I don't condone this but the video also doesn't show any punching at all.
ICE
39,043 Views |
940 Replies |
Last: 24 min ago by Aunburdened
Minnesota: "We refuse to work with federal law enforcement in any capacity."
— Tony Kinnett (@TheTonus) January 8, 2026
Minnesota: "Why isn't federal law enforcement letting us be a part of their investigations?!"
Make it make sense
Another cool story.
"Cults don't end well. They really don't."
Cal88 said:ICE detain Native American—punch him repeatedly even after complying with face scan.
— LongTime🤓FirstTime👨💻 (@LongTimeHistory) January 9, 2026
Mother brought passport & birth certificate but agents didn't care—just joked that he "wasn’t really from here."
"Police can you help us?" she begs officers just watching. "We're citizens!"… pic.twitter.com/pPnTGUeA0c
Why is the video edited? It stops and starts a few times.
So if she had time to reverse she also had time to brake and not hit the officer.
Nothing about this story is cool bro. It sucks all the way around. Really wish she would have thought about her children before putting herself in the position and making choices that led up to her being shot and killed.
Nothing about this story is cool bro. It sucks all the way around. Really wish she would have thought about her children before putting herself in the position and making choices that led up to her being shot and killed.
BearlySane88 said:
So if she had time to reverse she also had time to brake and not hit the officer.
Nothing about this story is cool bro. It sucks all the way around. Really wish she would have thought about her children before putting herself in the position and making choices that led up to her being shot and killed.
You could say that about a number of people.
Ashli Babbit comes to mind. But Trumper's here called that MURDER.
Hypocrites.
"Cults don't end well. They really don't."
DiabloWags said:BearlySane88 said:
So if she had time to reverse she also had time to brake and not hit the officer.
Nothing about this story is cool bro. It sucks all the way around. Really wish she would have thought about her children before putting herself in the position and making choices that led up to her being shot and killed.
You could say that about a number of people.
Ashli Babbit comes to mind. But Trumper's here called that MURDER.
Hypocrites.
The wagging TDS hypocrites blame the ICE officer for this agitator's death yet blame Ashley Babbit for being shot.
DiabloWags said:BearlySane88 said:
So if she had time to reverse she also had time to brake and not hit the officer.
Nothing about this story is cool bro. It sucks all the way around. Really wish she would have thought about her children before putting herself in the position and making choices that led up to her being shot and killed.
You could say that about a number of people.
Ashli Babbit comes to mind. But Trumper's here called that MURDER.
Hypocrites.
Not me. I've already said this numerous times in this thread.
Both deaths shouldn't have happened. Both were caused by actions of the individual. You can't have one be okay and the other not okay.
BearlySane88 said:DiabloWags said:BearlySane88 said:
So if she had time to reverse she also had time to brake and not hit the officer.
Nothing about this story is cool bro. It sucks all the way around. Really wish she would have thought about her children before putting herself in the position and making choices that led up to her being shot and killed.
You could say that about a number of people.
Ashli Babbit comes to mind. But Trumper's here called that MURDER.
Hypocrites.
Not me. I've already said this numerous times in this thread.
Both deaths shouldn't have happened. Both were caused by actions of the individual. You can't have one be okay and the other not okay.
+1000
Agreed but both cases represent an abuse of police/state power resulting in murder.
BearlySane88 said:*Charlie Kirk gets assassinated over free speech*
— Jack (@jackunheard) January 8, 2026
The left: “It’s his fault. He deserved it.”
*Woman attempts to murder ICE agents and gets killed*
The left: “It’s not her fault! She didn’t deserve it.”
Do you get it yet?
So you guys are just going to run with this "she tried to murder the ICE officer" nonsense for good now, huh?
sycasey said:BearlySane88 said:*Charlie Kirk gets assassinated over free speech*
— Jack (@jackunheard) January 8, 2026
The left: “It’s his fault. He deserved it.”
*Woman attempts to murder ICE agents and gets killed*
The left: “It’s not her fault! She didn’t deserve it.”
Do you get it yet?
So you guys are just going to run with this "she tried to murder the ICE officer" nonsense for good now, huh?
