sycasey said:I think there is a line on what should be encouraged and what shouldn't (Biden himself spoke to this today):calbear93 said:At a certain point, the left has to stop treating these left wing, pretend "liberals" (don't think they even understand liberalism) yelling hate speech and committing violence / hostile takeover of private property as some participant in free speech. These "brave" social justice warriors courageously hiding behind masks, whining about police brutality as they commit violence, and making racists / antisemitic statements completely empties any moral arguments anyone supporting these idiots may make in the future. Felt the same way about idiots treating rioters as protesters and completely bringing shame to the legitimate protesters participating in free speech. Two things can be wrong. I can be against 1/6th insurrectionists and these criminals.sycasey said:I wonder if the Berkeley admin has learned some lessons from other protests in recent years.ducky23 said:Big C said:dajo9 said:This is true.sycasey said:
The history of these Columbia protests has been a long series of overreactions, one after another. In that I include the school, the mayor, the police, the protesters themselves, and the media.
I hadn't heard anything in the news about protests at Cal so I googled it and it seems the protesters are there but the admin is basically letting them have their free speech but not really responding. No confrontation means no media. The hotheads on both sides want confrontation so I applaud the Cal admin. I'm sure eventually a hothead on one side or the other will force the issue but for now free speech is happening and nobody seems to be overreacting (for now).
Exactly. One pundit recently cited "Berkeley" as one of the schools doing it right (by not escalating).
The protests are largely well-intentioned. if perhaps a bit ignorant on the historical perspective. Listen to what they have to say and let them have their moment. Draw the line at antisemitism, vandalism and disruption of campus functions. Must show student ID after sundown.
Is anyone else pleasantly surprised (or even shocked really) that every other school seems to be in the news (for the wrong reasons) except us? This is usually the time we **** the bed.
But look at us. Admin is handling this correctly and more importantly our student protestors are handling this correctly. As Big C astutely stated, go protest all you want, but draw the line at anti semitism, vandalism, violence and segregation. If you want to actually move public opinion, there's a right way and wrong way of doing so. What's happening at UCLA isn't doing anything for the cause.
So hooray for Berkeley. While the rest of the elite universities are embroiled in conflict and controversy, we're just chilling and signing top 5 portal classes.
If protests don't involve violence or preventing others from going about their business, that's protected free speech. Once you do that other stuff, it's no longer protected. The behavior at UCLA clearly went over that line IMO. At Cal (at least so far), doesn't seem like it.
Last night’s rampage by pro-Israel mob makes it clear—since the encampments were completely non-violent, the new strategy is to *make them violent*
— Wyatt Reed (@wyattreed13) May 1, 2024
Turning protests into riots lets media blame both sides and gives authorities an excuse to shut them down:
pic.twitter.com/sgJbMDJcea
Look how patient they are with outside Zionist agitators spraying chemicals on their belongings https://t.co/keOOX2KRS1
— Max Blumenthal (@MaxBlumenthal) May 1, 2024
In 2020 we saw mass hysteria of well educated people seeing racism in everything — chess, drinking milk, the ok hand sign, punctuality. This year in 2024 it’s the exact same if not worse with people fabricating antisemitism en masse in order to shut down criticism of Israel.
— Lee Fang (@lhfang) May 1, 2024
Pro-🇮🇱 man sаvagely hitting students in LA
— What the media hides. (@narrative_hole) May 1, 2024
Zero repercussions or condemnation pic.twitter.com/TmdvAKYtfk