movielover said:
DiabloWags said:
sycasey said:
The employment rate is high. There are jobs there for the taking. It makes sense to bring in more people to do them. Given that our birth rate is also declining as tends to happen in any wealthy nation, it is also in our national interest to do so.
For the illegals and visa holders, we should give them a quick path to citizenship so they can actually live as full citizens and not remain in the shadows. They will also be a net gain for our economy, in the long run.
If these fundamentals change at some point in the future, we can change the laws to be more restrictive again.
Correct.
They make money.
They buy homes, furniture, clothes, cars, spend money on vacations, travel, restaurants, remodels, etc., and pay taxes like everyone else. Anyone who isnt pro job growth and expanding the SUPPLY OF LABOR in a country filled with old people (that dont spend any money) and a birth rate at zero is an ignorant fool.
Many don't pay taxes. I believe the Heritage Foundation estimated the average illegal immigrant costs us $400,000, and that was 10 years ago.
Unsurprisingly, your memory fails you. Undocumented immigrants do pay taxes like sales and use tax, property taxes, license and registration fees and even social security and other payroll taxes and don't always get the benefits they pay into. Contrast that with wealthy people - like Trump - who really don't pay taxes and sometimes get millions more back than they even paid in. I don't recall you being outraged by Trump pilfering the US treasury for his personal gain over decades. Or any other massive tax avoidance by the wealthy.
The real takeaway from that
research is that we run a much larger fiscal deficit from citizen households without high school degrees than we do from undocumented immigrant households. Maybe we should deport high school dropouts from West Virginia and other ****hole states since on average they cost taxpayers $35k per year whereas undocumented immigrant households only cost $14k per year.
I will give them credit for one thing - they got this right.
Quote:
Many conservatives believe that if an individual has a job and works hard, he will inevitably be a net tax contributor (paying more in taxes than he takes in benefits). In our society, this has not been true for a very long time.
Rank and file conservatives are naive and buy into the idea that education is overrated and good old fashioned work can still pay the bills.
The whole paper was pretty much garbage, like most heritage foundation work, and is really just agitprop for wealthy conservatives looking to take away entitlements and keep more of their money, even though bit was produced through the same economy that relies on foreign unskilled labor. It's a shallow analysis and doesn't take into account the benefits we receive from the labor participation that otherwise we wouldn't be able to find and would hamper our economy. With the hardline immigration stance we had the last few years, combined with COVID, we saw a significant reduction in the supply of unskilled labor which our economy still hasn't recovered from. Didn't see any discussion by heritage about labor force composition and the benefits of having enough unskilled labor to do the dirty work that lazy Americans simply won't do.