-23 team since he is not (if Miller replaced Reed Baker-Whiting on the senior team roster, then Baker-Whiting would be in this list). Frankie Westfield (20yo, Philadelphia Union - MLS) may be the Olympic starting right back. Or perhaps Luca Bombino (20yo, Stoke City - EFL Championship/2nd League) or Harbor Miller (19yo, LA Galaxy - MLS)
Holding Midfielders ("6" and "8"): Adri Mehmeti would have been an obvious choice here were he not on the USMNT senior team, as would Santiago Castaneda (except he is 2 months too old to qualify for Olympic U-23). So instead probably Brooklyn Raines (21yo, New England - MLS) at the "6" and either Nico Tsakiris (21yo, San Jose - MLS) or Taha Habroune (20yo, Columbus Crew - MLS) at the "8". Tsakiris and Habroune could also play a "10" (attacking midfield) and Habroune is a Dual-Nat who may play for Morocco. Could throw in Matthew Corcoran (20yo, Nashville - MLS), Cooper Sanchez (18yo, Atlanta - MLS) or Snyder Brunell (19yo, Seattle Sounders - MLS).
Attacking Midfielders ("10"): Obviously Cavan Sullivan has moved past this level and is mostly playing wing anyway. Tsakiris (above) can play here instead of holding mid. Maybe that is what should happen since I am at a loss as to who to put here that is eligible. Probably a spot where we'll want to use one of our 3 over-age allowances for the actual Olympics. Couple longshots could be could be U-20s Xanti Oyharcabal (19yo, CD Basconia - Secunda Federacion - Spanish 4th division).
Wingers: Mathis Albert/Cavan Sullivan are with the senior team, so we've got Zavier Gozo (19yo, Crystal Palace - EFL Premier League for now) and Cole Campbell (20yo, Elversberg - German Bundesliga). Would be fun to throw in U-20 Gabriel Wesseh (18yo, Fredrikstad - Norwegian League) to see what he can do. Some of the outside backs listed above can also play winger - e.g. Peyton Miller at left wing.
Strikers: oof, scraping the bottom of the barrel here too like at Center Back and Goalie with Justin Ellis and Julian Hall on the senior squad. Or a better way to put it might be - the only choices are too young. Maybe U-17 Malik Jakupovic (17yo, Philadelphia Union - MLS). I know sluggo is a fan of U-20 Tomo Allen (19yo, San Jose Earthquakes MLSNextPro). Another spot where maybe we use an overage player at the actual Olympics, or have one of Justin Ellis or Julian Hall play down here, with Ricardo Pepi filling in for the senior squad.