You are replying to a post that one poster made that has zero stars and attributing it to "You guys." Only one guy posted this tweet. With that being said, there are a ton of exaggerations on both sides of this argument. It is like folks are watching two different videos. For what it is worth, her actions were reckless and dangerous. I don't believe she intentionally tried to hit the officer. I do, however, understand why the officer thought that when the car was about to hit him.
Cal88 said:
Agreed but both cases represent an abuse of police/state power resulting in murder.
Still trying to understand how the actions against Babbitt are equivalent to this. One person was trying to break in to the Capitol Building and another was trying to drive away from ICE agents.
Yes, basically, the lives of protestors engaged in protests you don't agree with are cheaper.
Cal88 said:
Yes, basically, the lives of protestors engaged in protests you don't agree with are cheaper.
What? No, one of them was engaged in a far more aggressive action than the other.
That's where we disagree
Well she drove at an officer so yes. At least assault with a deadly weapon
Babbitt was an unarmed woman engaged in trespassing. Good was driving an SUV in the middle of an ICE operation, though I agree that she was leaving the scene.
In both cases, their lives were cheap.
In both cases, their lives were cheap.
sycasey said:Cal88 said:
Yes, basically, the lives of protestors engaged in protests you don't agree with are cheaper.
What? No, one of them was engaged in a far more aggressive action than the other.
You're welcome to that opinion but I firmly disagree. One was using a deadly weapon, the other was breaking and entering.
BearlySane88 said:
Well she drove at an officer so yes. At least assault with a deadly weapon
She drove away from an officer.
She hit him. Hardly away…
New video of the incident:
It's pretty distant so doesn't add much clarity other than it shows Good had been stopped there for 3 or 4 minutes before the ICE agents arrived and that other cars had passed by her in the meantime. Unclear why she stopped there. Did she know that ICE would be coming down that street several minutes before they did?
NEW: CNN has obtained a new angle of the incident involving Renee Good in Minneapolis, shows Good's vehicle sitting sideways in the street for three minutes before shots were fired.
— Collin Rugg (@CollinRugg) January 9, 2026
The footage shows a person exiting the car on the passenger side.
"[Video] shows Renee Good's… pic.twitter.com/jdV0YBwI3A
It's pretty distant so doesn't add much clarity other than it shows Good had been stopped there for 3 or 4 minutes before the ICE agents arrived and that other cars had passed by her in the meantime. Unclear why she stopped there. Did she know that ICE would be coming down that street several minutes before they did?
BearlySane88 said:
She hit him. Hardly away…
She didn't. I can see why he might have thought she was going to.
She stopped there to impede ice after letting her wife out to film it . Come on now…
Yes she knew because she had been following ICE around all morning according to reports and eye witnesses statements
Yes she knew because she had been following ICE around all morning according to reports and eye witnesses statements
Even if you're right, which I disagree that you are, then your statement justified the use of lethal force. Thank you
Driving towards an officer with your vehicle is grounds for the use of lethal force. You'd like the officers to get hit first?
Driving towards an officer with your vehicle is grounds for the use of lethal force. You'd like the officers to get hit first?
BearlySane88 said:
Even if you're right, which I disagree that you are, then your statement justified the use of lethal force. Thank you
Driving towards an officer with your vehicle is grounds for the use of lethal force. You'd like the officers to get hit first?
There is other context, like the officers escalating the situation by trying to force her out of the car and one of them wrongly placing himself in front of the vehicle. But yes, in a vacuum if an officer thinks he will be run over then force may be justified.
BearlySane88 said:
She stopped there to impede ice after letting her wife out to film it . Come on now…
Yes she knew because she had been following ICE around all morning according to reports and eye witnesses statements
I've only seen one "witness" who is mostly talking about "what she heard." Are there any other witnesses to this?
This is possible! But IMO not a lot of evidence for it yet.
sycasey said:BearlySane88 said:
She stopped there to impede ice after letting her wife out to film it . Come on now…
Yes she knew because she had been following ICE around all morning according to reports and eye witnesses statements
I've only seen one "witness" who is mostly talking about "what she heard." Are there any other witnesses to this?
This is possible! But IMO not a lot of evidence for it yet.
