B.A. Bearacus said:
dimitrig said:
B.A. Bearacus said:
I don't really find these sorts of posts helpful.
How do we even know who "her friend" is or if she is even a real person herself?
I don't want to minimize the threat, because my employer is now making me telecommute starting Tuesday, but we do need to put things into perspective.
I had a conversation tonight with my neighbor who is a physician (neurologist) who used to work for a lab researching coronaviruses 20 years ago before going into private practice. He said: "I know just about everything there is to know about coronaviruses and the immune response to them." His research focused on the potential link between coronaviruses and autoimmune diseases such as MS. Since then, obviously, he is no longer at the forefront of research, but he is still following the literature (and the news) closely.
He is keeping his practice open next week in part because his patients need him and in part because his employees need to get paid. His advice to me is the simple advice we have all been given, which is to wash your hands frequently, cover your mouth when you cough, avoid large crowds, and stay home if you feel ill. He said that all of this advice about staying locked inside and not going out in public is based on hysteria and posts like the above just feed that hysteria. He and his wife then went out to dinner together.
It was nice knowing him!
Glasser is a legit reporter for the New Yorker (check), the other person has a verified Twitter account and looking at her bio seems like she would have a lot to lose professionally by introducing a hoax tweet exchange (good enough, check).
Does your friend have Google set up in a way that any news story with the word "Italy" is excluded from results?
To be honest, his main concern was not First World countries like the US, China, or Italy but rather Third World nations which might be really ravaged by this because they won't have access to the information and the health care we have. That could then lead to a second or third wave in this nation - perhaps worse than the first - once everyone has let their guard down.
He said it was in our best interests to make sure that everyone is tested and that treatments (and a vaccine once we have one, which we will) are made widely available across the world. To say he is disappointed with the government's response is an understatement. However, hoarding toilet paper and canned goods isn't going to solve any problems. Be sensible, not hysterical. I went to two grocery stores today that had no fresh chicken. It was all sold out. They had beef, but not chicken. I don't think the media is helping and neither are all of our public institutions which are shutting down in response. That just fans the flames of the hysteria.
That is not to say that tens of thousand of people in the US won't die from it. They will. The percentage of healthy adults (and children) under 50 who will die from it is likely to be extremely small.
Here is the data from China:
Edit: Estimates are that 4M Americans will be infected by May. If about 1% of them die (10 times the regular rate of the common flu, which seems reasonable as mortality rates will decrease as testing increases) that means 40,000 deaths. That is about the same as a bad "regular" flu season and yet people don't go batshizznit crazy every flu season. The press likes to repeat things like: "Every hospital bed will be filled by May" or "There won't be enough ventilators" (which are both probably true and what the ER doctor quoted was alluding to) but those sorts of statements are meant to garner headlines. All they do is illicit panic. People are hyperaware. People are taking precautions. That's good. Scaring people for ratings isn't.