You're right, I should have said eye witness not witnesses. There's the video of the woman talking after the event, I think it's been posted here already. She says it was clear the woman was trying to impede ICE by blocking the road
sycasey said:BearlySane88 said:
Even if you're right, which I disagree that you are, then your statement justified the use of lethal force. Thank you
Driving towards an officer with your vehicle is grounds for the use of lethal force. You'd like the officers to get hit first?
There is other context, like the officers escalating the situation by trying to force her out of the car and one of them wrongly placing himself in front of the vehicle. But yes, in a vacuum if an officer thinks he will be run over then force may be justified.
What about the context that she was disobeying legal orders to get out of her car?
I'm not claiming everything was done well by the officers. Could this have been prevented, yes. Should it have been presented, yes. My only argument this whole time has been that the shooting was lawful. Tragic and terrible, but lawful
BearlySane88 said:sycasey said:BearlySane88 said:
She stopped there to impede ice after letting her wife out to film it . Come on now…
Yes she knew because she had been following ICE around all morning according to reports and eye witnesses statements
I've only seen one "witness" who is mostly talking about "what she heard." Are there any other witnesses to this?
This is possible! But IMO not a lot of evidence for it yet.
You're right, I should have said eye witness not witnesses. There's the video of the woman talking after the event, I think it's been posted here already. She says it was clear the woman was trying to impede ICE by blocking the road
Yes, and that woman was not an "eye witness" to Good having followed ICE around all morning. Just the shooting incident itself. The rest is her supposition based on things she heard. Again, could be true but this isn't great evidence of that.
BearlySane88 said:sycasey said:BearlySane88 said:
Even if you're right, which I disagree that you are, then your statement justified the use of lethal force. Thank you
Driving towards an officer with your vehicle is grounds for the use of lethal force. You'd like the officers to get hit first?
There is other context, like the officers escalating the situation by trying to force her out of the car and one of them wrongly placing himself in front of the vehicle. But yes, in a vacuum if an officer thinks he will be run over then force may be justified.
What about the context that she was disobeying legal orders to get out of her car?
I'm not claiming everything was done well by the officers. Could this have been prevented, yes. Should it have been presented, yes. My only argument this whole time has been that the shooting was lawful. Tragic and terrible, but lawful
I do not expect the ICE officers to get convicted of anything here. Lawful does not necessarily mean right.
UCLA law school grad SWC:
“Assault” is not the same as “battery.”
— Shipwreckedcrew (@shipwreckedcrew) January 9, 2026
Battery requires contact.
Assault requires a threat and an apparent intention to carry it out in a manner that causes fear or apprehension.
It is a federal crime to “assault” a federal law enforcement officer.
No contact is required.…
For every stupid scenario the liberal progs dream up here to undermine the legality of the Officer's action, simply put a gun in the Karen's hand rather than a car and ask if the answer to the question would be the same.
— Shipwreckedcrew (@shipwreckedcrew) January 9, 2026
Just so there is no confusion.
— Shipwreckedcrew (@shipwreckedcrew) January 9, 2026
Two prosecution options:
1. DOJ files in federal court under federal statute using Minneapolis based federal grand jury. ICE Agent could hire counsel or have counsel appointed.
2. Hennepin County DA or Minnesota AG file in state court. ICE…
movielover said:
ICE agent's body cam.
https://www.facebook.com/reel/826109317073638/?mibextid=CDWPTG
Thoughts on this:
1. Shows that Good's wife, at least, was not a big fan of ICE. I'm not shocked if these people are protestors or "observers" or whatever.
2. Doesn't actually show the car hitting him, so don't try to tell me it does. All this shows is that he moved back (or was moved) once the car started moving. We don't see the car hit him in the video.
3. Does show that the ICE agent moved in front of the car before it started moving, which he probably shouldn't have done.
Featured Stories
See All
New Phone Plan Created Specifically For Cal Fans
by Cal Athletics
Cal Defense Stifles Wake Forest
by Cal Athletics
Northern Arizona Safety Michael Hurst Jr Commits to Cal
by Jim McGill
Bears Snag Mississippi State OT Jimothy Lewis
by Jim McGill
Cal Comes Up Just Short In 78-75 Loss At Virginia Tech
by Cal Athletics